Politicians’ mishandling of education is a national disgrace | Letters

Barry Dufour on the complexity of schools provision; Karen Barratt on radical action; Simon Gibbs on a moral purpose for education; Colin Richards on dangerous talk of ‘broken schools’; Michael Bassey on trust in teachers

Yet again Melissa Benn speaks with eloquence and wisdom about our fractured education system in England (Our schools are broken. Only radical action will fix them, 9 August). There is a need for a structural overhaul of this confusing complexity of provision, which I find impossible to explain to my overseas friends.

Yes, the obsession with metrics and bean-counting at the heart of it, as part of a globalised competitive system, needs to be confronted as harmful and restrictive for staff and students, but so too does the influence this has on the internal regimes in our schools, which increasingly resemble prisons with their compulsory school uniforms for the inmates and authoritarian regimes (designed to ensure compliance to achieve results), with some practices worthy of an appeal to the Equality and Human Rights Commission.

So I hope Melissa Benn’s forthcoming book and the pending Labour party review of education will address the impact of the external and structural issues on the internal life of our schools, where there is well-documented evidence of significant and rising levels of stress for staff and students.
Dr Barry Dufour
Visiting professor of education studies, De Montfort University

• I’m not sure what Melissa Benn means when she refers to “uncritical acceptance” of the official claims made about academies and free schools. For those of us on the left it was clear from the start that the policy was designed to remove local control of education and create a two-tier system. Academisation was privatisation in all but name, with the predictable effect of transferring public money into private hands.

Initially, before the failures and bankruptcies began to hit the headlines, we were bombarded with good news stories about academies that prospered at the expense of schools still in local council control, which had to rely more and more on parent-teacher association fundraising for essential items. Pouring money into academies and free schools was clearly a divide-and-rule strategy in an already elitist education system.

Radical action should start with removing charitable status from public schools. They are not charities, they are businesses charging enormous fees and making money from other ventures, including land speculation. It is a scandal that they are allowed to avoid tax and business rates while state schools continue to struggle through funding cuts and the inevitable staff demoralisation.
Karen Barratt
Winchester, Hampshire

• Melissa Benn is undoubtedly right. However, I fear the solutions she offers lack a long-term aim. As I have tried to argue in a recent book, Immoral Education: The Assault on Teachers’ Identities, Autonomy and Efficacy, we lack an agreed moral purpose for education. As a result teachers, children, young people and the future citizens of a democratic society remain vulnerable to the vicissitudes of political and economic policies.

The results are, as Melissa Benn recognises, a demoralised workforce that is voting with its feet (more teachers leave than enter the profession) and young people who are denied an education that might help them learn how to be human beings (increasing and disproportionate numbers of young people being permanently excluded from school).

What is happening to education is criminal, and we do need radical action. The necessary change should, however, be informed by an agreed moral purpose, not merely a laudable reaction to present government policies.
Dr Simon Gibbs
Reader in educational psychology, Newcastle University

• Our schools aren’t “broken”; students are still learning; teachers are still teaching; and state schools are still good places to live and learn in – for the most part. I don’t recognise the picture gaudily painted in the article. I fear that, if they are convinced by it, middle-class Guardian readers will be anxiously scouring websites to find places in the independent sector for their offspring.

This is not to deny that our educational system has been badly served by governments, especially during this decade, or that the changes advocated would not be beneficial. But talk of “broken schools” is dangerous, misleading hyperbole.
Professor Colin Richards
Spark Bridge, Cumbria

• Melissa Benn’s coruscating and justified assault on the political changes made to our education system should be sent to every MP by constituent parents and grandparents with the questions “How did you let this happen?” and “What are you doing about it?”.

It is a national disgrace that the future of our children has been so mishandled.

Reform of our education system by restoring trust in teachers must also reflect on what the world may be like in, say, 30 years’ time when today’s schoolchildren will be in the prime of their lives. As the Guardian has warned readers, “Millions fear being replaced by machines, study finds” (6 August) and “This [extreme global weather] is the face of climate change, say scientists” (28 July).

Schools should engage with local communities on these issues and devise appropriate curricula: building stronger local communities might be identified on the grounds that when adverse environmental conditions rage, neighbourly support is vital. Also preparing for more leisure time would be worthwhile, including learning how to grow some foods!
Michael Bassey 
Emeritus professor of education, Nottingham Trent University

• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters

• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with other Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread in our print edition


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
An ambitious overhaul of education is needed | Letters
Letters: The Conservative One Nation group’s report on schooling doesn’t go far enough, according to Greg Brooks and Steven Burkeman, while Ruth Eversley ponders a career recommendation


12, Oct, 2020 @4:28 PM

Article image
Priorities for a National Education Service | Letters
Letters: Readers including Martin Lennon, head of policy for the Children’s Commissioner for England, come up with a variety of ideas for improving schools


06, Sep, 2018 @5:35 PM

Article image
Damage and disillusion caused by A-level downgrades | Letters
Letters: Retired headteacher Mary Smith says Boris Johnson cannot possibly think the marking system has been robust and fair, Chris Pratt calls for common sense, and Syeda Nooresahar Ahmad wonders why she was downgraded in all three A-level subjects. Plus letters from an anonymous former headteacher and Howard Falshaw


14, Aug, 2020 @2:54 PM

Article image
Shortsighted approach to transforming schools in England | Letters
Letters: Readers react to Gavin Williamson’s proposals for education reform, suggesting ways to bring about real change and highlighting the merits of a five-term academic year


08, Mar, 2021 @5:27 PM

Article image
Forget Sats – find a true measure of education | Letters
Letters: Clive Stafford Smith says Sats are irrelevant to his son’s life and Mary Bousted defends Labour’s proposed assessment reforms, while Ann Moore and Richard Wetherell highlight the negative effects of tests


15, May, 2019 @4:54 PM

Article image
Education secretary’s empty boast on school funding | Letters
Letters: Gill Vincent, Shaun Soper and Mike Lee on Gillian Keegan saying that the Tories are doing their best for teachers and schools

01, Dec, 2022 @6:28 PM

Article image
Conservative education plans branded ‘election gimmicks’
Headteachers say extra tests would break staff morale and Lib Dems claim Tories cannot be trusted to protect spending on schools

Rowena Mason and Richard Adams

02, Feb, 2015 @12:02 AM

Article image
Funding and staff levels in schools at crisis point | Letters
Letters: School governors urge the government to ‘stop ducking its responsibilities’ and provide essential funding


11, Mar, 2019 @6:21 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on calls to reopen schools: a dangerous distraction | Editorial
Editorial: With more than 1,000 deaths from Covid every day for weeks, talk of looser restrictions is reckless. The prime minister should ignore his backbenchers


25, Jan, 2021 @7:08 PM

Article image
The malign effects of coalition education policy in England’s schools | Letters: Frank Field MP, Cathy Wood, Michael Pyke, Fiona Carnie, Rev Canon David Jennings and others
Letters: It may be that all the chaos and confusion have simply provided an effective smokescreen for the primary purpose of the piecemeal privatisation of state education in our country

03, Feb, 2015 @7:51 PM