Free speech row at Oxford University after Rudd talk cancelled

University said it opposed ‘non-platforming’ after former minister’s speech was cancelled last minute

A free speech row has broken out at Oxford after the university attacked the decision by a women’s group to cancel a speech by the former home secretary Amber Rudd at the last minute.

The university authorities intervened after the UNWomen Oxford society called Rudd, who resigned from the cabinet over the Windrush scandal, to withdraw an invitation to her half an hour before she was due to speak on Thursday. The former MP was pictured with the organiser, Felicity Graham, in an empty auditorium.

Rudd said on Friday morning that the decision was “badly judged” and “rude” and urged students who opposed her politics to “stop hiding and start engaging”.

The university said it strongly disapproved of the decision to disinvite her, tweeting that it is “committed to freedom of speech and opposes no-platforming”.

We strongly disapprove of the decision by the UNWomen Oxford UK Society to disinvite Amber Rudd after she had been asked to speak.

Oxford is committed to freedom of speech & opposes no-platforming. We will be taking steps to ensure that this situation doesn't happen in future.

— Oxford University (@UniofOxford) March 6, 2020

The row over the decision – which drew in students, politicians and Rudd’s family on Friday – is the latest incident in the long-running discussion about freedom of speech at universities.

The academic Selina Todd was dropped from a feminist conference over her views on transgender rights issues, a decision that prompted the Office for Students to warn that “there is a legal requirement on universities to take steps that are reasonably practicable to secure freedom of speech within the law and protect academic freedom”.

UNWomen Oxford said the decision on Rudd came after intense pressure from campaigners to scrap her appearance, with Graham claiming she was adamant the event should go ahead but that “it was the Oxford African and Caribbean Society – who hold a lot of power – who really applied the pressure and forced us to cancel”.

But in response, Oxford’s African Caribbean Society (ACS) said it did not call for the cancellation of the event. In a statement published on Twitter it said: “We privately expressed [when approached by Felicity Graham, the UNWomen Oxford president] that although we share the disappointment expressed by some of our members, we did not in any way intend to boycott the event since we, as a cultural society, ultimately have no place to demand the event not go ahead.

“The society did not call for Ms Rudd’s speech to be cancelled, nor did we ‘force’ UNWomen Oxford to cancel their event.

“Individuals who are members of our society expressed public disapproval, but did so as individuals. Oxford ACS never planned or even discussed ‘boycotting’ the event … In no way did Oxford ACS ‘force this to happen.’”

The event, In Conversation: Amber Rudd, had been organised by UNWomen Oxford as part of its UN Women’s 2020 Trailblazer Series ahead of International Women’s Day on Sunday. The former home secretary was to be interviewed about her earlier role as minister for women and equalities and encouraging women to get into politics.

Following the row, the UN’s women group for the UK suspended the society’s permission to use its name. UN Women UK asked for the Oxford group to make no further association with the national body and it has now changed its name to United Women Oxford Student Society.

Rudd resigned as home secretary in 2018 after heavy pressure over her role in the Windrush scandal.

After news of the cancellation broke, she tweeted her frustration at the decision, saying it was “badly judged and rude of some students last night at Oxford to decide to ‘no platform’ me 30 mins before an event … to encourage young women into politics”.

Badly judged & rude of some students last night at Oxford to decide to “no platform” me 30 mins before an event I had been invited to for #IWD2020 to encourage young women into politics. They should stop hiding and start engaging. #FreeSpeech

— Amber Rudd (@AmberRuddUK) March 6, 2020

And her daughter, the journalist Flora Gill, tweeted: “Can not believe mum was ‘no-platformed’ at my old Uni yesterday.

“I don’t care if you disagree with her … this is NOT how women should treat each other.”

Can not believe mum was ‘no-platformed’ at my old Uni yesterday

Mum doesnt need the platform and travelled to talk for FREE for International Womens Day-proceeds to FGM charity

I dont care if you disagree with her. Its fucking rude

This is NOT how women should treat each other

— Flora E Gill (@FloraEGill) March 6, 2020

Her political allies gave their support on Friday, with the education secretary, Gavin Williamson, describing the decision as unacceptable and calling on the university to take “robust action” to defend free speech.

The leader of the Commons, Jacob Rees-Mogg, replied to Rudd’s tweet: “Free speech is the bedrock of a democracy and Oxford University ought to lead the way rather than being snowflake central.”

But others were sceptical about the significance of the offence to Rudd. The radio presenter James O’Brien tweeted: “I think Amber Rudd was treated pretty shabbily, but I wish I could think of a word to describe people more exercised by her experience than they were by people of colour being wrongly deported from the only home they’d ever known.”

I think Amber Rudd was treated pretty shabbily, but I wish I could think of a word to describe people more exercised by her experience than they were by people of colour being wrongly deported from the only home they’d ever known...

— James O'Brien (@mrjamesob) March 6, 2020

And the political commentator Ash Sarkar said: “I actually don’t think there’s a moral duty to no platform Amber Rudd the same as a fascist. But after presiding over the wrongful deportations of mums, dads, grandparents & loved ones, you don’t get to complain about not being allowed somewhere you feel you have a right to be.”

Contributor

Lucy Campbell

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Amber Rudd hits out at 'rude' Oxford students after talk cancelled
Former minister’s appearance at International Women’s Day event called off at last minute

Jamie Grierson Home affairs correspondent

06, Mar, 2020 @10:15 AM

Article image
Cancelled Rudd event at Oxford not free-speech issue, say feminists
Oxford Feminist Society’s ethnic diversity representative says booking of former home secretary was misjudged

Mattha Busby

07, Mar, 2020 @1:39 PM

Article image
Amber Rudd protest isn’t a threat to free speech | Letter
Letter: The disinvitation of the former home secretary by an Oxford University student society was not a matter of no-platforming, says Anshuman Mondal

Letters

08, Mar, 2020 @6:40 PM

Article image
How the Windrush scandal led to fall of Amber Rudd – timeline
All the key events, from the Guardian breaking the story to the home secretary’s resignation

Nadia Khomami and Goda Naujokaityte

30, Apr, 2018 @3:44 PM

Article image
Windrush row: five questions Amber Rudd has yet to answer
The home secretary is due to make a statement to the Commons on Monday

Rajeev Syal

29, Apr, 2018 @2:09 PM

Article image
Amber Rudd played the blame game over Windrush and lost
In denying there was a target culture at the Home Office, the former home secretary became a target herself

Nick Hopkins

30, Apr, 2018 @2:04 PM

Article image
Sajid Javid pushes for Home Office changes after Windrush errors
Home secretary believes too many people left in limbo, despite No 10 scepticism about review

Heather Stewart and Ben Quinn

02, Nov, 2018 @8:26 PM

Article image
Windrush generation will get UK citizenship, says Amber Rudd
Home Office will waive fees and knowledge test, and applicants may get compensation

Pippa Crerar, Anne Perkins and Amelia Gentleman

23, Apr, 2018 @7:32 PM

Article image
'I feel disgusted': how Windrush scandal shattered two brothers' lives
Trevor and Desmond Johnson’s family units have been destroyed, but they sense Home Office cruelty is routine

Amelia Gentleman

22, Apr, 2018 @6:56 PM

Article image
Windrush citizens share their relief at being listened to
Victims of Home Office blunders are trying to rebuild their lives despite ordeal of past few years

Amelia Gentleman

29, Apr, 2018 @6:22 PM