US message to Britain in bilateral trade talks: it's us – or China

Proposed clause viewed by diplomats as lever to deter closer UK relations with Beijing

The US government has been privately pressing the UK in bilateral trade talks to make a choice between the US and China.

The US is seeking to insert a clause that would allow it to retreat from parts of the deal if Britain reaches a trade agreement with another country that the US did not approve.

The proposed clause made no mention specifically of China, but is seen by British diplomats in Washington as intended to be a lever to deter closer UK-China relations.

It had been seen by the UK as equivalent to the public pressure the US had been placing on Britain not to reach an agreement with Huawei to provide the UK’s 5G telecoms network.

Most of the controversy concerning the US-UK trade talks has so far focused on the prices of medicines, food standards and a digital tax.

The proposed clause is based on article 30 of the US-Mexico-Canada agreement that locks out non-market economies. Although the UK does not formally oppose such clauses, British diplomats are worried that in the current context it would give the US extensive and unbalanced leverage over UK policy towards China.

UK diplomats are more broadly concerned that Donald Trump’s determination to use the coronavirus outbreak as a political stick with which to beat China, and secure his re-election, is going to place the UK government under intense external pressure to side with the US against China. Support for a stronger anti-China posture is growing across Conservative benches.

The former chancellor George Osborne said he was nevertheless confident that Boris Johnson was not going to succumb, saying: “Curiously, the member of the cabinet most in favour of engagement with China is the prime minister. He is perfectly prepared to resist some of the pressure from his backbenches.”

Osborne, speaking at a Strand Group webinar, added: “Multilateralism is a way for countries to cooperate on shared objectives. You cannot have this and side with the US in isolating China from the global system. It is the longest continuously existing civilisation in the world.”

Osborne recalled that when he was chancellor, Johnson, who at the time was mayor of London, accompanied him on a trip to China and fully understood the need for cooperation with Beijing.

In a Harvard Kennedy school of government paper jointly written by the former Treasury minister Ed Balls, the authors claim a full trade deal before the US presidential election in November is impossible.

They also suggest even a mini-deal might present a dilemma for the UK, since it could draw it into an emerging US foreign and economic policy based on anti-China bilateralism, and so close the door on plans for a global Britain.

The paper cites an unnamed UK government official saying: “The talks could conclude with a political statement that pulls the UK towards an anti-China, anti-cooperative view of the world.”

It also cites a UK finance official saying: “The US government seems to want to use the pandemic to cut off China from the global economy, to onshore manufacturing and redesign the global economy, to reprioritise around security while saying you can’t have China as part of the system because of how they behave.

“Is this electioneering rhetoric? Or is it potentially much more dangerous, a desire to have a different global economy where China isn’t part of the system?”

A Foreign Office official is quoted saying: “The strategy is not to leave the EU and find out that the US is setting the agenda and the UK is bound to the US because of a trade deal.”

Some UK officials believe there is still merit in the UK trying to reach a preliminary outline deal with China before the US presidential election, arguing it will put pressure on the EU to reach a deal with the UK by the end of the deal.

They also believe the prospect of a UK deal could be used as leverage to persuade Trump to adopt a more multilateral approach to the coronavirus crisis.


Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
China criticises British minister’s visit to Taiwan for trade talks
Beijing ‘resolutely opposes’ official exchanges between Taipei and UK government, says foreign ministry

Verna Yu and Aletha Adu

07, Nov, 2022 @2:17 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson talks tough before US trade talks
PM maintains that NHS is not on the table and animal welfare standards won’t drop

Rajeev Syal

01, Mar, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
UK and China 'won't always see eye-to-eye', says May before trade trip
PM must navigate human rights issues and steel dumping with little prospect of major deals

Jessica Elgot in Wuhan and Tom Phillips

30, Jan, 2018 @10:30 PM

Article image
PM accused of deliberate ‘strategic void’ on China to prioritise trade
UK government ‘ambiguous’ on policy despite China’s clear threat to the west, says report

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

10, Sep, 2021 @5:01 AM

Article image
Truss leads China hawks trying to derail TikTok's London HQ plan
Any last-minute reversal could lead to further deterioration in UK-China relations

Dan Sabbagh

16, Aug, 2020 @3:30 PM

Article image
Britain can complete trade talks within two years, says UK's EU envoy
Sir Tim Barrow says EU has duty to negotiate not just the divorce but also the future trading relationship

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

20, Mar, 2017 @7:12 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson talks up ‘solid steps’ on US trade as lamb deal agreed
PM says in Washington he has ‘every confidence a great deal is there to be done’ on transatlantic trade

Peter Walker Political correspondent

22, Sep, 2021 @1:51 PM

Article image
Barnier pours scorn on Johnson's spokesman ahead of trade talks
EU negotiator signals future relationship negotiations are on course for acrimonious start

Daniel Boffey and Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

25, Feb, 2020 @6:52 PM

Article image
With Brexit imminent, what are the chances of a UK trade deal with China? | Rana Mitter
The US has shown compromise with Beijing is possible but complicated, says Rana Mitter, director of the University of Oxford China Centre

Rana Mitter

19, Jan, 2020 @2:44 PM

Article image
Is free trade always the answer?
As Brexit talks continue, we answer the key questions on the free flow of goods

Richard Partington

13, Aug, 2018 @10:00 AM