Johnson is left spoiling for a fight after Corbyn goes missing at PMQs | John Crace

Tories scrapping A&E targets was surely an open goal but the Labour leader didn’t even see the ball

Someone needs to have a word. There are nine more prime minister’s questions before the new Labour leader takes over, but if Jeremy Corbyn is allowed to take them all there just might not be a party left to lead.

Already the opposition benches are barely half-full for what used to be a guaranteed sell-out gig. Give it another couple of months and the place will be completely empty as more and more Labour MPs are advised by their therapists to stay away in order to avoid making their PTSD any worse. Their mental health is on that much of a delicate knife-edge. Of the five leadership candidates, only the ever loyal and nominatively confused Rebecca Long-Bailey was in the chamber. And presumably only then to learn how not to do PMQs.

Hard to believe, but there were times in the previous parliament when Corbyn could almost hold his own at PMQs. Especially against Theresa May. Then it was an almost equal contest between two normally docile cockapoos half-heartedly growling at one another over a cuddly toy. Sometimes – seemingly more by accident than design – Corbyn might even come out on top. Since the election, though, the Labour leader has been a lost cause. Lost even to himself.

It’s not even as if Boris Johnson now gets to dominate the exchanges through force of will and parliamentary majority. Rather that Corbyn has developed new strategies for making himself look utterly hopeless. On the face of it, six questions on the disastrous A&E and cancer waiting-time figures should have been an easy win for Labour, given that the Tories had been in charge of the NHS for a decade.

Instead, the Labour leader is seemingly on a mission to kill what remains of his reputation and his party with it. If he’s not going to be leader then he’s going to make sure no one else gets a go. The Jim Jones of the Labour party. Now it’s just a matter of coercing all his followers to swallow the cyanide Kool-Aid.

You’d have thought that Matt Hancock’s announcement earlier in the day that the people’s government was planning on dropping its A&E targets was an open goal. What better way to meet targets than by not having any? That way, it was almost as if no one need ever die. And even if they did, who was really that interested in counting up all the dead bodies on trolleys? Such a waste of everyone’s time. But Corbyn didn’t appear to have heard the news that had dominated the headlines all morning. So he didn’t bother to mention it.

Worse was to come, when the Labour leader referred back to his party’s manifesto as a path to a brighter future. A manifesto that had been comprehensively rejected last December by voters who didn’t trust Labour to deliver on its promises. Suddenly it all became clear: Corbyn was in denial. His psyche had taken him back to his happy place. A regression in which the election had never happened and Labour was still a credible opposition. With him as its one true spiritual leader. The man who had won the argument. The few Labour MPs still in the chamber looked on silently, their eyes sunk deep into their sockets. No one dares tell him it’s now 2020.

Boris Johnson appeared rather disappointed by Corbyn’s lack of fight. Having found himself outwitted by the BBC’s football correspondent in his early morning TV interview the day before, the prime minister had spent at least five minutes preparing for this week’s PMQs. At least three and a half minutes longer than usual, though admittedly some of that time appeared to have been spent on taking performance-deteriorating drugs. The Boris in the chamber was sweaty and spoiling for trouble. Nothing was going to trip him up this time.

Only he had no outlet for his aggression. He tried winding Corbyn up by suggesting the only reason waiting times were going up was because people were now so desperate for the full NHS experience that they were going out of their way to give themselves cancer. Nothing. Not a flicker from Corbyn. Boris then upped the ante by repeating a whole load of familiar lies about 50,000 more nurses, 40 new hospitals and a social-care plan that both existed and was yet to be drawn up. Surely Corbyn would react to that? Still nothing. The Labour leader was almost entirely inert.

Boris needed excitement. Danger. Where was the pleasure in being able to do what you liked? All the excitement of having an affair was in the possibility of getting caught. Being prime minister when there was no sense of jeopardy was no fun. It had all only been about the getting of power. Having to exercise it responsibly wasn’t his thing at all. That was for dull apparatchiks. He picked a minor scuffle with the SNP’s Ian Blackford but that was as good as PMQs got for him. The rest of the time was spent barking out staccato morse code bursts – some of them almost recognisable sentences – while promising money he didn’t know he didn’t have to any old cause. A few seats along Sajid Javid was busy making bank transfers on his iPad.

Yet again, the Speaker wrapped things up in a straight 30 minutes. Johnson’s backbenchers cheered him on, but he could tell they were just currying favour. Besides, despite the photos attached to his briefing notes, he still didn’t know who most of them were. Nor would he ever. They were nothing to him. Boris left the chamber curiously unsatisfied. He needed something on which to take out his anger. He guessed that a large chunk of cheese and half a loaf of bread would have to do.


John Crace

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
PMQs returns – with a spot of role reversal for Corbyn and the Maybot | John Crace
May decides to let the Labour leader play at being prime minister for a little while, and he gratefully steps up to the plate

John Crace

28, Jun, 2017 @6:30 PM

Article image
Corbyn and May fail to land punches in PMQs bar brawl | John Crace
Labour leader and PM resembled two drunks fighting outside pub over who cared most about the NHS

John Crace

23, May, 2018 @5:49 PM

Article image
Corbyn has the knives out for Maybot – and so has Freewheelin' Phil | John Crace
No one enjoyed himself more than Philip Hammond as the prime minister felt the heat over public sector pay

John Crace

05, Jul, 2017 @5:50 PM

Article image
Rory Stewart knocked out of Tory leadership contest in third round - as it happened
Stewart received just 27 votes as favourite Boris Johnson topped the poll with 143 votes from MPs

Andrew Sparrow and Mattha Busby

19, Jun, 2019 @9:23 PM

Article image
Tories in awe of their Maybot as comedic Corbyn falls flat | John Crace
Conservative MPs toe the line as they rally behind their leader, leaving Labour looking more confused and bereft than ever

John Crace

18, Jan, 2017 @5:01 PM

Article image
Corbyn mocks May over Brexit, jobs and Johnson at PMQs
Labour leader says jobs at risk and highlights foreign secretary’s ‘Anglo-Saxon’ remark on business

Peter Walker Political correspondent

27, Jun, 2018 @12:32 PM

Article image
Corbyn gives May unexpected lifeline but Javid flounders | John Crace
Labour leader lets PM off the hook as miserable home secretary mumbles his way through Commons onslaught

John Crace

05, Dec, 2018 @6:36 PM

Article image
Cameron's PMQs plan: steal Rosie from Corbyn
Labour leader told PM of ‘Rosie who wants to buy a house in London’ – but Dave had a plan: repeat her name as often as possible

John Crace

10, Feb, 2016 @3:30 PM

Article image
Quizmaster Corbyn’s tricky questions leave May bewildered | John Crace
Acting like the host of University Challenge gave Labour’s leader a triumphant PMQs

John Crace

12, Sep, 2018 @4:43 PM

Article image
Corbyn catches Maybot on the hop in NHS-themed PMQs | John Crace
Six questions on the health service saw the Labour leader firmly on home ground, while the prime minister found her ground to be rather shaky

John Crace

11, Jan, 2017 @6:10 PM