What Johnson's deal means for workers' rights, the NHS and the economy

The PM’s Brexit plan loosens the economic ties to the EU, so what would be the impact?

Why are workers’ rights at stake in Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal?

The PM’s renegotiated deal opens the way to a much looser relationship with the EU than envisaged by his predecessor, Theresa May, and allows for more “divergence” with EU regulations.

As such, instead of writing into the legally binding withdrawal agreement that the UK will abide by EU standards on workers’ rights and the environment, these “level playing field” commitments have been shifted to the forward-looking political declaration.

In practice, it will be up to the government that negotiates the free trade deal – most likely after a general election – to decide how strong a commitment to EU rules it is prepared to make.

What promises is the government making to protect workers’ rights?

While labour rights – like a blizzard of other rules and regulations – would no longer be underpinned by EU law, the government has promised to write a series of commitments into the Withdrawal Act (the legislation implementing Brexit).

On Friday night, the government announced that ministers would be obliged to make a statement each time any new law could affect employment rights, and say whether they would comply with EU standards.

And the government would also report regularly on changes to EU standards and whether the UK planned to mirror them. MPs would then be given a vote on these reports, to approve or reject the government’s plan.

Ministers also pointed out that the government announced an employment reform bill in the Queen’s speech that would increase standards, and insisted they had no intention of reducing standards.

However, Labour’s employment rights spokesperson, Laura Pidcock, insisted those pledges were not worth the paper they were written on – and Jeremy Corbyn claimed Johnson was “firing the starting gun on a race to the bottom”.

Johnson has also repeatedly stressed his insistence that while environmental standards will no longer be guaranteed by EU law, the UK will set higher standards, including in an environment bill, announced in this week’s Queen’s speech.

What else might be up for grabs in future trade deals?

According to Johnson in the debate on Saturday, not the NHS – which Labour fears could be opened up to exploitation by US corporations as part of a trade agreement with Donald Trump’s White House.

When he flew to the G7 summit in Biarritz in August, the PM outlined a long list of trade barriers he said faced British business hoping to export to the US market – but declined to say what he could offer to Trump’s “America First” government in return.

Johnson has repeatedly insisted NHS contracts will not be part of any future trade deal and put hospital funding at the heart of his bid for re-election. However, Labour has accused him of being willing to put it up for sale.

What economic assessment has the government done of the impact of Boris Johnson’s deal?

Extraordinarily, it hasn’t done any.

Challenged by the Lib Dem Luciana Berger about why the government had failed to publish forecasts, the Brexit secretary, Steve Barclay, said: “There’s no level of analysis that is probably going to change her vote and her mind. Indeed, as a former Treasury minister one of the things I’m always aware of, is indeed it’s difficult to model a deal that was only made on Thursday.”

He added that it would be difficult to model changes to policy by the new European commission, and to the global economic backdrop.

The independent thinktank UK in a Changing Europe has published analysis comparing Johnson’s agreement with Theresa May’s deal, which came closer to achieving frictionless trade with the EU, in exchange for promising alignment with EU regulations in key areas.

It found that Johnson’s deal would be likely to reduce GDP per capita – a measure of living standards – by between 2.3% and 7% over the next decade, compared with remaining in the EU. That compares with an estimate of 1.9% to 5.5% under May’s deal.

It also suggested the deal would entail a hit to the public finances of £16bn to £49bn.


Heather Stewart Political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
British economy 'to grow 0.16% at best under US trade deal'
Admission lays bare limited benefits of ‘ambitious’ agreement with Donald Trump

Heather Stewart, Lisa O'Carroll, Richard Partington and Mathilda Walters

02, Mar, 2020 @12:45 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson talks tough before US trade talks
PM maintains that NHS is not on the table and animal welfare standards won’t drop

Rajeev Syal

01, Mar, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
Queen's speech: what is in Boris Johnson's 2020 programme?
Key bills include law to formally take UK out of EU, an immigration bill and law to guarantee level of NHS spending

Kate Proctor and Sam Merriman

19, Dec, 2019 @12:02 PM

Article image
Health unions seek assurances after leak on trade talks and NHS
Medics call for guarantees that health service will form no part of talks on trade deals

Haroon Siddique

28, Nov, 2019 @1:23 PM

Article image
Gove 'lying' about EU citizens' NHS rights to gain votes
Opponents say remarks are ploy based on xenophobia to win Labour leave marginals

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

17, Nov, 2019 @4:46 PM

Article image
Brexit: UK's new fast-track immigration system to exclude care workers
Minimum salary thresholds to also remain in place, presenting additional barrier

Peter Walker, Robert Booth, Lisa O'Carroll and Jessica Elgot

13, Jul, 2020 @5:59 PM

Article image
UK leaving single market for TPP could hit workers' rights, union warns
TUC delivers stark warning about labour abuses after trade secretary Liam Fox refuses to rule out membership of TPP

Anushka Asthana Political editor

03, Jan, 2018 @6:21 PM

Article image
From shortbread to the NHS: Scotland fears loss of workers after Brexit
Employers have depended on EU nationals, many of whom are now embedded in the Highlands

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

04, Mar, 2018 @4:42 PM

Article image
Ministers still do not know if NHS can cope with no deal, says watchdog
NAO says data does not show that health services will be ready if UK leaves EU next month

Rajeev Syal

27, Sep, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Inside the Welsh NHS stockpile set up for no-deal Brexit
Huge warehouse in secret location holds £5m-worth of medical products and food

Steven Morris

02, Oct, 2019 @12:23 PM