Priti Patel forced to resign over unofficial meetings with Israelis

Theresa May loses second cabinet minister in a week as pro-Brexit international development secretary departs

Priti Patel’s resignation letter and Theresa May’s response – in full

Theresa May’s government was rocked on Wednesday by a second cabinet resignation in a week after Priti Patel was forced to step down as international development secretary.

The minister quit after being summoned back from a trip to Uganda and Ethiopia by Downing Street after it emerged she failed to be candid with May about 14 unofficial meetings with Israeli ministers, businesspeople and a senior lobbyist.

The prime minister will now need to carry out another reshuffle that will create disruption and add to the sense of instability across Whitehall and Westminster as her minority government battles to retain control of the political agenda.

May and Patel met for just six minutes in the early evening. In her resignation letter, released moments after she left No 10, Patel admitted her actions “fell below the high standards that are expected of a secretary of state”.

The prime minister said Patel’s decision was the correct one. She argued in a letter to the former cabinet minister that the UK and Israel were close allies and should work closely together.

“But that must be done formally, and through official channels. That is why, when we met on Monday, I was glad to accept your apology and welcomed your clarification about your trip to Israel over the summer.”

But she added: “Now that further details have come to light, it is right that you have decided to resign and adhere to the high standards of transparency and openness that you have advocated.”

13 August 2017

Priti Patel goes to Israel on what she claims was a family holiday, which she paid for herself.

22 August 2017

Patel met the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu. The meeting was not authorised in advance and no UK officials were present. She later claimed the Foreign Office was made aware of this meetings and others while her trip was under way.

Meanwhile, Patel’s deputy Alistair Burt and David Quarrey, the British ambassador to Israel, were meeting Michael Oren, a deputy minister at the Israeli prime minister’s office, according to the Jewish Chronicle. According to notes of the meeting, cited by the paper, Oren referred to Patel having had a successful meeting with Netanyahu earlier.

24 August 2017

Foreign Office officials became aware of Patel’s first meetings, according to a statement given to the Commons by Burt on 7 November. He did not mention his own visit to Israel. Hansard quotes Burt telling the Commons: “The Secretary of State [Patel] told Foreign Office officials on 24 August that she was on the visit. It seems likely that the meetings took place beforehand.”

On the same day Patel met Yair Lapid, the leader of Israel’s Yesh Atid party, who describes her as a “true friend of Israel”. 

August 2017

On an undisclosed date during her trip, Patel visited an Israeli military field hospital in the occupied Golan Heights, according to the Israeli newspaper Haaretz. If confirmed, this would be a breach of a protocol that British officials do not travel in the occupied Golan under the auspices of the Israeli government.

25 August 2017

Patel leaves Israel after 12 work meetings, during two days of a 13-day holiday. As well as meeting Netanyahu, she also held talks with the public security and strategic affairs minister, Gilad Erdan, and an Israeli foreign ministry official, Yuval Rotem. The meetings were organised by Lord Polak, a leading member of the Conservative Friends of Israel. He accompanied Patel on all but one one of the meetings.

On her return to the UK, Patel inquires about using the UK aid budget to help fund the Israeli army’s humanitarian work in the Golan Heights. The idea is rejected because the UK does not recognise Israel’s permanent presence in the Golan Heights, which were seized from Syria in the 1967 war.

7 September 2017

Patel meets Gilad Erdan, the minister for public security, and is photographed with him on the House of Commons terrace.

18 September 2017

While in New York for the UN general assembly, Patel has another meeting with Yuval Rotem, an official from the Israeli foreign ministry.

2 November 2017

Theresa May meets Netanyahu in Downing Street.

3 November 2017

Patel told the Guardian that the foreign secretary knew about her trip and suggested the Foreign Office had been briefing against her. “Boris knew about the visit. The point is that the Foreign Office did know about this, Boris knew about [the trip],” she admitted telling the paper.

The BBC’s diplomatic correspondent James Landale reported that Patel had undisclosed meetings in Israel without telling the Foreign Office. He quoted one official as saying that Patel had been “pushing to get her hands on the Palestinian Authority aid budget and we have been pushing back”.

6 November 2017

Patel apologises after admitting she gave a misleading account to the Guardian of her trip to Israel. In a statement, she admits holding 12 meetings, including three with Israeli politicians – Netanyahu among them.

She said: “This quote [to the Guardian] may have given the impression that the secretary of state had informed the foreign secretary about the visit in advance. The secretary of state would like to take this opportunity to clarify that this was not the case. The foreign secretary did become aware of the visit, but not in advance of it.”

