Labour sued by members barred from leadership vote

Group hires law firm to challenge NEC decision that anyone who joined after 12 January can only vote if they paid £25 fee

Labour is being sued by a group of its members over the decision to exclude 130,000 people who joined the party since January from being able to vote in its leadership contest.

Harrison Grant, a London law firm, issued proceedings against Labour and its general secretary, Iain McNicol, on behalf of the members, who are crowdfunding to pay for their action.

In a statement, the group said: “We have called on the party to reconsider its decision, but it has not proven forthcoming. We believe the only way we can retrieve our rights is by taking the party to court.

“Harrison Grant Solicitors have issued proceedings on our behalf and we hope it will be heard very soon.”

Labour’s national executive committee (NEC) decided to allow only members who joined before 12 January to vote in the contest between Jeremy Corbyn, the party’s leader, and Owen Smith.

Anyone who joined afterwards can now only vote if they have paid £25 to be a registered supporter, or if they are registered through an affiliated union.

Jeremy Corbyn holds leadership rally in Manchester
Jeremy Corbyn holds leadership rally in Manchester. Photograph: Jack Taylor/Getty Images

Kate Harrison, of Harrison Grant, said: “The basis of the claim is that [the members’] entitlement to vote in the leadership election is part of their contract with the Labour party. They all joined when the Labour party website said in terms ‘you will be eligible to vote in leadership elections’.”

The claimants have applied for the legal action to be expedited so that it is heard in the high court before 4 August. A Labour party spokesperson said: “We will vigorously defend the decision of the NEC.”

Corbyn appeared to give his support to those challenging the membership cutoff in an interview with the Sunday Mirror last week.

“I’m very concerned. We haven’t heard the end of this. A lot of people joined the party in the past six months and will be extremely annoyed,” he said. “They joined because they want to be involved in the party and they’re not being allowed to.”

Some Corbyn supporters believe that the excluded members are backing Corbyn by four to one and believe the legal challenge has a good chance of success.

Corbyn is the clear favourite to win the contest. A survey released on Monday by the Labour History Research Unit at Anglia Ruskin University found that 60% of Labour councillors in 250 marginal constituencies were backing Smith, but they expected that members and registered supporters in their wards will favour Corbyn.

More than 500 Labour councillors from across the UK have signed a letter supporting Smith to lead the party. Two organisers of the letter, Gedling councillor Michael Payne and Westminster councillor, Tim Roca, said: “Councillors speak to real voters every day, and understand that winning a general election with Jeremy Corbyn as leader will be nearly impossible.”

There are signs that Corbyn may be slowly winning round some MPs who initially took part in the wave of mass resignations last month. It emerged on Monday that Sarah Champion had asked for her job back as shadow Home Office minister and she had now returned to the frontbench.

Labour sources said Corbyn had been reaching out to MPs and more were “reconsidering their resignations”, especially given the expectation that he will win the leadership contest.

The legal action is separate from another court case that is challenging the NEC’s decision to put Corbyn automatically on the ballot paper without needing to collect signatures from MPs.

The action, brought by party donor, member and former candidate Michael Foster, is to ascertain that the rules were properly applied. That case is due to be heard on Tuesday, but Corbyn is not expected to attend the high court despite successfully getting himself named as a second defendant.

Labour leadership candidate Owen Smith
Labour leadership candidate Owen Smith. Photograph: Jack Taylor/Getty Images

The NEC heard three contradicting pieces of legal advice, including from Michael Mansfield QC, which found only challengers needed nominations, and another from James Goudie QC, which found all candidates should seek nominations from MPs.

The decisions by various people within Labour to resort to legal action is a sign of the high stakes and factionalism gripping the party since it became clear Corbyn would face a leadership challenge.

As tensions continued to run high, McNicol ruled on Monday that Labour members who are abusive to others will be prevented from voting in the leadership contest.

