A Labour-Lib Dem pact and the need for reform | Letters

Under a PR system there would be no need for tactical alliances, writes Theo Morgan, while Jan Kamieniecki advocates looking at other voting models. Plus letters from Judith Martin, Nigel Lindsay and Jeremy Beecham

Bravo to Polly Toynbee for her continued efforts in flying the flag for electoral reform (A pact with the Lib Dems may be the only way Labour can win, 25 February). She is right to highlight most of the voting public supporting a system of proportional representation. The main obstacle is the politicians elected under the current system, who put their own interest first.

The Tories throw the word democracy around when it suits them, but will never change a system that gives them a free rein on a minority of the vote. Unfortunately, in recent years, it seems that Labour would rather its own members voted tactically for the Lib Dems than commit to a system that negates the need for this. Keir Starmer has made some encouraging comments on PR, and appears to be more open to reform than any Labour leadership candidate for decades. Rebecca Long-Bailey is also open to PR. Lisa Nandy is more enthusiastic about progressive alliances, which would be unnecessary under a new system. However, all three leadership candidates find it an easier win to talk up abolition of the House of Lords, which is already party policy. All three also have safe seats, but would do well to remember those Labour voters in safe Tory seats, currently unrepresented.
Theo Morgan
Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform

• I share Polly Toynbee’s enthusiasm for a tactical alliance between Labour and the Liberal Democrats to obtain a majority in order to drive through electoral reform as one route to unblocking our malfunctioning politics.

However, her suggestion that pure proportional representation is the solution is less convincing. Some of our near neighbours use different systems that offer attractive features, not least the French two-round voting and the Irish multi-party constituencies. Rather than guessing the answer, and rushing into another poorly designed constitutional referendum, a Labour-led coalition in 2024 should first convoke a citizens’ assembly to study the options in depth and recommend how and why our electoral system could be reformed.
Jan Kamieniecki

• May I remind Polly Toynbee, who says Lib Dems stay unforgiven by Labour voters for coalition austerity, that Blairite Labour stays unforgiven by many Lib Dems for the Iraq war?

As someone who can see both sides, who has been a member of both parties, I’m relieved that no one in the Labour leadership election was involved, although it would have ruled out Yvette Cooper, for instance, who is frequently cited as someone who should have stood.

Labour has tried hard to remind young voters of the Lib Dem U-turn on student fees. Canvassing for the Lib Dems in a traditionally Labour area of Winchester last December, I found that the traditional Labour voters were largely not interested, but the council houses that had been privatised through right-to-buy and are now student housing were now occupied by interested young people who were keen to vote Lib Dem. Analyse that if you can.

In the end the Lib Dem candidate knocked 90% off the Tory majority, which, although a magnificent effort, was sadly not enough. If Labour had not fielded a candidate, we would not now have a Tory MP.
Judith Martin
Winchester, Hampshire

• Much as I agree with Polly Toynbee on the potential benefits of a pact between Labour and the Liberal Democrats at the next general election, she seems to have overlooked the need for the SNP and Plaid Cymru to be involved too, for the figures to add up. Perhaps she could explain how such a wide pact might work?
Nigel Lindsay
Bo’ness, West Lothian

• Polly Toynbee unfortunately underestimates the challenge Labour faces in the next election when she refers to the need “to beat a majority of 80”. That is the government’s overall majority. Its majority over Labour is, alas, 162.
Jeremy Beecham
Labour, House of Lords

• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters

• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Unconventional wisdom on Labour ‘heartlands’ | Letters
Letters: Ian Wrigglesworth discusses the awkward fact that there is a substantial Tory vote in the north, Roger Backhouse advocates Old Lefties for Labour to win back the pensioner vote, Robert Leach says Labour should take a tip from the late former MP Jack Dunnett, and Dr Alyson Hall Yandoli proposes a new way of testing the leadership hopefuls


13, Jan, 2020 @5:42 PM

Article image
Next Labour leader should back sweeping electoral reforms, Greens say
Siân Berry and Jonathan Bartley write to leadership candidates urging switch to PR

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

03, Apr, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
Labour must be the party of electoral reform | Letters
Letters: It must build a consensus for a new voting model before the next election, says Dr Anthony Isaacs. Plus letters from Sandy Martin, Glyn Evans and Michael Radcliffe


29, Sep, 2022 @3:52 PM

Article image
Electoral reform and making every vote count | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to Polly Toynbee’s call for the Labour leadership candidates to back proportional representation


15, Jan, 2020 @4:38 PM

Article image
A Labour leader who can represent working-class interests | Letters
Letters: Lisa Nandy is the candidate best able to engage and listen to voters, says Giles Oakley, while Peter McKenna believes the party has become too middle-class. Plus letters from Les Bright, Geoff Debelle, Simon Warne and Ian Sinclair


24, Jan, 2020 @5:34 PM

Article image
Labour contenders have loads of brilliant ideas | Letters
Letters: Readers take issue with Rafael Behr’s column criticising Keir Starmer, Lisa Nandy and Rebecca Long-Bailey for the paucity of their plans


01, Mar, 2020 @6:16 PM

Article image
Labour should fight for electoral reform | Letter
Letter: Labour parliamentary candidates and other supporters of Make Votes Matter call on the party to back a system of proportional representation


14, Nov, 2019 @6:23 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on electoral reform: an argument Labour needs to have | Editorial
Editorial: Whichever candidates get through the current stage of the leadership race, proportional representation must be among the ideas they take with them


12, Jan, 2020 @6:50 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on a progressive alliance: divided they fall | Editorial
Editorial: Labour should show it could work with like-minded parties by committing to proportional representation


13, Dec, 2020 @6:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Labour’s leadership race: a long road back | Editorial
Editorial: After a catastrophic election, the party’s contest to replace Jeremy Corbyn must be conducted in a spirit of honesty and humility


06, Jan, 2020 @6:36 PM