She does not mention visiting the occupied Golan Heights or the two subsequent meetings in September.

A No 10 spokesman confirms that Patel was rebuked for breaching the ministerial code.

7 November 2017

Patel avoids answering an urgent Commons question about her meetings in Israel because of a “longstanding commitment” to visit Kenya, Uganda and Ethiopia. The international development minister Alistair Burt is put up in her place. Burt points out that Patel apologised for the undisclosed meetings. He adds: “The department’s view is that aid to the IDF [Israeli Defence Force] in the Golan Heights is not appropriate.”

Downing Street initially backs Patel but later confirms that the prime minister was not informed about providing aid to Israel during her meeting the previous day. It is suggested Patel failed to disclose her two subsequent meetings in September with Israeli officials. A Whitehall source says: “There was an expectation of full disclosure at the meeting on Monday. It is now clear Priti did not do that. It will now have to be looked at again.” But according to the Jewish Chronicle, it was No 10 who told Patel not to include her meeting with Rotem in New York in her list of undisclosed meetings for fear of embarrassing the Foreign Office.

DfiD confirms previously undisclosed September meetings with Erhad and Rotem in September.

8 November 2017

Patel resigns from the cabinet after being summoned back from a trip to Uganda and Ethiopia by Downing Street. In her resignation letter, released moments after she left No 10, Patel admitted her actions “fell below the high standards that are expected of a secretary of state”.

Six days of revelations about Patel’s meetings dominated headlines. On Monday it emerged that she had spoken to the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, in August in a meeting that May did not know about and with no officials present. Thirteen meetings were held in the presence of Lord Polak, an experienced Tory lobbyist.

The move piles pressure onto May’s government following a string of controversies. The sex harassment scandal has already resulted in the resignation of the defence secretary, Michael Fallon, while one of the prime minister’s closest allies, Damian Green, is being investigated by the Cabinet office over allegations. Meanwhile there have been calls for May to sack her foreign secretary, Boris Johnson, after an intervention risked lengthening the sentence of a British woman jailed in Iran.

The development will also be seen as a blow for Brexiters, for whom Patel is a standard bearer. She was also the only minority ethnic woman in the cabinet. Patel could become an outspoken backbencher and help exert pressure on May from the pro-Brexit wing of the party. MPs supportive of Patel claimed she had been subjected to a Foreign Office “hatchet job” – claiming that senior individuals in Johnson’s department had briefed against her.

A replacement for Patel was expected to be announced on Thursday. One senior MP said that May would be determined to maintain “balance” within her cabinet, both in terms of gender and the divide between ministers who backed the leave and remain campaigns in the EU referendum.

Names under discussion include Penny Mordaunt, the welfare minister who was a prominent campaigner for out, and Andrea Leadsom, the pro-Brexit leader of the House of Commons. Remainers who could be in line for promotion include Claire Perry, the climate change minister, and Alistair Burt, whose current brief spans the Department for International Development and the Foreign Office.

Patel’s return to Britain on a flight from Nairobi, Kenya, had been closely followed on the internet and in the media, with broadcasters even airing pictures of the plane she had been travelling in as it landed.

It appeared that the MP for Witham had broken ministerial rules when the BBC disclosed on Friday that she met politicians and businessmen from Israel while on holiday in August without informing departmental officials, the FCO or Downing Street in advance.

In an interview with the Guardian on the same day, she made misleading claims that Johnson had been aware of the meetings and that FCO mandarins had briefed against her.

Patel told the Guardian: “Boris knew about the visit. The point is that the Foreign Office did know about this, Boris knew about [the trip]. It is not on, it is not on at all. I went out there, I paid for it. And there is nothing else to this. It is quite extraordinary.”

But on Monday she was forced to apologise and withdraw her claims about the FCO and Johnson after a meeting with May. She also admitted that she had held 12 meetings in Israel with officials, businessmen, Netanyahu and the country’s security minister.

Patel’s downfall was triggered by a failure to be entirely candid with the prime minister on Monday. It is understood that Patel told May in person that there were no other revelations due to emerge about her visit.

But her reassurances collapsed on Tuesday when it emerged that DfID officials had been asked to explore whether it would be feasible to send UK aid money to the Israeli army for humanitarian work in the occupied Golan Heights.

Her fate was sealed late on Tuesday after Downing Street confirmed that Patel had two further unauthorised meetings with senior Israeli officials after her return from Israel.

