London congestion charge rise down to good old power struggle

Forget health or economic concerns - this is a classic political fight between a Labour mayor and a Tory government

Good old-fashioned politics rather than economic, environmental or health considerations seem to explain the decision by Transport for London to reimpose the congestion charge from Monday, hike it by 30% next month, and to also restrict free travel for the young, the elderly and the disabled.

Put simply, a power struggle is taking place between London’s Labour mayor and TfL on one side of the table and a Conservative government on the other.

The row is about the size and the strings attached to a government bailout needed because of the massive drop in numbers using public transport in the capital. Stuck in the middle are the citizens of the capital, many of whom are already struggling to make ends meet.

The congestion charge was originally introduced to make London’s traffic flow more freely and the air cleaner. It was suspended at the start of the lockdown in the hope that car travel would help keep the capital ticking over, especially by making it easier for key workers, including nurses, to drive to work.

In recent days the government has urged workers to use cars to travel wherever possible, because it is currently safer than public transport. It is also encouraging cycling and walking. The mayor also wants Londoners to stay away from public transport. He wants them to walk, cycle, or stay at home, but not use cars.

TfL says its cash crisis means it has no choice but to reintroduce the congestion charge from Monday and to raise it from £11.50 a day to £15 next month. Older and dirtier vehicles will also have to pay the Ulez (ultra-low emission zone) charge of £12.50 a day, which has also been suspended in lockdown.

The basic laws of economics suggest that whacking up the congestion charge provides an incentive to find other ways of getting around.

But the continuing need for social distancing means there isn’t the capacity on the tubes and buses to take more than a fraction of London’s usual workforce.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

The second option is to follow the example of cities such as Amsterdam, where people cycle and walk more than they do in London. Amsterdam, though, has a population a tenth the size of London. It is often not feasible for low-paid workers, forced to live in the less expensive outer boroughs of London, to get to work on their bikes (even assuming they have one).

The third option is to suck it up and pay the higher congestion charge. But many of London’s workers – the builders, shopworkers, delivery drivers, plumbers, midwives and security guards – are not highly paid.

For them, the stand off between City Hall and Westminster means putting their health at risk or seeing a bigger slice taken out of their already low incomes.


Larry Elliott

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Why the row over congestion charge expansion could tear London apart
No 10 and the mayor are at loggerheads over how to fill a hole in the capital’s transport budget. But is it a £2bn game of bluff?

Gwyn Topham

24, Oct, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
TfL to raise congestion charge by 30% as part of £1.6bn bailout deal
Deal to keep ‘tubes and buses running’ also affects free travel for children and the over-60s

Mark Sweney

15, May, 2020 @1:39 PM

Article image
London gridlock at pre-congestion charge levels

Mayor announces new measures to tackle tailbacks as TfL says capital's streets as congested as in 2002

Dan Milmo, transport correspondent

06, Aug, 2008 @10:02 AM

Article image
Petition calls for key workers to be exempt from London congestion charge
No one should be financially penalised for working to keep people safe, say critics

Matthew Weaver

20, May, 2020 @9:29 AM

Article image
London road congestion: causes, effects and what happens next
How will Transport for London and the new mayor’s transport deputy address the heavy pressures on the capital’s road space and the strong passions they arouse?

Dave Hill

15, Jun, 2016 @6:46 AM

Article image
London to introduce £10 vehicle pollution charge, says Sadiq Khan
Mayor says owners of more polluting cars will have to pay extra levy from October to drive within congestion charge zone

Rowena Mason Deputy political editor

17, Feb, 2017 @10:43 AM

Article image
London transport fares will rise, says minister, as TfL secures bailout
After mayor’s ultimatum, Grant Shapps says non-Londoners should not ‘carry burden’

Jasper Jolly and Peter Walker

14, May, 2020 @5:55 PM

Article image
Tfl to add 500 e-bikes to Santander cycle-hire scheme as costs rise
E-bikes will cost £3.30 for 30 mins – double new rate for an ordinary Santander cycle hire

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

12, Aug, 2022 @11:38 AM

Article image
Uber apologises after London ban and admits 'we got things wrong'
London mayor Sadiq Khan says he welcomes apology by CEO of ride-hailing app, which has been stripped of its licence

Julia Kollewe and Gwyn Topham

25, Sep, 2017 @1:11 PM

Article image
Ulez to be expanded across whole of Greater London from August
Mayor says ultra-low emission zone has been ‘transformational’ and expansion will benefit 5m more people

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

25, Nov, 2022 @12:42 PM