Labour in crisis: shadow ministers resign in protests against Corbyn

Shadow foreign secretary dismissed overnight after telling party leader there was ‘no confidence in his ability to win next election’

More than half of the Labour shadow cabinet is expected to stand down on Sunday in a major coup against Jeremy Corbyn, triggered by the result of the EU referendum and the leader’s decision to sack Hilary Benn.

Loyal members of shadow cabinet told the Guardian they were writing their resignation letters after Heidi Alexander, the shadow health secretary, stepped down on Sunday morning.

A Labour source said Alexander’s decision to resign in the wake of Benn’s dismissal would prove hugely significant, because unlike the shadow foreign secretary she was a more “loyal and pragmatic” member of the Corbyn team.

“She is seen as a moderate, practical and pragmatic voice,” they said. “Hilary always had a problem with Jeremy. Now that Heidi’s gone, most of the shadow cabinet will step down. He can’t just replace those positions because other frontbench ministers won’t step up to the roles.”

In her resignation letter to Corbyn, Alexander said: “It is with a heavy heart that I am writing to you to resign from the shadow cabinet. The result of the referendum last week means that our country is facing unprecedented challenges.

“More than ever, our country needs an effective opposition which can hold the government to account and which is a capable of developing a credible and inspiring alternative to an increasingly rightwing and backward-looking Conservative party.

“As much as I respect you as a man of principle, I do not believe you have the capacity to shape the answers our country is demanding and I believe that if we are to form the next government, a change of leadership is essential.”

Shadow cabinet members resign in Labour ‘coup’ against Corbyn

The Guardian understands Angela Eagle, Lucy Powell, Jonathan Ashworth, Lisa Nandy, Chris Bryant, Luciana Berger, Gloria De Piero, Charlie Falconer, Ian Murray, Rosie Winterton and Andy Burnham could be among those to resign from the Labour frontbench on Sunday.

A spokesman for Corbyn insisted he has no intention of resigning. “Jeremy Corbyn is the democratically elected leader of the Labour party and will remain so,” the spokesman said.

An ally added: “They don’t have a candidate, they don’t have a programme, they don’t have the supporters to win a leadership election. Rather than self-indulgent destabilisation, they should work with the Labour leadership to respond to the a momentous national event that needs a united Labour party.

“He is not going to resign, and if there is a challenge he will fight it. Anyone that resigns can be replaced. It is obviously disappointing and a distraction. If they want to challenge Jeremy Corbyn for the leadership they can collect the nominations and stand. He will be standing for election.”

Benn turned on Corbyn after being sacked as shadow foreign secretary in a late-night phone call, telling the Labour leader that MPs and shadow cabinet members have “no confidence in our ability to win the election” under his leadership.

Corbyn sacked Benn in the early hours of Sunday morning after the Observer revealed that the shadow foreign secretary was preparing to lead a coup against him.

Hours later, shortly after 8am, Alexander resigned.

In a defiant statement issued at 3.30am, Benn said he had been dismissed over the phone, after telling Corbyn he had “lost confidence in his ability to lead the party”.

He added: “It has now become clear that there is widespread concern among Labour MPs and in the shadow cabinet about Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership of our party. In particular, there is no confidence in our ability to win the next election, which may come much sooner than expected, if Jeremy continues as leader.”

It is understood that Benn had called fellow MPs over the weekend to suggest that he would ask Corbyn to stand down if there was significant support for a move against him. He had also asked shadow cabinet colleagues to join him in resigning if Corbyn ignored that request.

Shadow cabinet members told the Guardian that Corbyn’s decision to sack Benn could cause a mutiny. One loyal member said they were “staggered”. Another added: “A bad-tempered sacking is likely to lead to more trouble for Jeremy.”

A Labour spokesman insisted that the leader had to act following his middle-of-the-night conversation with his shadow foreign secretary, the son of his former mentor, Tony Benn.

“Hilary Benn was sacked because Jeremy’s lost confidence in him. Corbyn rang Benn at 12.50am and following that conversation he sacked him,” the spokesman said.