The general secretary said Labour would issue bans because it was not enough simply to criticise some of the aggressive and intimidating behaviour that has soured the contest so far. “Words of condemnation are meaningless unless they are backed up by action,” he said.

People should report abusive behaviour to a party email address, McNicol said, adding that those who were found to have broken the rules would not be allowed to vote.

“I want to be clear. If you are a member and you engage in abusive behaviour towards other members, it will be investigated and you could be suspended while that investigation is carried out,” he said. “If you are a registered supporter or affiliated supporter and you engage in abusive behaviour, you will not get a vote in this leadership election.”

Labour has already decided to suspend local party meetings while the contest is going on, apart from those to make supporting nominations for leader.

“For a fair debate to take place, people must be able to air their views in an atmosphere of respect. They shouldn’t be shouted down, they shouldn’t be intimidated and they shouldn’t be abused, either in meetings or online,” McNicol said. “Put plainly, there is simply too much of it taking place and it needs to stop.”

Corbyn also addressed the problem of abuse on Saturday, telling members: “I know some people are angry at the actions of some MPs … but where we disagree in the Labour party, we settle it through democratic means … not coups, not intimidation and not abuse.”

John McDonnell makes appeal to Labour members: ‘We’ve got to stop this now’

Corbyn has reported receiving death threats as tensions over the future of the party have spilled over.

Labour MPs have also complained that they have been subjected to abuse for supporting people standing against Corbyn. Angela Eagle, who stepped aside for Smith, had a brick thrown through the window of the building where her constituency office is based and received threats that have forced her to cancel events.


Rowena Mason Deputy political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
New union members barred from voting in Labour leader election
National executive committee has stopped union affiliates who joined in the past six months from taking part

Rajeev Syal

14, Jul, 2016 @4:46 PM

Article image
Labour members will not take leadership vote challenge to supreme court
Five new members who challenged party’s national executive committee in high court and court of appeal cite excessive costs

Jessica Elgot Political reporter

14, Aug, 2016 @2:01 PM

Article image
High court to rule on new members' vote in Labour leadership ballot
Party was wrong to decide in July that only members who joined at least six months before are eligible, complainants say

Peter Walker Political correspondent

04, Aug, 2016 @4:18 PM

Article image
Labour leadership: quarter of new supporters could be barred from voting
Jeremy Corbyn’s allies say party’s oversight process could lead to contest being skewed

Peter Walker Political correspondent

02, Aug, 2016 @7:12 PM

Article image
Jeremy Corbyn says new Labour members should get leadership vote
Labour leader criticises decision to bar new members from voting as Owen Smith says only one candidate should be challenger

Peter Walker

17, Jul, 2016 @11:15 AM

Article image
Labour leadership contest: one result, five possible scenarios
Either Jeremy Corbyn or Owen Smith will be elected party leader on 24 September. What could happen after the vote?

Heather Stewart and Jessica Elgot

18, Sep, 2016 @4:16 PM

Article image
Labour NEC wins bid against allowing new members a leadership vote
Up to 130,000 new Labour members to be barred from voting in contest between Jeremy Corbyn and Owen Smith after court of appeal ruling

Jessica Elgot

12, Aug, 2016 @4:30 PM

Article image
Jeremy Corbyn fights off court challenge over Labour leadership ballot
High court rules there is no basis to challenge NEC’s decision that Labour leader should automatically be on ballot

Peter Walker, Rajeev Syal and Rowena Mason

28, Jul, 2016 @5:47 PM

Article image
Labour leadership court of appeal ruling: all you need to know
Party’s NEC wins bid to deny new members a leadership vote. How many are affected by ruling and who can actually take part?

Ben Quinn

12, Aug, 2016 @6:07 PM

Article image
Jeremy Corbyn and Owen Smith face off in tense Labour leadership hustings
Challenger heckled by audience during plea for unity as incumbent questions his resignation from shadow cabinet

Alice Ross and Rowena Mason

05, Aug, 2016 @6:09 AM