David Gauke survives Leave.EU-backed vote of no confidence

Tory members in justice secretary’s South West Hertfordshire constituency reject motion

The justice secretary, David Gauke, has survived a vote of no confidence by his local Conservative association, defeating efforts by hard Brexit groups such as Leave.EU to potentially deselect the cabinet minister from his South West Hertfordshire constituency.

The motion accused Gauke of “wilful obstruction” towards implementing the 2016 EU referendum result by opposing a no-deal exit. Although Gauke supported remain in the referendum, he repeatedly voted for Theresa May’s withdrawal agreement in parliament.

During the meeting – which ended with a vote of 123-61 in Gauke’s favour, with one abstention – the proposer of the motion admitted that he had only joined the Conservative party in February. He called the MP a “Brexit wrecker” with an “extremist anti-leave stance” in his speech.

Replying, the minister said that of the 50 people who pushed for the motion, “the majority have joined in the last 12 months”. He said that “there [was] an attempt to fundamentally change the nature of the Conservative party” taking place.

“Are we morphing into a new party, the Brexit party?” Gauke asked. “If so, I’m not the candidate for you. If I have to change my tune under the threat of deselection, then I’m not going to do that.”

Following the vote, Gauke tweeted: “Tonight, I argued that: We should not allow the Party to be taken over by entryists. We should be a broad church. No deal would be immensely damaging to the UK. I defeated a motion of no confidence 123 to 61. I am grateful to the members of my association for their support.”

The result was applauded by fellow moderate Tories, with Rory Stewart, whose leadership bid Gauke had supported, tweeting that it had been a “tribute to the power of truth, to his association and a tribute above all to David Gauke”.

Former foreign officer minister Alastair Burt said: “Total support for a great colleague, and strong, decent Conservative. Good on his association in standing up to those who may not be singing from a truly Conservative script.”

And Scottish Tory leader Ruth Davidson tweeted the word “Good” followed by three applause emojis.

The decision by the association is a defeat for the Leave.EU campaign group. On Thursday, it tweeted: “Tomorrow we claim our first Cabinet scalp as DavidGauke is up for deselection in South West Herts”.

Tomorrow we claim our first Cabinet scalp as @DavidGauke is up for deselection in South West Herts.

With a new leader and potential election, now is the time to make the Conservative party conservative again. If we fail? The Brexit Party wipes the floor with them. Win win! 👍

— Leave.EU (@LeaveEUOfficial) June 27, 2019

After the result, Gauke tweeted mischievously at Leave.EU’s co-founder Aaron Banks, saying “Not so fast there, Aaron”.

Gauke has held the seat since 2005 and was returned at the 2017 election with a majority of 19,550, increasing his personal vote to 35,128, almost 60% of the electorate.

Ministers from both sides of the Brexit divide rallied to support Gauke before the vote took place.

The work and pensions secretary, Amber Rudd, tweeted: “Tonight’s motion of no confidence in @DavidGauke is ludicrous. Rounding on colleagues in this way is the type of behaviour you’d expect from the hard left.”

She said Gauke had her “full support” and expressed hope that Boris Johnson and Jeremy Hunt would also back him.

Leave.EU swiftly replied to Rudd, who backed remain, warning that she would face similar moves in her ultra-marginal Hastings constituency, which she holds by just 346 votes.

Thanks for your feedback, Amber. You're next. https://t.co/4F1w5c7uEm

— Leave.EU (@LeaveEUOfficial) June 28, 2019

Hunt did tweet support for his colleague – who is now backing him for the leadership – saying that Gauke “is an outstanding cabinet colleague and we need him to carry on doing such a great job!”

The Brexit minister, James Cleverly, exasperatedly pointed out on Twitter that there was “no deselection mechanism” in the party and complained about having “these Leave.EU stories amplified by the press for months and no Conservative MP has been deselected”.

Cleverly, a former leave-supporting deputy chairman of the Conservatives who has said a no-deal would be “deliverable but [not] easy or effortless”, said Gauke was “a great MP and a huge asset to our party”.

Claire Perry, the energy minister who campaigned to remain, compared those seeking to unseat Gauke to Labour’s left. “It’s a @LeaveEUOfficial “momentum moment”. Their hit list ignores the fact that MPs like David have voted repeatedly for a firm EU exit – if other MPs had joined us rather than indulging in their Brexit fantasies we would be out by now.”

Former ministers Phillip Lee and Dominic Grieve were not as fortunate as Gauke, having lost votes of no confidence by their local associations this year.

On Thursday, Leave.EU claimed: “Activists in East Surrey have now amassed more than the 50 signatures required to initiate deselection proceedings against the former universities minister Sam Gyimah.” He resigned in November 2018 after voting against May’s Brexit deal and subsequently endorsed the holding of a second referendum.


Seth Jacobson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Vote Lib Dem, urges former Conservative minister David Gauke
Ex-justice secretary calls for people to ‘vote for the centre-ground’ to avoid hard Brexit

Kate Proctor Political correspondent

13, Nov, 2019 @9:15 AM

Article image
Johnson's political strategy 'inspired by Trump', says Gauke
Ex-minister says PM’s language owes more to Donald Trump than Winston Churchill

Kate Proctor Political correspondent

01, Oct, 2019 @5:14 PM

Article image
Gauke could back rebel move to stop PM proroguing parliament
Speculation about cabinet resignations as justice secretary considers voting for Grieve amendment

Matthew Weaver

18, Jul, 2019 @8:35 AM

Article image
Brexit: Rudd, Clark and Gauke should resign, says Andrew Bridgen
Three cabinet ministers have signalled they could vote to delay withdrawal from EU

Sarah Marsh

23, Feb, 2019 @9:15 AM

Article image
Gauke: Johnson risks millions of votes with 'Farage-lite' strategy
Expelled MP warns PM’s approach will leave deep scars and alienate traditional Tories

Heather Stewart Political editor

06, Sep, 2019 @3:22 PM

Article image
David Gauke: populist politicians are poisoning Britain
Justice secretary remarks will be seen as veiled attack on Boris Johnson

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

04, Jul, 2019 @7:12 AM

Article image
David Gauke expresses 'grave concerns' about no-deal Brexit
Justice secretary says leaving EU without deal would have ‘very adverse effect’

Mattha Busby

16, Feb, 2019 @12:16 PM

Article image
David Gauke mocks Boris Johnson over spending promises
Justice secretary wishes ‘good luck’ to whoever becomes chancellor under Tory frontrunner

Peter Walker Political correspondent

17, Jun, 2019 @10:02 AM

Article image
Senior Tory suggests he would vote with Labour in no confidence motion to block no-deal Brexit – Politics live
Rolling coverage of the day’s political developments as they happen, including ministers discussing planning for a no-deal Brexit

Andrew Sparrow

18, Dec, 2018 @7:02 PM

Article image
David Gauke signals he will press on with universal credit
Work and pensions secretary says benefit changes are ‘transforming lives’ after MPs called for a pause in their introduction

Heather Stewart

25, Aug, 2017 @4:30 PM