Brexit: UK backing away from threat to leave with no deal, say EU diplomats

UK officials recognise that failure to agree post-Brexit trade deal with EU27 would cause havoc, according to EU sources

European diplomats based in the UK say the British government is stepping back from its threat to leave the EU without a trade deal if negotiations break down.

In private, say diplomats, UK officials recognise the “havoc” that this would cause, and have come to regret the threat to turn the UK into a deregulated offshore tax haven, implicit in Theresa May’s Lancaster House speech in January, when she warned that “no deal for Britain is better than a bad deal”.

They claim the conciliatory signals from UK government officials are an attempt to lower the temperature asthe prime minister prepares to send the UK’s article 50 letter on Wednesday, triggering the start of two years of intensive Brexit negotiations.

Many EU diplomats told the UK government in the wake of May’s Lancaster House speech that the threat jarred with the tone of the rest of what she said, and had made it harder to build a political consensus for a deal in Europe.

One UK-based ambassador, with deep knowledge of the European Union, said: “They [British ministers] have realised that ‘no deal is better than a bad deal’ won’t fly. They are worried about people in this country who have an ideological and political intention of creating chaos. The civil service have told them it would create havoc.”

The EU diplomats revealed their anxiety that May has been too willing to bend to the prevailing wind with some of her own backbenchers and the Brexit-supporting press, setting up expectations that they believe she will struggle to meet.

One source said the decision of Michel Barnier, the EU chief negotiator, to be as open as possible about the talks is in part an attempt to educate the UK public about the dangers of not reaching a deal, and leaving the bloc on what is known as World Trade Organisation terms.

“It is not possible to overestimate the threat the UK press poses to reaching a deal. We have to counteract that by being open,” said one diplomat.

In briefings given to EU diplomats, British civil servants and ministers have told the EU governments not to expect anything substantially new in the article 50 letter when it is delivered on Wednesday, although there may be some clarification about the extent to which the government is willing to countenance a transitional deal or implementation phase.

The diplomats added that for the first time there have been hints from the UK government suggesting they might accept a continued role for the European court of justice as arbiter in any transition, a point emphasised by Barnier in his speech last week. The issue of the jurisdiction during a transition, although not fundamental to the final deal, is likely to be one of the most difficult to negotiate, as it could mean May having to accept that the UK will still be subject to the jurisdiction of the ECJ at the time of the next general election in 2020.

EU sources said it would not be possible for trade disputes between the UK and the EU over the single market rules to be decided by the UK supreme court.

The source said that in private UK civil servants accepted “that the UK, as part of a transitional arrangement, could stay in the customs union for a limited period of time. But they don’t want to go public on this.” Civil servants have acknowledged that the number of goods that would need to be tracked would rise from 17m to 350m a year.

The diplomats also predicted that the UK was likely to change its rhetoric towards immigration, suggesting that the British realised that strict limits on immigration were a bad idea for British society and the economy, and there was a need to focus more on control and not quantitative limits. “They will talk themselves out of the 100,000 [limit] thing,” one diplomat said.

David Davis suggests EU immigration won’t necessarily go down after Brexit

Diplomats point out the number of migrants likely to be seeking to enter the UK from the EU is set to decline since growth is picking up on the continent and there will be greater competition for labour.

The sources added that they had been told to expect the first round of negotiations to focus on technical issues of how the talks will be conducted. Thereafter, the issues of the Irish border, citizens’ rights and the bill for the divorce settlement are expected to dominate discussions until after the German elections in September.

The diplomats insist that the EU will not be raising a specific sum that needs to be reimbursed by the UK, but instead will talk about the principles underlying any calculation. The money is “peanuts in the big picture”, the source added.

Diplomats insist EU countries will refuse to discuss giving the UK access to their markets post-Brexit until Britain reveals whether it will discriminate against EU goods.


Patrick Wintour Diplomatic Editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Brexit deal 'a week away' but May must agree on customs union, says Barnier
Deal could be done by next Wednesday but PM must abandon red line, says EU negotiator

Daniel Boffey and Jennifer Rankin

10, Oct, 2018 @5:05 PM

Article image
Theresa May's speech to warn EU of risk of giving UK a raw Brexit deal
PM is expected to build on chancellor’s combative language by highlighting other potentially lucrative deals Britain can seek

Heather Stewart Political editor and Philip Oltermann in Berlin

15, Jan, 2017 @7:04 PM

Article image
UK cannot have a special deal for the City, says EU's Brexit negotiator
Michel Barnier’s stark declaration quashes hopes for a bespoke trade deal to include financial services

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

18, Dec, 2017 @9:00 PM

Article image
Get Brexit deal fast, business leaders to tell Theresa May
Senior representatives to warn prime minister that firms will assume and act on worst case scenario if no transition deal is achieved soon

Dan Roberts and Daniel Boffey in Brussels

10, Nov, 2017 @12:37 AM

Article image
Royals to serve as extras in Donald Trump’s victory lap of UK
US president to use state visit to promote House of Trump as he doubles down on Brexit bet

Julian Borger in Washington

02, Jun, 2019 @8:06 AM

Article image
The Guardian view of Boris Johnson’s Brexit vision: all about me | Editorial
Editorial: It was billed as a Valentine’s Day letter to remainers. But the foreign secretary’s love affair with himself got in the way


14, Feb, 2018 @5:37 PM

Article image
Cabinet accepts Brexit transition will mean years of free movement
Senior source tells Guardian mood has shifted under pressure from British businesses to secure a workable deal

Jessica Elgot and Rowena Mason

20, Jul, 2017 @9:00 PM

Article image
UK Brexit boost as ECJ rules trade deals do not require extra ratification
Surprise ruling confirms EU officials have key negotiation powers in trade talks with approval of state parliaments not needed

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels, and Dan Roberts

16, May, 2017 @1:07 PM

Article image
Eight key points you need to know about the Brexit negotiations
Civil servants have noted 700 areas that need untangling before the UK can leave the EU. Here is the distilled version

Dan Roberts Brexit policy editor

29, Mar, 2017 @5:30 AM

Article image
EU prepares for a no-deal Brexit amid lack of progress on talks
EU seminars will cover citizens’ rights, transport, border controls and financial services

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

31, Oct, 2018 @10:24 AM