Preparing the ground for a windfall tax on wealth | Letters

DBC Reed, Alan Healey and Rae Street respond to an article by Polly Toynbee. Plus Margaret Squires on the truth of the magic money tree and David Napier on Rishi Sunak’s ‘smart’ mug

As a long-term supporter of the oldest and most radical form of wealth tax, the Henry George land tax (which Andy Burnham was trying to get the Labour party behind 10 years ago), I can claim to have some experience with popular prejudices in favour of large holdings of wealth that Polly Toynbee wrestles with in her excellent article (To save the arts and all else we hold dear, a wealth tax now seems the only answer, 6 July).

Most people think wealth is a good idea and just needs sharing out in their direction. The most popular method is increases in house prices that you don’t have to work for. But house prices rises simply spread poverty, as the high rents and property values ruin capitalism by leaving people who have to work without the money to buy the totality of production they are engaged in.

As a member of the very leftwing Labour Land Campaign, I remember the confusion among potential young recruits when they realised that the Henry George land tax we were recommending was meant to liberate capitalists, but from a form of monopoly that is bigger than all of us.
DBC Reed

• It has seemed increasingly odd that, as the chancellor throws money at shoring up our economy, there has been so little discussion of how this very un-Tory-like approach will be paid for. Polly Toynbee provides a timely reminder that the elephant in the room is wealth. It is a sobering thought that a relatively modest windfall tax could resolve our deficit problems and allow massive investment in things that would make us a civilised country again.

Toynbee quotes Gus O’Donnell, perhaps the best cabinet secretary in recent times because of his willingness to tell ministers when they were getting it wrong. He says that there is no better time to tackle tax reform and that a Tory government could do so more easily than Labour because of the hostile environment that would be created in the media and elsewhere.

Most people have no real idea about average income and wealth, with those towards the top thinking the average is much higher than it is and those towards the bottom believing the opposite. We need a concerted effort to educate the public about the real gaps in income and wealth so that relatively modest changes could be introduced without civil unrest.
Alan Healey
Baschurch, Shropshire

• As Polly Toynbee points out, so many sectors are going to need funds. She is suggesting, quite rightly, a windfall tax on all wealth. There is another area from where money could be redirected. The replacement of Trident is estimated to amount to £205bn, if all costs are taken into account. Nuclear-armed submarines cannot keep us safe from terrorists, cyberattacks or pandemics. The Trident replacement should be cancelled; this would free up money for health, education and welfare.
Rae Street
Littleborough, Lancashire

• Larry Elliott (Rishi Sunak’s mini-budget will be the most leftwing in years. Can Labour capitalise?, 7 July) says what I have always believed: there is a magic money tree, and it is fine as long as it produces blue blossoms, not red ones.
Margaret Squires
St Andrews, Fife

• The “smart” in the “smart mug” that Rishi Sunak posed for a photo with obviously does not refer to the mug who has paid £180 for some sort of heating element and a thermostat (Rishi Sunak poses for pre-budget photo with £180 ‘smart mug’, 7 July).
David Napier
Lewes, East Sussex

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sunak serves up more politics than economics | Letters
Letters: Bernie Evans is clear where the chancellor’s rhetoric will take the country, and Dave Hunter believes Labour can offer a credible alternative, if only it puts in the work


07, Oct, 2020 @4:13 PM

Article image
Post-furlough sums don’t add up for me
Letters: With his £1,000-per-employee bonus plan, the chancellor is effectively saying, ‘If you give me £3, I’ll give you £2 in return’, writes Chris Simmonds


12, Jul, 2020 @4:19 PM

Article image
In search of a new economics for Covid-19 era | Letters
Letters: John Marsh on modern monetary theory and David Cockayne on doughnut economics and art


17, Jul, 2020 @3:57 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Sunak’s agenda: trapped by a legacy of failure | Editorial
Editorial: The prime minister cannot be honest about Britain’s problems without repudiating 12 years of Tory rule


04, Jan, 2023 @6:30 PM

Article image
Rishi Sunak: a sorry tale of wealth, morality and tax | Letters
Letters: Dr Stephen Riley on how wealthy people collude to avoid tax and Hilary Cashman says people should be morally obliged to pay their fair share. Plus letters from Hugh Cooper, Adrian Carter, Angela Barton, Liz McInnes and Sue Wallace


11, Apr, 2022 @5:03 PM

Article image
Trying to make sense of the political centre ground | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to an article by Andy Beckett that said the left should welcome that centrists seem to be slowly coming to terms with today’s world


11, Feb, 2020 @6:31 PM

Article image
George Osborne’s plan may not be set in stone, but it still spells deep cuts
The chancellor has accused his critics of hyperbole, but his autumn statement leaves him little room for manoeuvre

Larry Elliott

04, Dec, 2014 @9:17 PM

Article image
Shameful pay freeze is an insult to key workers | Letters
Letters: Freezing public sector wages is an attack on those already hardest hit by the pandemic, writes Marion Doherty. Plus letters from Alan Millington, Pete Dorey and Gary Bennett


23, Nov, 2020 @5:44 PM

Article image
Reshape the economy for our sake and the planet’s | Letters
Letters: Colin Hines and Kevin Donovan respond to an editorial on Rishi Sunak’s economic strategy


24, Nov, 2020 @5:50 PM

Article image
Economic cost of Covid crisis prompts call for one-off UK wealth tax
Tax experts and economists outline ‘fairest, most efficient’ way to repair public finances and quickly raise £260bn

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

09, Dec, 2020 @12:01 AM