House of Lords idea gets lukewarm reception in York

Proposal to move place of work for 800 peers to North Yorkshire gets mixed reaction on city’s streets

It is known for its imposing gothic cathedral, medieval walls and quaint, cobbled streets. But – in theory, at least – York could soon take on a new role as a modern political hub.

Under a proposal hatched by Boris Johnson’s government to encourage less London-centric decision-making, the House of Lords could be shifted to the northern city when restoration work begins on the Palace of Westminster in 2025.

But while members of the House of Lords were deriding the idea as a PR stunt and suggesting they might just as well be housed on a cruise ship, residents of York were not much more enthusiastic about the prospect of the peers’ arrival.

Chris Nunns, 55, an education guardian for international students, said the move would not lead to any meaningful changes. “York itself isn’t disconnected – we have people from all over the country and the world visiting every day,” he said, arguing that it was politicians themselves who were out of touch.

“Instead of moving the House of Lords here, we should have more regular people with good ideas in politics, rather than the usual Oxbridge types.”

Others seemed sceptical that moving the place of work for 800 peers would force them to engage more with the public. Among those who told the Guardian they were unsure of the work the second chamber does, or what effect its departure from Westminster would have on their own lives, was Chloe Guy, a bar manager.

Chloe Guy
Chloe Guy: ‘Even if they do have to come to work up here, I’m not sure how many people will actually pay attention.’ Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian

The 26-year-old said she wasn’t “massively into politics” but believed there should be more consideration for the views and needs of people living in the north. “But even if they do have to come to work up here, I’m not sure how many people will actually pay attention,” she said.

Some who were asked about the idea on Monday lunchtime in York’s bustling centre were more favourable. At Krusties sandwich shop, a stone’s throw from the crowded timber-framed stores on the Shambles, the Italian owner Camelia Andrei said it could only be a good thing for politicians to get out of the capital.

“Why not? They have to interact with people. To us they are virtual beings because we only ever see them through a screen,” she said. “I’m not English but I understand that there’s a divide in politics between people and parliament.”

Camelia Andrei
Camelia Andrei: ‘I understand that there’s a divide in politics between people and parliament.’ Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian

Helping to dish out filled rolls and soup to customers, Tony Bradley, 67, similarly felt that the move would make politics less insular. “I think Boris Johnson genuinely wants to change that,” he said. “Geographically, it makes more sense for the House of Lords to be in York because it’s in the middle of the country.”

Lindsay Thomas, 37, a bookseller at Minster Gate bookshop, said she felt the move was an act of tokenism. “My reaction wasn’t a positive one. I understand it would be seen as a great idea, like they’re engaging with the north,” she said.

For Thomas, York’s considerable affluence, strong tourism economy and respected university made it the inoffensive but ineffectual choice for policymakers. “It’s not really representative of the north – it’s not Macclesfield, you know?”


Amy Walker

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Peers deride Tory plan to ship House of Lords to north of England
Some cracked jokes, others said it threatened democracy – and several supported idea

Rowena Mason and Peter Walker

20, Jan, 2020 @6:54 PM

Article image
‘Our doors are open’: York gets its first resident rabbi in more than 800 years
Elisheva Salamo is keen to reach a wide range of people in the city notorious for its medieval massacre of Jews

Harriet Sherwood

03, Aug, 2023 @4:00 AM

Article image
Boris Johnson confirms plans for 'government hub' in York
PM says city should be in frame if Commons or Lords have to move during restoration work

Peter Walker Political correspondent

15, Jul, 2020 @7:35 PM

Article image
Police in York issue 'shocking number' of fines to visitors from tier 3 areas
Patrols target people breaching rules in tier 2 city, as crackdown begins across England

Amy Walker

22, Dec, 2020 @4:07 PM

Article image
House of Lords may move out of London to 'reconnect' with public
Tory plan a symbol of Boris Johnson’s aim to ‘level up’ rest of UK with capital

Heather Stewart Political editor and Josh Halliday

19, Jan, 2020 @11:34 AM

Article image
York City FC seeks relatives to find ashes buried under old pitch
Historic England project aims to find ashes of fans buried at football ground slated for redevelopment

Alexandra Topping

19, Aug, 2021 @2:08 PM

Article image
Ann Widdecombe 'was offered Brexit talks role to stand down as Farage candidate'
Exclusive: Brexit party leader claims other candidates were offered seats in Lords in move that ‘borders on corruption’

Kate Proctor Political correspondent

14, Nov, 2019 @9:09 PM

Article image
York council to rule on whether to allow alcohol at axe-throwing centre
Police and council officials are against idea, citing the ‘risk of harm to staff and other customers’

Mark Brown North of England correspondent

10, May, 2022 @11:35 AM

Article image
Claudia Lawrence: renewed call for information on woman missing since 2009
Chef, then 35, was reported missing after she failed to show for early shift at York University 12 years ago

Maya Wolfe-Robinson North of England correspondent

17, Mar, 2021 @1:10 PM

Article image
One-way Shambles: how York is trying to keep its narrow streets safe
City known for its labyrinthine lanes draws up ‘confidence charter’ to reassure visitors

Helen Pidd

28, Apr, 2020 @5:35 PM