Top Tory says Dominic Cummings's trip was 'deeply unfortunate'

Justice secretary Robert Buckland breaks cabinet omertà by criticising controversial Barnard Castle visit

Dominic Cummings’s notorious trip to Barnard Castle in April was a “deeply unfortunate episode” that undermined the government’s coronavirus message, the justice secretary, Robert Buckland, has admitted.

Appearing on the BBC’s Question Time on Thursday, Buckland was asked by the host, Fiona Bruce, if he thought the former chief Downing Street adviser broke the guidelines.

“Look, it was a deeply unfortunate episode. There is no doubt about that and it didn’t help when it came to creating a consistent message,” Buckland replied.

It marks the first time a senior government minister has publicly acknowledged this since the paymaster general, Penny Mordaunt, said there were “inconsistencies” in Cummings’s account of his actions during lockdown and apologised to her constituents for how the incident “undermined key public health messages”. Douglas Ross, who was then Scotland minister, resigned in protest over the affair.

At the time, as many as six cabinet ministers privately disclosed to colleagues that they thought Cummings should go, and several did not publicly defend or express support for him. In May, Buckland wrote in the Swindon Advertiser that he “completely understood” the strength of public feeling on the issue, but did not comment further.

Earlier that month, the Guardian and the Daily Mirror revealed that the No 10 aide had driven 264 miles from his London home to his parents’ property in Durham on 27 March with his sick wife and child, at a time when the public were being told to stay at home to stop the spread of coronavirus.

Cummings also admitted to the 60-mile round trip to Barnard Castle, claiming he wanted to test his eyesight and to check if he was fit enough to make the long drive back down to London.

The revelations unleashed a wave of public anger. MPs were bombarded with tens of thousands of emails from furious constituents and Boris Johnson faced growing discontent and revolt among his own backbenchers at his refusal to sack Cummings.

Durham’s former police chief said the Cummings affair undermined lockdown enforcement and a study published in the Lancet found there was a clear and lasting Cummings effect on public confidence in the government’s handling of the pandemic, with willingness to adhere to guidelines plummeting, particularly in England.

The tumultuous Cummings era came to a dramatic end in November when Johnson ordered him to leave Downing Street with immediate effect following a bitter row over the departure of Lee Cain, who was then No 10’s director of communications.

Contributor

Lucy Campbell

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Question Time: Why can’t the BBC admit if it’s wrong? | Jane Martinson
The weird response to errors such as those when Diane Abbott was on the show often makes things worse

Jane Martinson

27, Jan, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
Diane Abbott: Fiona Bruce 'repeated Tory propaganda'
Shadow home secretary says Question Time host misstated Labour’s position in the polls

Jim Waterson Media editor

21, Jan, 2019 @12:51 PM

Article image
Fiona Bruce apologises for referring to man as ‘the black guy’ on air
Presenter contacted Roberto Gocan, 35, about her comment during Question Time in Wolverhampton

Sammy Gecsoyler

07, Oct, 2023 @3:29 PM

Article image
Labour questions Dominic Cummings's links to Russia
Emily Thornberry writes to government asking for details of No 10 security vetting

Jamie Grierson Home affairs correspondent

03, Nov, 2019 @11:21 AM

Article image
Thanks, David Dimbleby. Now maybe Question Time can get with the times | Anne Perkins
The veteran broadcaster’s departure should prompt the lumbering show to shake up its format, says Anne Perkins, a freelance writer and broadcaster

Anne Perkins

14, Dec, 2018 @9:01 AM

Article image
Boris Johnson brushes off Tory revolt over Dominic Cummings
PM also refuses to allow top scientific advisers to talk about chief aide at daily No 10 briefing

Rowena Mason and Vikram Dodd

28, May, 2020 @8:19 PM

Article image
Question time over Fiona Bruce and the BBC | Letters
Letters: Readers discuss the treatment of Diane Abbott on Question Time, audience balance and the need for impartiality

Letters

01, Feb, 2019 @4:47 PM

Article image
Fiona Bruce surprised at Question Time's 'level of toxicity'
Presenter speaks out after BBC politics show was embroiled in racism row

Gregory Robinson

03, Mar, 2020 @12:01 AM

Article image
Fiona Bruce on 40 years of Question Time: 'It's where the reality confronts the rhetoric'
The BBC panel show now causes as much debate as it hosts, accused of bias by all sides. Presenter Fiona Bruce still has hope for the future

Tim Adams

15, Sep, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
Dominic Cummings tries to explain when and why of lockdown trip
Key exchanges from press conference given by Boris Johnson’s chief aide

Archie Bland

25, May, 2020 @6:55 PM