Tories deny plan to compromise workers' rights after Brexit

Business minister defends Johnson after Labour says PM misled parliament with his plan for exiting the EU

The government has denied it has misled parliament and that it is seeking to tear up provisions for workers’ rights after Brexit.

The business minister Kwasi Kwarteng admitted on Saturday that it would be very difficult for Britain to leave the European Union next week, but he dismissed reports employees’ rights would be slashed after Brexit as “way exaggerated”.

He said it was for the EU to decide whether the UK was granted an extension, with deliberations in Brussels continuing into the weekend after Boris Johnson grudgingly requested a delay to Brexit.

Fresh scepticism over the agenda of Johnson’s government is likely to impact ongoing EU27 discussions after the Financial Times reported that the prime minister was willing to consider diverging from EU standards on the environment and workers’ rights.

But Kwarteng dismissed the report and said it was completely inaccurate. “I think this is completely mad, actually,” he told the BBC. “You’ve said how we built a coalition – 19 Labour MPs have come with us and voted for a second reading [of the withdrawal agreement bill]. It wouldn’t make any sense at all to dilute workers’ rights in building that coalition to land the bill.

“We have said we will be better than our word. We have said our ambition on securing workers’ rights will be stronger than the provision of the bill.”

According to the report, the leaked document said the way the political declaration – the agreement setting out the aims of the future trade negotiations between the UK and the EU – had drafted workers’ rights and environmental protection commitments left “room for interpretation”.

It reportedly boasts that “UK negotiators successfully resisted the inclusion of all UK-wide level playing-field rules” in the previous deal negotiated by Theresa May’s team, allowing Britain to compete against EU members by possibly watering down rights.

The document, which has not been shared with parliamentarians or the public, goes to the heart of Labour’s concerns that workers’ rights and environment rights would be tampered with if the Tories were in power after Brexit.

Jenny Chapman, the shadow Brexit minister, said: “These documents confirm our worst fears. Boris Johnson’s Brexit is a blueprint for a deregulated economy, which will see vital rights and protections torn up.

“It is also clear Boris Johnson was misleading parliament earlier this week. You simply can’t trust a word Boris Johnson says. Under his proposals, this Conservative government has no intention of maintaining high standards after we leave the EU.”

Those fears are particularly felt in Berlin, as speculation mounts that Johnson is preparing to reform the UK into a low-tax, lightly regulated economy described as “Singapore-on-Thames”.

He told MPs this week that the UK was committed to “the highest possible standards” on both sets of rights. This stance helped convince 19 Labour MPs to back his withdrawal agreement bill at its second reading on Tuesday.

The Department for Exiting the European Union initially declined to comment on Saturday morning. Later, a government spokesperson said: “The UK government has no intention of lowering the standards of workers’ rights or environmental protection after we leave the EU and we already exceed EU minimum standards in areas such as maternity leave, shared parental leave and greenhouse gas targets.

“UK level playing field commitments will be negotiated in the context of the future UK-EU free trade agreement, where we will achieve a balance of rights and obligations which reflect the scope and depth of the future relationship.”

The EU has insisted any future relationship should be based on a level playing field. After a meeting of EU ambassadors on Friday, a Brussels source said there was full agreement on the need for an extension and that work would continue over the weekend.

The final decision on whether the EU will opt for an extension until January or a shorter November delay is not expected until Monday or Tuesday. It is believed that Emmanuel Macron, the French president, is not in favour of the extension stretching into the new year.

Kwarteng said: “I think it will be very difficult to leave on 31 October precisely because of the Benn act, the surrender act, which essentially gave authority to the EU, the other side, about whether we will leave on 31 October or not. It looks like they may well give us an extension.”


Mattha Busby

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
EU diplomats remain guarded over May's Brexit compromise
Diplomats uneasy about giving UK unique status outside EU, with one ‘unsure this is going to fly’

Jennifer Rankin Brussels correspondent

07, Jul, 2018 @12:28 PM

Article image
No-deal fears rise as Boris Johnson 'least willing to budge on Brexit'
The prime minister remains determined not to compromise over the terms of Britain’s exit from the European Union, say senior Whitehall sources

Michael Savage

15, Nov, 2020 @7:45 AM

Article image
Johnson and Von der Leyen extend Brexit talks by a month
UK and EU leaders instruct chief negotiators to work harder to close gaps on deal

Daniel Boffey in Brussels

03, Oct, 2020 @3:12 PM

Article image
Calls for inquiry into claims Johnson backers benefit from no-deal Brexit
Cabinet secretary urged to look into conflict of interest fears raised by Philip Hammond and Rachel Johnson

Michael Savage Policy editor

28, Sep, 2019 @4:06 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson threatens Rishi Sunak’s bid to end deadlock over Brexit
Ex-PM will fight to save Northern Ireland protocol bill – while Labour vows to support No 10 if it can reach deal with EU

Michael Savage and Patrick Wintour

18, Feb, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
UK faces Brexit crisis after Europe’s leaders demand: ‘Get out now’
France and Germany urge swift action by Britain as Tory MPs say Boris Johnson is preparing leadership bid

Toby Helm and Daniel Boffey

25, Jun, 2016 @10:05 PM

Article image
Come clean on logjams at British borders as new Brexit rules kick in, ministers told
Amid confusion for lorry drivers in Kent, logistics firms call for greater transparency to help lessen disruption

Michael Savage Policy Editor

02, Jan, 2021 @9:02 PM

Article image
Labour cannot make people’s lives better until it talks about Brexit | Stella Creasy
Silence on the issue, for fear of saying the wrong thing, means the Tory dogma and narrative on Europe will go unchallenged

Stella Creasy

19, Jun, 2022 @9:15 AM

Article image
Tusk: Boris Johnson must not become known as 'Mr No Deal'
European council president says he is willing to listen to realistic ideas on Brexit

Julian Borger in Biarritz

24, Aug, 2019 @11:00 PM

Article image
As the UK’s MPs prepare to cast their crucial vote on Brexit, where do the parties stand?
If Boris Johnson strikes a free trade deal with Brussels, deciding whether to back it won’t be easy for many parliamentarians

Toby Helm Political editor

20, Dec, 2020 @9:00 AM