We must fix Lords legitimacy problem | Letters

Green peer Jenny Jones says new appointments should be proportionate to the number of votes cast in the general election rather than the number of MPs

Almost every peer agrees that reform of the House of Lords is needed, but the only thing they can all agree on is trimming it down. Lord Fowler is doing a good job of culling the numbers in a humane way (House of Lords: Second chamber has too many ‘passengers’ – Speaker, 2 January), but a voluntary scheme relies upon goodwill, and that can be hard to maintain in turbulent times. A desperate government could crowd the benches with new appointments after the Lords themselves have tried hard to create a bit of elbow room.

New appointments should reflect the vote in the general election. Importantly, the numbers should be proportionate to the vote, rather than the number of MPs. This changes the distorted outcome of a first-past-the-post system where a party can win a third of the vote but finds itself in government with a clear majority in the Commons. It also means that smaller parties, like the Greens, get representatives in the Lords, increasing the diversity of political voices.

This would be a partial step towards an elected second chamber, which many of us feel is the only guarantee that the people who go into the Lords see it as a job, rather than a retirement plan.

The Lords has a problem with legitimacy. Our job is to tidy bills up and to tell ministers that they are about to do something stupid, but we can’t stop that stupid thing from happening. Sometimes this system works: recently the government accepted one of my amendments to their counter-terrorism bill that will ensure greater protection for journalists.

Ultimately, we need a smaller, more efficient House of Lords where people turn up to do a job of work to ensure that the right legislation is passed. That ideal scenario still seems a long way off.
Jenny Jones
Green, House of Lords

• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters

• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The party interests that have stalled Lords reform | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to John Harris’s article about cash for peerages, and the long road to reform of the second chamber


16, Nov, 2021 @6:10 PM

Article image
Trade bill fails to protect environmental standards | Letter
Letter: Green party peer Jenny Jones says her amendment to the bill would ensure that existing standards become the foundation for future trade deals


12, Mar, 2019 @6:04 PM

Article image
A move to the north and other ideas to reform the House of Lords | Letters
Letters: Manchester would be a more obvious choice to bring the regions together, writes Bernard Porter, while Colin Challen MP says the plan is just pointless theatrics. Plus letters from Roy King, Richard Clark, Tony Greaves and Colin Hulley


23, Jan, 2020 @6:23 PM

Article image
Prevent and political judgments by police | Letter from Jenny Jones
Letter: Parliament, rather than the police, should define who is and is not a domestic extremist, says Green party peer Jenny Jones


14, Feb, 2019 @6:11 PM

Article image
The House of Lords needs trimming but still has a vital role to play | Letters
Letters: The Lord Speaker, Norman Fowler, says that work to reduce the size of the House of Lords is under way; Darren Hughes rails against the partisan nature of the house; plus letters from Rob Parrish and Susan Newton


02, May, 2018 @4:43 PM

Article image
The House of Lords’ vital work must continue | Letter from Norman Fowler
Letters: Digital advances mean that members can continue to question ministers and that opportunity should be taken, writes Lord Speaker Norman Fowler


09, Apr, 2020 @6:03 PM

Article image
Top-secret court to weigh ban on MI5 and GCHQ spying on MPs in public
Investigatory Powers Tribunal will hold public hearing brought by Greens on Wilson Doctrine, which bans spying on parliament

Ian Cobain

01, Jul, 2014 @8:02 PM

Article image
My first year in the House of Lords
As the only Green party member in the House of Lords, Jenny Jones is baffled by the etiquette – and wonders if she will ever fit in

As told to Hannah Marriott

22, Dec, 2013 @6:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Brexit and the Lords: power to examine | Editorial
Editorial: The British government cannot expect peers to rubber-stamp its EU timetable


17, Nov, 2016 @7:21 PM

Article image
How to fix a broken parliamentary system | Letters
Letters: Readers air their views on the UK’s constitutional crisis over Brexit


28, Mar, 2019 @6:22 PM