Amber Rudd seeks more EU action over online extremism

Green MEP Jan Philipp Albrecht says home secretary’s ideas would ‘dramatically weaken internet security’

Amber Rudd has called for more EU action to tackle online extremism, as she steps up pressure on tech firms to make it harder for terrorists to use the internet.

Meeting her EU counterparts in Brussels, just days before Britain embarks on its European divorce by triggering article 50, the home secretary reiterated her message that internet companies needed to be more proactive in efforts to combat terrorism.

Rudd did not name specific companies, but on Sunday she called for police and intelligence services to be given access to WhatsApp and other encrypted messaging services, a proposal criticised by one leading MEP as disproportionate and dangerous.

Jan Philipp Albrecht, a German Green, who is a vice-chair of the European parliament’s civil liberties and justice committee, said Rudd’s WhatsApp idea would “dramatically weaken internet security”.

The MEP, a privacy campaigner, said allowing security services to access encrypted messages would open the door to hackers, escalating “the potential to misuse ... and to hurt and harm”.

Albrecht warned against handing authorities sweeping surveillance powers. He said security services already had means of detecting keystrokes and recording voice calls of terrorist suspects under warrant. “What you cannot do is have no limit and say everyone needs to be under surveillance or under the possibility to decrypt everything,” he said.

Rudd made her points in a brief statement at the end of the one-day meeting and the issue was not debated. She also discussed the UK’s own specialist unit dedicated to removing terrorist material from the internet.

Her calls to allow security forces to unlock WhatsApp are likely to get a sympathetic hearing from her EU counterparts. France and Germany said last year technology companies should be compelled to ensure encrypted content was available to terrorism investigators. The French government has called for an EU law, although so far no plans have been drawn up. A spokesman for the European commission, which proposes all EU laws, said nothing had been ruled out.

Matthias Fekl, France’s interior minister, said the attack on London was an attack on democracy. “We are going together to strengthen even more our cooperation on security on the struggle against terrorism,” he said, describing London and Paris as “two magnificent European cities that have been attacked by terrorist barbarism”.

After the 28 ministers held a one-minute’s silence to remember the victims of the Westminster attacks, Rudd said she had been struck by messages of support from her EU colleagues. “The threat we face is an international one and preventing these attacks is a common aim,” she said. “I want to make it clear that the UK is, and will continue to be, a strong, reliable and committed partner in the fight against terrorism and other threats to our security.”

The police minister, Brandon Lewis, will hold more detailed talks in Brussels on Tuesday on cybersecurity and Rudd has summoned technology companies to a meeting on Thursday.

Dimitris Avramopoulos, the EU home affairs commissioner, said the EU would be redoubling its work in the coming months, as the London attacks showed that “homegrown radicalisation ... was one of our biggest challenges”. He met bosses of Twitter, Facebook and YouTube in California earlier this month to discuss an existing EU-led voluntary scheme to remove terrorist content from the internet.

The scheduled EU meetings come just before the British government launches the formal EU exit process. The article 50 exit clause is silent on security issues, but Brexit is likely to require painstaking renegotiation of multiple accords on police cooperation and crime-fighting.


Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
WhatsApp must be accessible to authorities, says Amber Rudd
Critics say home secretary’s demand for access to encrypted messaging to thwart terrorists is unrealistic and disproportionate

Andrew Sparrow Political correspondent

26, Mar, 2017 @8:29 PM

Article image
Call for encryption ban pits Rudd against industry and colleagues
A previous plan to ban end-to-end encryption was dropped after widespread opposition, including from David Davis

Alan Travis Home affairs editor

26, Mar, 2017 @3:45 PM

Article image
Calls for backdoor access to WhatsApp as Five Eyes nations meet
Countries focus on increasingly effective encryption of communications

Dan Sabbagh Defence and security editor

30, Jul, 2019 @7:32 PM

Article image
No 10 repeats Rudd's call for authorities to access encrypted messages
Downing Street backs home secretary’s call for agencies to have access to WhatsApp and other encrypted messaging apps

Peter Walker and Heather Stewart

27, Mar, 2017 @12:56 PM

Article image
Amber Rudd to tell tech firms: do more to combat terrorism
Home secretary summons Google, Microsoft, Twitter and Facebook for discussion on encrypted messages and extremist propaganda

Kevin Rawlinson

30, Mar, 2017 @5:00 AM

Article image
Top tech firms avoid encryption issue in government talks
Executives commit to removing extremist material but do not address Amber Rudd’s concerns after Westminster attack

Peter Walker Political correspondent

30, Mar, 2017 @7:18 PM

Article image
UK may force Facebook services to allow backdoor police access
End-to-end encryption could be challenged with security agencies enabled to monitor user messages

Dan Sabbagh

01, Apr, 2021 @5:26 PM

Article image
WhatsApp design feature means some encrypted messages could be read by third party
Trade-off between security and usability unlikely to permit systematic surveillance, experts say

Guardian staff

13, Jan, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on counter-terrorism: strong encryption makes us all safer | Editorial
Editorial: There are many things the web giants could do to help combat terrorism, but weakening privacy protection is not one of them


27, Mar, 2017 @6:51 PM

Article image
EU seeks to outlaw 'backdoors' in new data privacy proposals
Draft report from European parliament clashes with UK government calls to allow access to encrypted communications from WhatsApp and others

Samuel Gibbs

19, Jun, 2017 @3:36 PM