Labour MP Stella Creasy attacks Momentum movement

Walthamstow MP claims grassroots group is more interested in ‘meetings and moralising’ than real campaigning

Labour MP Stella Creasy has launched an attack on Momentum, the grassroots group of Jeremy Corbyn supporters, accusing its activists of trying to deselect members of parliament and draining energy out of the political process.

Creasy, who came second in Labour’s deputy leadership race, also claimed the group was more interested in “meetings and moralising” than real campaigning.

Despite Momentum repeatedly saying it does not support attempts to oust sitting MPs, she said there was an “emphasis by some in these groups on controlling the levers of power to select – or deselect – MPs and party officials”.

Her criticism of Momentum is the most forthright of any MP for some time, after Tom Blenkinsop called for the group to be banned and Tom Watson dismissed it as a “bit of a rabble”.

There have previously been reports that Creasy herself has become a target for deselection in her Walthamstow seat after some campaigners marched to her office to protest against her voting for bombing Islamic State (Isis) in Syria.

Momentum has stated that it is “not a threat to MPs who voted for bombing” and “will not campaign for the deselection of any MP”, concentrating its efforts on campaigning for voter registration, Labour wins in the May elections, defending the NHS, and stopping Trident.

But speaking to the London School of Economics, Creasy said: “Groups like Momentum now appear to be draining the very energy from our political process they claimed to be promoting.”.

“In the last six months I’ve seen little evidence of campaigning ‘for’ something. I have seen a lot of meetings and moralising – and a lot of people standing for positions to be able to divert people into more meetings and moralising to complete the cycle.

“It’s taking the Oscar Wilde argument ‘that the problem with socialism is it takes too many evenings’ to the extreme – as though having meetings with ourselves and passing resolutions is the revolution we seek.”

She argued that the new interest in politics is “not translating into engagement”.

“It’s not just the curdled political debate of ‘red Tory’ and ‘Corbynista’ that make it hard for people to go to meetings with each other or talk on Facebook,” she said.

“It’s that even when people aren’t shouting at each other, they aren’t being encouraged to take action either.”

Creasy also claimed that a focus on party process and deselections “doesn’t challenge elitism, it strengthens it”.

Her intervention comes at a time of heightened tensions with Labour’s parliamentary party over a leaked list drawn up by an ally of the leader that ranked MPs according to their supportiveness towards Corbyn. Creasy was one of those named as “hostile”.

However, the party received a boost from new polling by Ipsos Mori that showed the gap between Labour and the Conservatives narrowing after George Osborne’s budget unravelled over cuts to disability benefits.

It also showed Corbyn leapfrogging David Cameron in the satisfaction ratings, putting him ahead by 35 points to 34.


Rowena Mason Political correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Good and brave Labour MPs need to be defended | Nick Cohen
Such is Corbyn’s grip on the Labour party that his supporters can pick off opponents with impunity

Nick Cohen

01, Oct, 2016 @5:30 PM

Article image
Stella Creasy: Labour needs to become a movement, not a machine
Shadow minister sets out her pitch for deputy leadership of the party by saying Labour needs to do more to connect with people

Rowena Mason Political correspondent

05, Jun, 2015 @1:57 PM

Article image
Momentum to start children's wing to boost 'involvement in labour movement'
The pro-Corbyn campaign group will provide childcare at events and promote ‘child-friendly’ political activity

Heather Stewart

18, Sep, 2016 @9:01 PM

Article image
Labour MP Stella Creasy receives Twitter rape threats
Walthamstow MP uses Twitter to inform police of abuse in wake of arrest of man for threats made to banknote campaigner

WARNING: Article contains abusive language

Sam Jones and agencies

29, Jul, 2013 @1:55 PM

Article image
Labour must break party’s silence on Brexit, says Stella Creasy
Writing for the Observer, Labour MP calls on the leadership to ‘name’ problems, as frustration grows with its stance on Europe

Toby Helm Political Editor

19, Jun, 2022 @9:15 AM

Article image
Labour antisemitism more widespread than thought, Momentum says
Accusations should not be dismissed simply as rightwing smears, group says, urging Labour to deal with the problem

Jessica Elgot Political correspondent

02, Apr, 2018 @6:19 PM

Article image
Momentum shakeup will force members to join Labour
Founder Jon Lansman convinces committee to sign up to new structure and rules in attempt to settle disputes

Heather Stewart and Rajeev Syal

10, Jan, 2017 @11:47 PM

Article image
Momentum sweeps board at Labour party youth elections
Supporters of Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership take all 18 seats in youth elections ahead of Young Labour annual conference next week

Oliver Milne

19, Feb, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Momentum calls for more open Labour selection process
Changes are needed to create ‘new generation of MPs’, says pro-Corbyn campaign group

Haroon Siddique

02, Sep, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
Momentum and the future of the Labour party | Letters
Letters: Helicoptering in candidates imposed from Labour’s centre is hopefully at an end, writes Rosie Brocklehurst; Sue Shanks is appalled that Labour activists are targeting Caroline Lucas’s seat; plus letters from Anita Pollack and Mike Allott


21, Mar, 2018 @5:35 PM