Gilad Erdan, the Israeli security minister, met Patel in parliament on 7 September. She also saw Yuval Rotem, an official from the Israeli foreign ministry, for a meeting at the UN general assembly in New York. Polak was present at both meetings.

The Israeli newspaper Haaretz claimed on Wednesday that Patel had visited an Israeli military field hospital in the Golan Heights, a disputed area that the UK does not recognise, and failed to declare it. DfID said it could neither confirm nor deny the report.

Downing Street insisted that May knew nothing about Patel’s meetings until the controversy broke in the media late last week.

However, Burt said in the Commons that the British embassy, FCO and DfID had been informed on 24 August, immediately after the meetings took place and while Patel was still in the country.

Neither the FCO nor DfID were able to explain why No 10 had not been informed.

Patel’s resignation will prompt further calls from the Conservative right to merge DfID with the FCO.

Johnson appeared to make a play for his department to absorb DfID last month, saying it was a “colossal mistake in the 1990s to divide the Department for International Development from the Foreign Office”.

Labour’s Tom Watson claimed that he had been informed of a further meeting by Patel during her holiday with officials from the British consulate general in Jerusalem, suggesting the government had been formally notified of the situation.

“The existence of such a meeting or meetings would call into question the official account of Ms Patel’s behaviour, and the purpose of her visit,” wrote Watson in a letter to the prime minister last night, which listed a series of fresh questions.

The development comes seven days after Sir Michael Fallon resigned as defence secretary over accusations of inappropriate behaviour towards women, which he categorically denies.

Damian Green, May’s righthand man, remains under investigation by the Cabinet Office for alleged inappropriate behaviour towards a female activist and for allegations connected to claims that pornography was found on a laptop seized by police. He denies both of these claims.

May’s administration has been hit by a series of crises since she lost her House of Commons majority in June.


Rajeev Syal and Anushka Asthana

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Priti Patel forced to resign over meetings with Israeli officials – Politics live
International development secretary becomes second cabinet minister in a week to quit

Patrick Greenfield (now), Andrew Sparrow, Jessica Elgot and Claire Phipps (earlier)

08, Nov, 2017 @10:44 PM

Article image
Priti Patel accused of overshadowing Middle East minister's mission
Alistair Burt failed to be granted access to the most senior Israeli politicians because of unofficial trip by former international development secretary

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

09, Nov, 2017 @6:55 PM

Article image
May prepares for second reshuffle in a week as Priti Patel departs
PM under pressure to replace minister with another Eurosceptic as Labour raises questions about Israel meetings

Jessica Elgot Political reporter

09, Nov, 2017 @9:42 AM

Article image
Penny Mordaunt replaces Priti Patel in May's cabinet
Pro-Brexit disabilities minister promoted to international development secretary after Patel quit over Israel row

Jessica Elgot Political reporter

09, Nov, 2017 @3:31 PM

Article image
Priti Patel accuses Foreign Office of briefing against her over Israel meetings
Development secretary says officials wrong to claim she had not told them about talks in August accompanied by lobbyist

Rajeev Syal and Harriet Sherwood

03, Nov, 2017 @3:31 PM

Article image
Priti Patel summoned back to UK as PM prepares to sack her
Minister flies back from Africa trip as Israeli media reports she visited Golan Heights as guest of Israel, in breach of protocol

Matthew Weaver, Rajeev Syal, Anushka Asthana and Peter Beaumont

08, Nov, 2017 @1:11 PM

Article image
Priti Patel clinging on after details of more Israel meetings emerge
International development secretary failed to inform PM about discussions on plan to send funds to Israeli army

Rajeev Syal, Peter Walker and Peter Beaumont

08, Nov, 2017 @12:41 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on Boris Johnson and Priti Patel: incompetent, insubordinate and still in office | Editorial
Editorial: Theresa May’s weakness as prime minister has allowed her most ambitious ministers to do their own thing


07, Nov, 2017 @7:19 PM

Article image
Priti Patel: an outspoken Brexiter who went too quietly to Israel
The fierce campaigner branded ‘a modern-day Norman Tebbit’ may have blown her chances of leading the Conservative party

Anushka Asthana Political editor

08, Nov, 2017 @12:31 PM

Article image
Priti Patel plans foreign aid overhaul based on 'core Tory values'
International development minister says too much of Britain’s aid money is wasted, stolen or spent poorly

Ben Quinn

14, Sep, 2016 @12:06 AM