Johnson's promised Brexit border in Irish Sea 'will not be ready in time'

Influential thinktank warns that UK will need to extend transition period in wake of coronavirus or risk very hard border

A new Brexit border in the Irish Sea will not be ready by Boris Johnson’s end-of-year deadline, according to a new analysis that warns more than 60 administrations, government departments and public bodies will be involved in overseeing the new system.

Ministers finally admitted last week that there would be some checks on certain goods entering Northern Ireland from the rest of the UK from next January, when the Brexit transition period comes to an end.

Johnson and others have also refused to consider extending the transition period, despite having no agreement between the EU and Britain over the practical treatment of Northern Ireland and little prospect of a trade deal being in place by the start of 2021.

However, in its most forthright intervention to date, the influential thinktank Institute for Government (IfG) said the transition period must be extended or a longer implementation period agreed for the new border arrangements in the Irish Sea. It warns that many businesses are simply focused on “staying afloat” during the coronavirus crisis and cannot be expected to concentrate on new trade arrangements – and suggests the government is underestimating the complexity of the new Northern Ireland arrangements.

“The UK and the EU should extend the transition period or agree to a separate longer implementation period for the withdrawal agreement,” the institute warns in a new report. “The timetable for putting arrangements in place for the Irish Sea border was very tight even before Covid-19 hit Europe. But now coronavirus has slowed the pace of negotiations on the future relationship, delaying key decisions.

“Key businesses such as freight transport associations and trading associations are focused on maintaining supply chains rather than getting ready for new border arrangements, and many businesses are focusing on staying afloat, not complying with new regulatory requirements. Against the background of a global pandemic, it is very difficult to see how preparations to implement the protocol can be completed before the end of the year – given the scale of both the decisions and practical work still required.”

New arrangements dealing with goods flowing from Great Britain to Northern Ireland are needed as part of the so-called Northern Ireland protocol, hammered out by Johnson and the EU in January to avoid a hard border on the island of Ireland. A failure to implement it by the end of December would instead lead to the implementation of a very hard border in the Irish Sea.

The IfG’s stark warning comes after Michael Gove, the cabinet office minister, said last week that checks on goods heading from great Britain to Northern Ireland would be needed to maintain “disease-free status” on the island of Ireland, with border inspection posts for agrifood. It contradicted Johnson’s repeated vow that there would be no checks.

The IfG, however, suggests that more sweeping changes will be needed than those admitted by Gove. “The protocol creates a customs and regulatory border in the Irish Sea, which the UK will be legally obliged to administer under supervision from EU institutions,” it states. “Northern Ireland will remain part of the UK customs territory but will be required to align with EU rules on customs and regulations.

“The UK government must recognise the scale of the implementation task and make it a government priority even in these difficult times. The UK needs to scale up existing systems for customs administration, design and implement new systems for tariff administration and compensation and develop new capacity for regulatory checks.

“With UK ministers only recently publicly stating what additional processes may be needed, progress so far has been slow. With 64 departments, public bodies and agencies across the UK with scope for involvement in the implementation of the protocol, clarity on what is required is key.”

Its analysis also warns that the protocol arrangements will be voted on by the Northern Ireland assembly every four to eight years, making it a “potentially destabilising issue” for years to come.


Michael Savage

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Irish warn Theresa May: change course or risk Brexit chaos
Single market pledge would solve EU border crisis, says Phil Hogan, European commissioner for agriculture

Michael Savage and Toby Helm

25, Nov, 2017 @10:00 PM

Article image
EU’s vaccine blunder reopens Brexit battle over Irish border
Tory MPs use short-lived announcement of export ban to call for overhaul of trade deal, as EU chief is attacked over U-turn

Michael Savage and Daniel Boffey

30, Jan, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Brexit puts special rights for Irish citizens in UK ‘at risk’
‘Patchwork’ laws threaten ability to live and work in Britain, says report

Ben Quinn and Jamie Doward

03, Dec, 2017 @9:44 AM

Article image
The Northern Ireland protocol is said to be a blight on regional economy. That’s just not true
After an initial shock to businesses, manufacturing jobs are growing four times faster here than the UK average

Rory Carroll

15, May, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
‘Brits are suffering but for us it’s boom time’: how Brexit boosted French and Irish ports
The cheapest way from Ireland to Europe used to be via Dover. But now Cherbourg and Rosslare are thriving

Jon Henley in Cherbourg and Rory Carroll in Rosslare

25, Feb, 2023 @1:24 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson's plans for Irish border checks threaten Brexit talks
Downing Street banks on secretive ‘tunnel’ negotiations to hammer out agreement

Daniel Boffey and Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

01, Oct, 2019 @10:13 PM

Article image
Northern Ireland peace at risk because of Brexit, says Bertie Ahern
Irish leader who helped secure Good Friday agreement says he fears the consequences of a border dividing north and south

Patrick Maguire and Daniel Boffey

11, Feb, 2017 @10:00 PM

Article image
Irish republican says violence is counter-productive
Killings turn people away from cause, says former hardline leader Des Dalton

Henry McDonald

08, Mar, 2021 @2:07 PM

Article image
Brexit bust-up torpedoes Johnson’s bid to showcase ‘global Britain’ at G7
Northern Ireland border row hits G7 summit in Cornwall as prime minister tells other leaders UK is ‘a single country’

Heather Stewart & Toby Helm

12, Jun, 2021 @7:10 PM

Article image
‘Mistrusted’ Johnson feels full force of EU fury as Brexit wrecks G7 summit
European leaders made their feelings about the Northern Ireland protocol known to a PM desperate to score a PR victory

Toby Helm & Heather Stewart

13, Jun, 2021 @5:30 AM