It is understood that an overwhelming majority of members of the shadow cabinet now believe that Corbyn should quit, in the wake of millions of Labour voters ignoring their leader’s advice to vote in favour of Britain’s continued membership of the EU, and amid the possibility of an early general election.

Benn made it clear in his statement that the Brexit vote had prompted his move, saying: “At this critical time for our country, following the result of the EU referendum, we need strong and effective leadership of the Labour party that is capable of winning public support so that we can stand up for the people of Britain.”

Leaked internal Labour party polling of people who voted for Labour in 2015 reveals that nearly a third (29%) would support a different party if a general election was held today.

It shows that just 71% of those who voted for Ed Miliband’s party in May last year say they would vote Labour now, and this drops further – to 67% – among working and lower middle-class C2DE voters.

A Labour source said: “MPs and members were worried about their prospects at the next election under Corbyn, but thought they had four years to turn things around. Now many fear they may have just four months if a snap election is called, so know they must act now to change the leader.”

Corbyn, speaking earlier on Saturday at a speech in London, had acknowledged rumblings of discontent about his leadership. “Yes, there are some people in the Labour party, and the parliamentary Labour party in particular, who probably want someone else to be the leader – I think they’ve made that abundantly clear,” he said.

Miliband, speaking at the Glastonbury festival on Saturday, offered some support, saying Corbyn was not to blame for the failure of the remain campaign. “I don’t think we should blame Jeremy Corbyn for the seismic earthquake. Part of the problem is that Westminster has been talking to itself too much,” he said.

Sources close to the leadership indicated that Benn had been a marked man even before the Observer revelations. The MP for Leeds Central electrified his party, and dismayed Corbyn, when he made a passionate speech in favour of British military involvement in Syria in December.

Shadow cabinet members resign in ‘coup’ against Corbyn

Rumours that Benn would be ousted in a future Labour reshuffle had circulated in Westminster for weeks. However, the development will be a major jolt to the shadow cabinet.

It is yet to be seen whether it will only strengthen the resolve of some to launch a unified assault on Corbyn’s leadership or quieten down the rebels. One shadow secretary of state suggested that only a small minority in the shadow cabinet now felt any loyalty to the Labour leader.

Despite the late hour of the sacking, some Labour MPs were quick to express their concern over the move. Ben Bradshaw, MP for Exeter, tweeted: “The Labour shadow cabinet must act now to save the party and for the sake of the country. Otherwise we will never be forgiven.”

Ilford North MP Wes Streeting tweeted: “Lots of good people chose to serve in shadow cabinet to keep the show on the road. There are no longer good reasons for good people to stay.”

The shadow minister for housing, Roberta Blackman-Woods, called the sacking “sad news indeed”, adding: “I cannot understand how Jeremy thinks it will help his worsening position with the PLP [parliamentary Labour party].”

The Labour Shadow Cabinet must now act to save the Party and for the sake of the country. Otherwise we will never be forgiven.

— Ben Bradshaw (@BenPBradshaw) June 26, 2016

Lots of good people chose to serve in Shadow Cabinet to keep the show on the road. There are no longer good reasons for good people to stay.

— Wes Streeting MP (@wesstreeting) June 26, 2016

This is sad news indeed and I cannot understand how Jeremy thinks it will help his worsening position with the PLP

— R. Blackman-Woods (@robertabwMP) June 26, 2016

Liberal Democrat MP Alistair Carmichael noted that the row would distract from the Conservative party’s own internal strife, tweeting: “Thank God Corbyn has sacked Benn. Just when media attention was going to focus on Tory splits.”

Before news of the sacking broke, both the Sunday Times and the Sunday Telegraph had led on news of Tory infighting over who will succeed David Cameron, who has said he will stand down as prime minister and party leader by October.

Thank God Corbyn has sacked Benn. Just when media attention was going to focus on Tory splits.

— Alistair Carmichael (@acarmichaelmp) June 26, 2016

Conservative MPs who had backed staying in the European Union are seeking to find a candidate who can “stop Boris” – with the former mayor of London and Vote Leave frontman Boris Johnson currently considered the strongest candidate to succeed Cameron.

