The next Labour leader and what party members want | Letters

The party must get behind Jeremy Corbyn’s successor, writes Chris Morris, while Magi Young hopes for someone who can unite and motivate members up and down the country. Plus Shaun Soper and Brian Wilson on whether the leader should appeal most to members or the wider electorate

Zoe Williams correctly states that Jeremy Corbyn’s election as Labour leader in 2015 “should hardly have come as a surprise” (What Labour members really care about in this leadership race is ideas, 8 January). Despite Labour’s dreadful election defeat, Corbyn deserves enormous credit for enabling Labour to become a radical party again.

In July 2015, under the temporary leadership of the usually admirable Harriet Harman, the party had so lost direction that MPs were told to vote for the government’s welfare bill which cut child tax benefits and household welfare entitlement. I cannot see any of the current leadership contenders supporting such a move. As Williams says, they offer “versions of leftwing analysis that are genuinely different”.

The candidates all offer a radical alternative to the Johnson government. Whoever is chosen as leader, it is imperative (and should be possible) for the parliamentary party to unite behind him or her. The refusal of so many Labour MPs to support Corbyn in his early days as leader was manna to the Tories. The parliamentary party must not make the same mistake again.
Dr Chris Morris
Kidderminster, Worcestershire

• Zoe Williams is right that most Labour members are interested in political ideas rather than internal factions. And she identifies the candidates who are giving fresh versions of modern leftwing analysis.

But I, and many others, also want a leader who can effectively hold this rightwing Johnson government to account – and who is able to lead, unite and motivate members all over the UK so that Labour wins in 2024.

The two candidates mentioned by Williams as more associated with power blocs don’t meet these tests for me. Careful use of language matters. Jess Phillips’ sweary Twitter feed is neither unifying nor motivating for members or voters. Rebecca Long-Bailey’s assessment of Corbyn’s leadership, no doubt well-intentioned (Long-Bailey scores Corbyn ‘10 out of 10’ as she launches campaign, 7 January), is not to me evidence of the critical thinking the next leader needs. So ideas matter to Labour members. But so do intelligence, verbal skills and character.
Magi Young

• What Zoe Williams overlooks in her criticism of the way ideas are developed within the Labour party is that the views of the membership are all too often ignored in favour of the preferences of the leadership, the big unions and the cliques that surround them. For example, all the polls indicated quite clearly that the Labour membership favoured remain in the Brexit debate over the last few years. Yet the Labour leadership chose to ignore these views and drive through alternative Brexit policies via a clever juggling of the makeup of the NEC and a system of a “show of hands” at conference.

Any new Labour leader will improve Labour’s credibility hugely if they committed to complete Ed Miliband’s democratisation of the party and deliver one-member-one-vote on all significant policy decisions, which should no longer be left to the NEC or “delegates”.
Shaun Soper
Midhurst, West Sussex

• Zoe Williams is wrong if she thinks the Labour leadership election should be all about the wishes of party members. Part of the problem is that the outgoing leadership and supporting factions have spent too much time obsessing about the sanctity of the membership, boasting about “the movement” being the biggest in Europe, rather than concentrating on the wishes of the wider electorate.

A new leader must address the ideas and attitudes of the millions of voters the party needs if it is ever to form a government. In voting for a new leader, members should think less about what satisfies their own sense of destiny and more about how they win back those lost seats. It is not a question of right, left or centre, but about dogmatism or pragmatism. Successful leaders have always embraced the latter, while those adhering to the former have invariably crashed in flames.
Brian Wilson
Glossop, Derbyshire

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit

• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Unconventional wisdom on Labour ‘heartlands’ | Letters
Letters: Ian Wrigglesworth discusses the awkward fact that there is a substantial Tory vote in the north, Roger Backhouse advocates Old Lefties for Labour to win back the pensioner vote, Robert Leach says Labour should take a tip from the late former MP Jack Dunnett, and Dr Alyson Hall Yandoli proposes a new way of testing the leadership hopefuls


13, Jan, 2020 @5:42 PM

Article image
Should Labour’s next leader be a woman? | Letters
Letters: Readers debate Guardian columnist Suzanne Moore’s argument for a female-led opposition


17, Dec, 2019 @4:25 PM

Article image
What Labour members really care about in this leadership race is ideas | Zoe Williams
The big distortion of this election is that it’s dominated by bitter infighting. Yet it’s really a debate over differing visions of the future, says Guardian columnist Zoe Williams

Zoe Williams

08, Jan, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on Labour’s leadership race: a long road back | Editorial
Editorial: After a catastrophic election, the party’s contest to replace Jeremy Corbyn must be conducted in a spirit of honesty and humility


06, Jan, 2020 @6:36 PM

Article image
Strictly Come Dancing way to find next Labour leader | Letters
Letters: John Harrison suggests how to pick the next opposition leader, and Paul Curzon outlines the attributes that person needs to possess


15, Dec, 2019 @6:22 PM

Article image
A Labour leader who can represent working-class interests | Letters
Letters: Lisa Nandy is the candidate best able to engage and listen to voters, says Giles Oakley, while Peter McKenna believes the party has become too middle-class. Plus letters from Les Bright, Geoff Debelle, Simon Warne and Ian Sinclair


24, Jan, 2020 @5:34 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on electoral reform: an argument Labour needs to have | Editorial
Editorial: Whichever candidates get through the current stage of the leadership race, proportional representation must be among the ideas they take with them


12, Jan, 2020 @6:50 PM

Article image
How a Labour opposition leader can show and command respect | Letters
Letters: Sean Day-Lewis cites Harold Wilson as the kind of opposition leader the current candidates should aspire to be, while David Hughes urges Jess Phillips to show more courtesy to the prime minister


16, Jan, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
The new Labour leader will try to unite the party – but around what? | Rafael Behr
Unity without clarity is not a route out of opposition. You can’t learn from your mistakes if you don’t name them, says Guardian columnist Rafael Behr

Rafael Behr

26, Feb, 2020 @4:19 PM

Article image
Labour leadership rivals back '10 pledges' to tackle antisemitism
Contenders voice support for recommendations from Board of Deputies of British Jews

Kate Proctor

12, Jan, 2020 @7:21 PM