'A recipe for chaos': UK Brexit plan provokes alarm along Irish border

Business people on two sides of border express concern about prospect of ‘back door’ to EU and lack of clarity

Until last June there was nothing to observe on the border between the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland except a change in the colour of markings on the verge of the road from yellow to white. But 14 months after the UK voted to leave the European Union, giant billboards calling for “no EU frontier in Ireland” and “no hard border” mark the divide between the countries.

The concern on both sides of the open 310-mile (499km) border is whether the signs represent just the beginning, a change made worse by an air of mistrust of all politicians.

Hugh Morgan, who has a dairy farm that straddles both sides of the border in Carrickarnon but also runs a fuel business for hauliers in 16 countries, complained that people like him were ignored.

“We are the people who will be affected: we employ 80 people here on the border, we are putting bread on the table, and not one politician, from Dublin, Stormont, Westminster, Brussels or the local council, has come here to ask people like us how is it going to affect us, or do we need help,” he says.

Morgan describes Brexit as just another challenge for business, arguing “no matter what, business people will have to adapt”, but wonders if the process will ever be concluded because it so complicated.

“I’m not living in oblivion, but there will another election, then European elections, then more negotiations with another set of politicians. I can’t see this ever happening because it will take 20 to 30 years to get straight.”Andy Lecky, a truck driver, who is taking a break at the derelict customs inspection post on the south of the border, stressed the importance of north-south negotiation. “I think Brexit could be a good thing if they would knuckle down instead of fighting everybody.

“This scaremongering about the border isn’t helping anyone. If only Ireland and England could just work together and stop fighting. I don’t think this hardline stance helps anyone,” he says.

On this point there is wide agreement among locals: a hard border is in nobody’s interests. But it is not clear whether the British government’s desire to retain a largely invisible border is realistic.

Conor Patterson, chief executive of the northern Irish Newry and Mourne Entreprise Agency, describes the paper as “strong on aspiration” but “weak on deliverability”.

He welcomes the British proposal to mirror customs arrangements with the EU in order to exempt small businesses from customs checks on the border but says this amounts to staying in the EU customs union. “If it walks like the customs union, talks like the customs union, which it does, then why not just commit to the customs union?” he asks.

Morgan makes the additional point that it is misleading to assume the border is invisible today. His cross-border farm is essentially divided in two – one south and one north of the border. Under EU law he cannot move cows registered as grazing in the north to the Republic, because of strict controls on moving livestock to stop cross-border infection such as foot and mouth disease and swine flu.

A few miles south of the the border, Paddy Malone, the president of Dundalk chamber of commerce, said the “British elite” had no idea what they were landing Ireland with and should have started working on the programme three years ago.

Malone said there was “merit” in the British government’s proposed trusted trader scheme but said the proposal to exempt small business from a host of customs regulations was “a recipe for chaos”, facilitating everything from smuggling of alcohol and cigarettes to hormone-treated beef that may find its way onto Northern Irish supermarket shelves as a cheap alternative to homegrown food.

“It will be a back door in and out of the EU and that cannot be allowed to exist,” said Malone. “Who would regulate or police that? “The answer is the European court of justice. So, congratulations Britain, you are right back in the EU. Britain has not figured out how to square the circle, because the circle cannot be squared.”


Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK accused of 'magical thinking' over Brexit plan for Irish border
Britain’s call for ‘flexible solutions’ as it pursues goal of avoiding border posts with Ireland leaves EU officials rolling their eyes

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

25, Aug, 2017 @6:03 PM

Article image
Brexit: Varadkar and May to work on plan for frictionless Irish border
Leaders of Ireland and UK seek deal that does not need Northern Ireland to be in single market

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

12, Feb, 2018 @7:31 PM

Article image
Brexit threat causes alarm among Northern Irish border communities
Suggestions of a hardening of the border and fears over the peace process among reasons why remain is well ahead in region

Esther Addley in Newry

08, Jun, 2016 @6:30 PM

Article image
EU's Brexit vision plan likely to be delayed over doubts at No 10
PM’s spokesman puts dampener on optimism of Brussels officials about talks

Daniel Boffey and Jennifer Rankin in Brussels and Lisa O'Carroll

08, Oct, 2018 @5:41 PM

Article image
Technology cannot make post-Brexit Irish border frictionless, says academic
Analysis of various Brexit outcomes concludes some check and stops will be necessary

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

07, Mar, 2018 @2:34 PM

Article image
Brexit minister says UK not trying to move checks to Irish border
Lord Frost says triggering article 16 remains an option but he is hopeful of deal on Northern Ireland

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

17, Nov, 2021 @9:43 AM

Article image
UK to seek Irish border waivers on customs and food safety after Brexit
Britain reveals plan to ask for exemptions for all small traders and farmers as it pursues goal of avoiding EU border posts

Dan Roberts, Jennifer Rankin and Henry McDonald

16, Aug, 2017 @10:17 PM

Article image
Dominic Raab to face hard questions about Irish border on US visit
Foreign secretary will have to allay fears over the Good Friday agreement and the rule of law

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

15, Sep, 2020 @1:05 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson's plans for Irish border checks threaten Brexit talks
Downing Street banks on secretive ‘tunnel’ negotiations to hammer out agreement

Daniel Boffey and Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

01, Oct, 2019 @10:13 PM

Article image
Zero-tariff plan for Irish border could face WTO legal threat, says Gove
Environment secretary admits other nations could have a case against no-deal Brexit proposal

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

27, Mar, 2019 @1:56 PM