How long can Dominic Raab govern as a stand-in prime minister?

Boris Johnson’s hospital stay thrust the foreign secretary into the spotlight, but revealed a flaw in the UK’s constitutional processes

Last week exposed a gap in the UK’s constitutional arrangements. The prime minister fell victim to the virus his government was battling. After a week of assurances that he was able to govern as normal from a sealed flat in Downing Street, Boris Johnson was admitted first to hospital, then to intensive care.

Before Johnson went to St Thomas’ hospital, he had the foresight to pass the baton to the first secretary of state, Dominic Raab, who would combine some prime ministerial responsibilities with those of his day job of foreign secretary. Raab’s primary duty would be to chair meetings of the cabinet and cabinet committees. That, in fact, is much of what occupies prime ministerial time, especially when there are daily crisis meetings. Raab said that he was acting under clear instructions from the prime minister.

We were assured that there was no lacuna in our national security arrangements – Raab could, if necessary, declare war. Fortunately that capability was not tested last week. But he did not have the full range of prime ministerial powers. He could not hire and fire his colleagues – and would not be meeting the Queen for a weekly audience.

For a week, these arrangements have worked. The tramlines of the government’s Covid-19 strategy were clear: ramping up testing, reinforcing NHS critical-care capacity, making sure that the cheques promised by the chancellor to support workers and business were delivered. Raab could front press conferences. Last weekend’s papers were full of unedifying mudslinging and scapegoating: one immediate consequence of the PM’s hospital admission seems to have been to make the cabinet realise it needed to show it could act collectively, without a PM to impose discipline.

The question is whether this ad hoc arrangement can work for longer than a week.

Raab’s authority was always going to be tested when important choices had to be made: how to start the exit from lockdown; how to balance maximum suppression with the wider health and social implications of stringent restriction; and the need to support economic bounce-back. Down the line, a decision will have to be made on whether to agree an extension to the Brexit transition before the end of June.

Skilful chairmanship might be able to fashion a consensus. But sometimes prime ministers just have to decide. That is where Raab might have struggled. In his cabinet, Johnson is the unique big beast. Raab was knocked out early in the leadership contest. He was not the architect of the election victory; cabinet members do not owe him their jobs. Under Theresa May we saw how hard it was for a prime minister to get her way when she had no political authority.

Raab’s task will be much easier if, on the big calls, a convalescent prime minister can give his cabinet a steer. That will lend Raab valuable authority. If Johnson can’t do that, Raab’s task will be much harder.

So we, like the prime minister, may have got lucky. We may never find out whether our ad hoc arrangements are robust enough to withstand the long-term incapacitation of a prime minister during a crisis. Strengthening them should be a post-crisis priority.

Jill Rutter is senior research fellow at thinktank UK in a Changing Europe


Jill Rutter

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'I owe them my life': how Boris Johnson's illness shook him, and the nation
The news of the prime minister’s admission to intensive care shook the nation. For a time his life appeared to be in danger. Will this brush with mortality change his attitudes?

Toby Helm

11, Apr, 2020 @10:41 PM

Article image
Blundering Boris: how U-turns and broken promises have split the Tories
From backtracking on free school meals to lack of planning over Covid-19, many backbenchers are in despair. But what now for the future of No 10?

Toby Helm Political editor

21, Jun, 2020 @8:14 AM

Article image
Johnson’s moment of lockdown truth looms as announcement on reopening awaited
Should PM listen to those who urge a rapid return to normality now the vaccine programme is advancing, or will he heed those who urge caution?

Toby Helm, Robin McKie and Robyn Vinter

21, Feb, 2021 @10:30 AM

Article image
Covid’s second coming: how did Britain get back in this mess?
Some nations have suppressed the virus. Others have stabilised their outbreaks. In the UK, infections are soaring again. Why?

Toby Helm, Emma Graham-Harrison, Robin McKie, James Tapper and James Chater

27, Sep, 2020 @7:45 AM

Article image
A year after Johnson’s swaggering Greenwich speech, 100,000 dead
The government says nobody could have done more but it’s clear poor leadership on Covid has brought the UK to this pass

Tim Adams

31, Jan, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Covid confusion and Brexit betrayals: is this any way to run Britain?
At home, fiats about the pandemic dismay Tories. Abroad, threats to breach deals destroy trust. But what leader can hope to govern without goodwill?

Toby Helm, Daniel Boffey, Rory Carroll and Philip Oltermann

13, Sep, 2020 @6:18 AM

Article image
How England’s ‘pingdemic’ took a heavy toll on the Tories
It was billed as a return to freedom, but the week ended with empty supermarket shelves and cancelled trains as many thousand workers – including the PM and chancellor – self-isolated

Toby Helm

25, Jul, 2021 @6:15 AM

Article image
London doesn't always know best: how the north is choosing its own pace out of lockdown
Angered by Dominic Cummings, and exasperated by diktats on school openings, councils are working together after being bypassed and ignored

Julian Coman

30, May, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Why trust politicians? How UK voters lost faith in our leaders
More people than ever before feel disaffected by our political system. But what are the reasons for this and what risks does it pose?

Toby Helm Observer political editor

04, Dec, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
A Tudor court without a king: inside No 10 as Raab takes the reins
In the absence of Boris Johnson, how will Downing Street cope with the many Covid-19 decisions that loom?

Michael Savage

12, Apr, 2020 @6:05 AM