Nicky Morgan, the education secretary and a possible contender for the leadership, writes today in the Sunday Times that the priority for the next prime minister will be “the task of reuniting our divided kingdom”, and urges party members to resist the temptation “to retreat to our ideological comfort zone and to appease the noisy fringes at the expense of the broad centre”.

A vote on a motion of no confidence in Corbyn is likely to be held by the parliamentary Labour party on Tuesday. Backbench MPs have been using WhatsApp to garner support for the motion, and it is believed that up to 80% of the parliamentary party are now set to vote in favour of Corbyn standing down.

However, it is understood that the chief whip, Rosie Winterton, is seeking to delay the vote for a week. Critics fear she is allowing support to gather for the candidature of the shadow chancellor, John McDonnell, a Corbyn ally, in case the Labour leader does quit and a leadership contest is launched. Winterton’s allies deny the claim.

In the Observer, Tristram Hunt, the former shadow education secretary, joins Corbyn’s critics, arguing: “Our experiment with Corbynism has to end. If Labour members care about Labour voters, we need to do something about the Labour leader.”

Writing before Benn’s sacking, Hunt wrote: “The shadow cabinet needs to act or MPs will.”

Fellow Labour MP Stephen Kinnock also wrote in favour of ousting Corbyn, saying he would back the motion of no confidence in the party leader. “There is no doubt that Jeremy is a great campaigner, but this is not a time for campaigners. This is a time for hard-headed negotiators. And it is also a time for people who have more than a passing knowledge of, and interest in, the EU,” Kinnock wrote.

“We need people at the table who will be able to see and understand the positions of the other member states, and of the EU institutions. We need a team in place that will secure the best possible deal for the British people.”


Daniel Boffey, Claire Phipps and Anushka Asthana

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hilary Benn seeks shadow cabinet backing to oust Corbyn
Shadow foreign secretary plans mass resignation following EU referendum result’s ‘existential’ threat to Labour

Daniel Boffey Observer policy editor

25, Jun, 2016 @8:59 PM

Article image
Grassroots Labour supporters revolt against Jeremy Corbyn over Brexit
Letter signed by 2,000 members causes more strife for party leader after high-profile resignations from frontbench over article 50

Toby Helm Observer political editor

28, Jan, 2017 @8:00 PM

Article image
Grassroots and shadow cabinet add to pressure on Corbyn over Brexit
Senior figures in the Labour party want commitment to another vote after disastrous EU election results

Toby Helm, Observer political editor

16, Jun, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
Labour chairman attacks Corbyn over ‘people’s vote’ on Brexit
Lavery in ‘broadside’ at party leader during meeting of MPs

Toby Helm political editor

06, Apr, 2019 @7:30 PM

Article image
Labour MPs challenge Corbyn on antisemitism and Brexit
Explanations demanded over Facebook comment and sacking of Owen Smith

Toby Helm

24, Mar, 2018 @9:01 PM

Article image
Corbyn faces furious Labour backlash over backing Brexit
Labour leader accused of betrayal on second poll and ‘in danger of losing young backers’

Toby Helm and Michael Savage

22, Dec, 2018 @9:00 PM

Article image
Has Jeremy Corbyn ended Labour unity with article 50 whip?
In cities such as Liverpool there is growing disillusionment with the Labour leader’s stance on Europe

Patrick Maguire

28, Jan, 2017 @8:30 PM

Article image
Labour grandees call for Jeremy Corbyn to embrace softer Brexit
Neil Kinnock and Charlie Falconer back Britain retaining single market membership, while insiders threaten to trigger rebellion at party conference

Michael Savage

29, Jul, 2017 @9:00 PM

Article image
Corbyn told: change course before it’s too late for Labour
Senior party figures warn leader over approach to antisemitism and new Brexit vote

Michael Savage

23, Feb, 2019 @9:00 PM

Article image
Jeremy Corbyn urged to make Labour the pro single market party
Leader faces calls from across Labour movement to back full membership of single market and customs union

Toby Helm and Michael Savage

23, Sep, 2017 @8:00 PM