Keir Starmer urged to wait before telling MPs to approve Brexit deal

Unease in the Labour party over leader’s policy as Neil Kinnock warns against complicity in harming British economy

Some of Labour’s union backers have urged Keir Starmer to wait before telling Labour MPs to support a Brexit deal, amid growing unease within the party over the leader’s policy.

Several sources said Starmer was already set on backing a Brexit deal should it be agreed and return to the Commons for a vote. Some in his team believe the issue is too big for the party to abstain on, and fear opposing the deal would suggest they preferred a no-deal outcome.

However, in a conference call with Labour’s affiliated union bosses on Friday, Starmer was urged by some to back away from a decision over the potential vote until the details of any agreement are published and properely analysed. With unease mounting among some MPs and peers, those opposed to supporting a deal are keen to reopen the option of abstaining in any vote.

One union insider said any decision to vote for the Brexit deal would hand a campaigning slogan to the SNP in Scotland and Plaid Cymru in Wales at next year’s local elections. The pro-Remain Transport Salaried Staffs’ Association (TSSA) led the calls for Starmer to wait before deciding to endorse a deal, but other unions said Labour risked no-deal should it back away from endorsing an agreement.

While Unite’s Len McCluskey is understood not to have intervened in the conference call, his union – Labour’s biggest financial backer – is said to be supportive of backing a Brexit deal to show former pro-Leave voters that the party accepts the referendum outcome.

Asked about Friday’s call, TSSA’s general secretary Manuel Cortes said: “Until we see the text of a deal – if one is eventually reached – it’s too early to say which way our Labour party should whip its MPs. If we don’t know what’s in it, how can we decide whether to vote for it or not?”

Rachel Reeves, the shadow cabinet office minister, has been talking to Labour MPs, peers and unions for several weeks about the prospect of a Brexit deal vote as part of a concerted effort to keep them on board, but concern is building.

There is still opposition to voting in favour of a deal within the shadow cabinet, with even shadow chancellor Anneliese Dodds said to be torn. Others still unsure are understood to include shadow justice secretary David Lammy and shadow international trade secretary Emily Thornberry. Several MPs were “really pissed off” by what they saw as a concerted attempt by leadership to marginalise those with doubts about backing a deal, one insider said.

Concerns have also emerged among Labour Lords. Former leader Neil Kinnock told fellow peers in a private message: “Johnson’s ‘deal’ will not cover the huge and prolonged NON tariff impediments and costs of Brexit or safeguard the industries, services, communities and people who will be harmed by that reality. If Labour supports the ‘deal’, all our future justified criticisms will be rebuffed by ‘but you voted for this!’ and, because it will be true, it will be lethal.

“We must abstain and explain that this is the rational course when faced with a damaging ‘yes’ and a disastrous ‘no’. Johnson will get his ‘deal’ through the Commons anyway and he must OWN the outcome – if we share ownership, we share complicity in the harm to our country (the most vital issue) and we give him a totally unwarranted credibility.”

One Labour figure who backed a second referendum said it was a miscalculation by Starmer’s team to think that “the relatively small proportion of former Labour voters who are highly motivated by Brexit will in any way be persuaded to back the party again because it is backing a deal”. They added it was also a mistake to assume the huge number of Remain voters who backed Labour in 2017 have “nowhere else to go”.


Michael Savage, policy editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Keir Starmer facing pressure to end silence on Tory Brexit failures
The Labour leader is being urged to hold Boris Johnson to account for his flawed trade deal with the EU

Toby Helm

13, Feb, 2021 @7:09 PM

Article image
Labour group urges Keir Starmer to back better Brexit deal
Labour MPs and activists urge their leader to commit to aligning Britain with Brussels and restoring EU programmes

Toby Helm and Michael Savage

25, Apr, 2021 @8:30 AM

Article image
Keir Starmer warned not to insist Labour MPs vote for Brexit deal
Leader faces resignations from his front bench in a ‘dangerous moment’ for his authority

Michael Savage & Daniel Boffey in Brussels

29, Nov, 2020 @10:45 AM

Article image
Keir Starmer urged to speak out and help millions of EU citizens in Britain
Labour activists call on leader to intervene as deadline to apply for settled status looms

Toby Helm

27, Jun, 2021 @9:45 AM

Article image
Keir Starmer seeks alliance against no-deal Brexit with Tory ex-ministers
Cross-party move to foil ‘disastrous exit’ comes as economic forecasts pile pressure on next PM

Toby Helm Political Editor

20, Jul, 2019 @9:04 PM

Article image
Keir Starmer winning Tory Leave voters for Labour – poll
As the party leader decides whether to back any Brexit deal, a survey of 7,000 electors shows he has closed the gap with the Conservatives since the election last year

Michael Savage

12, Dec, 2020 @12:53 PM

Article image
Labour needs an ‘honest debate’ about Brexit damage, union warns
Unless Britain develops a closer relationship with the EU it will continue to haemorrhage investment and jobs, says the GMB

Toby Helm Political editor

03, Jun, 2023 @11:57 AM

Article image
Labour MPs dismayed at orders to maintain ‘radio silence’ on Brexit
High command fears that criticising Boris Johnson’s flawed deal with the EU would be damaging for the party

Toby Helm Political editor

20, Feb, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson threatens Rishi Sunak’s bid to end deadlock over Brexit
Ex-PM will fight to save Northern Ireland protocol bill – while Labour vows to support No 10 if it can reach deal with EU

Michael Savage and Patrick Wintour

18, Feb, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Johnson will not stumble until Starmer tackles him on Brexit
Our Houdini PM looks poised to win a byelection in a Labour stronghold, even as his signature policy creates crisis after crisis

William Keegan

18, Apr, 2021 @6:00 AM