BAME MPs accuse Priti Patel of gaslighting in racism debate

Labour MPs write to home secretary after she raised her own experiences of racial abuse

Senior Conservatives have hit back after more than 30 Labour MPs from black, Asian and minority ethnic backgrounds accused Priti Patel of trying to silence debate by “using” her own experience of racism.

The 32 MPs, including Diane Abbott and Clive Lewis, expressed their “dismay” after the home secretary said in a Commons debate that she would “not take lectures from the other side of the house” because she had been racially abused as a child.

The health secretary, Matt Hancock, accused them of “divisive identity politics”.

In the strongly worded letter, the MPs told the home secretary they were disappointed “at the way you used your heritage and experiences of racism to gaslight the very real racism faced by black people and communities across the UK”.

They added: “We all have our personal stories of the racism that we have faced, whether it has been being defined by the colour of our skin or the faith we choose to believe in. 

“Our shared experiences allow us to feel the pain that communities feel when they face racism, they allow us to show solidarity towards a common cause; they do not allow us to define, silence or impede on the feelings that other minority groups may face.”

Patel herself responded strongly to the letter on Twitter, saying: “I will not be silenced by @UKLabour MPs who continue to dismiss the contributions of those who don’t conform to their view of how ethnic minorities should behave.”

Asked about the letter at the daily Downing Street coronavirus briefing, Hancock said, “of course Priti Patel was not wrong to talk of her personal experiences of racism. I have seen this letter, and I abhor this divisive identity politics that’s being levelled at Priti Patel. I’m incredibly proud to be part of the most diverse government in history.”

Former chancellor Sajid Javid called the letter “utterly misguided and irresponsible”.

“Imagine listening to an ethnic-minority woman’s history of suffering racist abuse - and then deciding that you’d rather condemn the victim than her abusers,” he tweeted.

The letter was coordinated by the shadow community cohesion minister, Naz Shah, and was also signed by other senior Labour MPs including Tulip Siddiq, Kate Osamor, Chi Onwurah, Seema Malhotra, Dawn Butler and Rosena Allin-Khan.

In a Commons debate on Monday, the Labour MP Florence Eshalomi suggested the government did not understand the anger felt by people and the desire to tackle structural racism.

Patel told the Commons she was “really, really saddened” by Eshalomi’s criticism and added: “It must have been a very different home secretary who as a child was frequently called a Paki in the playground, a very different home secretary who was racially abused in the streets or even advised to drop her surname and use her husband’s in order to advance her career.

“A different home secretary recently characterised … in the Guardian newspaper as a fat cow with a ring through its nose, something that was not only racist but offensive, both culturally and religiously. [Patel was referring to a Steve Bell cartoon.] So when it comes to racism, sexism, tolerance or social justice, I will not take lectures from the other side of the house.”

In the letter, the Labour MPs tell Patel that “being a person of colour does not automatically make you an authority on all forms of racism” and that experiences should not be used to “silence” others.

They write: “In conclusion, we ask you to reflect on your words and to consider the impact it had towards black communities in the UK trying to highlight their voices against racism. 

“Rest assured that Asian and ethnic minority colleagues on this side of the house will not use their experiences to silence our black colleagues, but will use our shared experiences to stand behind them and support their voices to lead us on standing up against the distinct form of racism black communities in the UK and across the globe face.”

Patel said on Monday that “thugs and criminals” would be brought to justice for pockets of violence at the largely peaceful anti-racism demonstrations in London at the weekend.


Josh Halliday and Heather Stewart

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Priti Patel bullying inquiry delay 'eroding trust' within Whitehall
Union writes to PM amid suspicions ministers may be behind Home Office asylum leaks

Rajeev Syal

02, Oct, 2020 @2:29 PM

Article image
Windrush victims accuse Priti Patel of 'deeply insulting' behaviour
Home secretary tells Daily Mail those trying to stop deportation flight to Jamaica are ‘do-gooding celebrities’

Kevin Rawlinson and Amelia Gentleman

04, Dec, 2020 @5:16 PM

Article image
Bullying inquiry 'found evidence Priti Patel broke ministerial code'
Sources say strong evidence of bullying found as PM expected to rule within weeks

Rajeev Syal and Heather Stewart

19, Nov, 2020 @8:00 PM

Article image
Priti Patel describes Black Lives Matter protests as 'dreadful'
UK home secretary says she disagreed with last year’s protests as well as taking the knee

Nazia Parveen Community affairs correspondent

12, Feb, 2021 @11:31 AM

Article image
Priti Patel appoints ex-Taxpayers’ Alliance head as new aide
Jonathan Isaby joins Home Office as home secretary’s new communications private secretary

Jamie Grierson Home affairs correspondent

12, Aug, 2021 @5:14 PM

Article image
Priti Patel forced to resign over unofficial meetings with Israelis
Theresa May loses second cabinet minister in a week as pro-Brexit international development secretary departs

Rajeev Syal and Anushka Asthana

08, Nov, 2017 @8:57 PM

Article image
PM's defence of Priti Patel sparked Home Office fury, union says
Civil servants angry at ‘double standards applied to home secretary over bullying report’

Peter Walker Political correspondent

22, Nov, 2020 @7:34 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson adviser quits after being overruled on Priti Patel bullying report
PM’s backing of home secretary criticised as No 10 fails to deny reports he tried to get findings toned down

Heather Stewart and Simon Murphy

20, Nov, 2020 @7:12 PM

Article image
Johnson and Patel accused of hypocrisy over racist abuse of England footballers
England footballer Tyrone Mings adds voice to criticism of politicians over football racism

Rowena Mason Deputy political editor

12, Jul, 2021 @2:40 PM

Article image
How Boris Johnson found grounds to ignore Priti Patel bullying verdict
Sir Alex Allan was clear in his central finding against home secretary but offered caveats

Jamie Grierson Home affairs correspondent

20, Nov, 2020 @2:47 PM