Advisers urge ministers to review benefit cap in wake of coronavirus

Estimates suggest 108,000 families will miss out on chancellor’s emergency boost due to cap

The government’s own expert welfare advisory group has called on ministers to review the benefit cap, amid evidence that the controversial policy has left tens of thousands of low-income claimants without vital extra financial help during the coronavirus lockdown.

A letter to the work and pensions secretary, Thérèse Coffey, from the Social Security Advisory Committee (SSAC) said that although the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) had done “remarkable” work to support claimants during the crisis, ministers needed to address several “rough edges” to its policies, including the benefit cap.

The SSAC also called for the £90-a-month uprating of universal credit and tax credits announced by the chancellor in March to help with living costs related to Covid-19 to be extended “as soon as possible” to hundreds of thousands of people on older unemployment benefits who did not receive the cash boost.

“We are of the strong view that it is increasingly untenable for this group of claimants to be excluded and to continue to have a lower level of income than those in receipt of universal credit and working tax credit,” the committee, which is formally sponsored by the DWP, said.

The letter was also critical of DWP advice that left some self-employed people worse off after losing existing benefits in lockdown when they were wrongly told to apply for universal credit as their incomes dropped. Many were refused universal credit, but prevented from reclaiming their original benefits by DWP rules.

It comes amid rising concern from charities and opposition parties that policies such as the benefit cap and the two-child benefit limit have left the poorest households struggling to cope with the increased cost of food and energy bills during the pandemic.

Estimates suggest that around 108,000 families – including 90,000 families already capped – will not see any of the chancellor’s cash boost because it takes them over the benefit cap limit, enabling the DWP to claw it back. In one case, a capped claimant has taken legal action after she was left worse off by the chancellor’s uprating.

The benefit cap was intended to “incentivise” unemployed claimants to get a job by limiting their total household benefits to £23,000 a year (£442 a week) in London and £20,000 a year (£385 a week) outside the capital. People can escape the cap if they get a job or work more hours.

The SSAC letter pointed out that this was currently likely to be difficult: “Claimants would normally have the option to move into paid work or to move home to avoid the impact of the benefit cap, but neither of these are realistic choices for many people at the current time.”

It said the DWP had claimed it was administratively too difficult to safely uprate jobseeker’s allowance (JSA) and employment and support allowance (ESA). However, ministers should “ensure that this group of claimants … are brought up to the same level as those in receipt of universal credit as soon as it is possible to do so”.

Labour’s Jonathan Reynolds, the shadow work and pensions secretary, said ministers should heed the committee’s words: “There is no justification for failing to uprate JSA and ESA In line with UC and the benefit cap should be scrapped – it’s clearly impossible to work more hours or move to cheaper housing during the crisis.”

The SSAC’s membership includes policy experts from organisations such as the Institute for Fiscal Studies and the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, as well as former DWP officials.

The DWP said: “We are doing whatever it takes to ensure people are supported through these unprecedented times, including injecting £6.5bn into the welfare system and rolling out income protection schemes, mortgage holidays and additional support for renters.

 “We have experienced a surge in demand since mid-March and universal credit has enabled us to increase payments at pace, while maintaining the stability of the welfare system overall. We estimate that 2.5 million households on Universal Credit will benefit immediately from the £20-a-week increase in the standard allowance. We have also increased other entitlements such as local housing allowance, to better support those across all benefits.” 


Patrick Butler Social policy editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ministers consider climbdown over ending universal credit boost
Potential move comes amid pressure from a series of Tory MPs to extend the £20-a-week uplift

Jessica Elgot and Peter Walker

18, Jan, 2021 @8:29 PM

Article image
Doctors, charities and Tory thinktank urge PM to drop universal credit cut
Letter signed by 100 organisations warns £20 a week reduction would push 500,000 people into poverty

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

01, Sep, 2021 @11:01 PM

Article image
Coronavirus: 4.5m people in UK forced to become unpaid carers
Charities call on government to rebuild care system to support carers and their families

Amelia Hill

19, Jun, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Record levels of benefit fraud in first year of pandemic in Britain
DWP hope for £1.3bn fraud-and-error savings fade with £6bn loss from universal credit overpayments

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

13, May, 2021 @2:19 PM

Article image
Ministers urged to speed up review of benefits for terminally ill
Thousands of people have died before being able to access welfare payments, charities say

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

11, Jan, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
One-off UK Covid benefit may stop people working, says minister
Thérèse Coffey was responding to MPs about replacing weekly £20 universal credit top-up

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

03, Feb, 2021 @3:43 PM

Article image
Housing benefit reforms should not go ahead, warned government advisers
Experts said welfare shakeup could increase crime and homelessness and force poor families to move to deprived areas

Randeep Ramesh, social affairs editor

30, Nov, 2010 @6:57 PM

Article image
Scrap two-child limit on benefits, urge government’s social mobility advisers
Social Mobility Commission also calls for end to two-child benefit limit to help generation recover from devastating pandemic

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

20, Jul, 2021 @1:05 PM

Article image
Housing benefit cap plan will backfire, ministers told

Experts say benefits bill will rise as result of move while London mayor Boris Johnson warns of 'social cleansing'

Randeep Ramesh, Allegra Stratton, Hélène Mulholland and Amelia Gentleman

28, Oct, 2010 @8:24 PM

Article image
Ministers sanctioned over benefit claims | Letters
Letters: We are disgusted by Rachel Reeves’s statement that Labour is ‘not the party of people on benefits. We don’t want to be seen, and we’re not, the party to represent those who are out of work’


18, Mar, 2015 @7:25 PM