Ed Miliband at bay: the hack pack scents the blood of vulnerable prey

Newspapers can’t destroy politicians, but they can catch a baleful mood, surf a savage tide

The question of survival – to which there are two separate answers – pursued Ed Miliband through a dreadful week. Is he under such withering attack because (as Polly Toynbee of the Guardian put it) of ruthless “monstering by the press” – with the Mail, Telegraph and Express naturally joining the hunt? Or is he the author of his own misfortunes? Answer on the monstering charge: yes, he’s getting a pretty raw deal. Answer on the misfortunes front: yes again.

Newspapers can’t destroy politicians or political parties – see the Times’s repeated efforts to degrade Nigel Farage and Ukip by bombing them with stinky stories. But they can catch a baleful mood, surf a savage tide, when they find one.

Miliband wasn’t a target last week because he sought to define his leadership, in part, by denouncing Rupert Murdoch over hacking, cover-ups and the seedy rest. If he’d been riding high in the polls, looking like the next prime minister, the Murdochs of this world would have been far more circumspect. Pending power breeds respect.

However, month after month, year after year, Labour has pottered along drawing only around one-third of support in the polls. The Labour leader in Scotland didn’t resign because she read something in the Sun. The YouGov poll putting Miliband below Nick Clegg in the popularity stakes conveyed a stark verdict. The New Statesman broadside, couched in the most brutal, personal terms, didn’t answer some Murdoch call. Miliband was, and is, vulnerable. And vulnerability in politics also destroys defences in a Westminster world where off-the-record chat makes big headlines.

Here was a “Bonfire night plot to oust Ed” leading the Mail. Here was a “Secret plan for end of Miliband” leading the Times. Here, inevitably, was a flood of columns and supporting yarns filling pages of Conservative-supporting papers from the Express to the Telegraph.

Of course, the papers that more naturally put Labour’s case didn’t join the pack, but the Independent led on Miliband’s problems and the Guardian gave them front-page treatment. There were clearly enough Labour MPs briefing behind the scenes – or in the case of the Mail and Ian Austin, MP for Dudley North, breaking cover to keep momentum rolling. The plots withered and splintered swiftly under examination. The possibility of Miliband’s departure seemed to vanish, too. But there’s no easy end to this particular storyline.

The Times appeared high-minded on Friday when it advised Labour MPs to “stay quiet” and “help make their leader the best he can be”. Simon Heffer in the Mail couched the same practical outcome in different terms: “Why Dave should pray Miliband doesn’t quit.”

Where will it all end? The difficulty for the Tory-supporting newspapers is that they also have their EU demons to deal with. Ukip in Rochester could turn the tide yet again.

The story on the doorstep seems to be weakness infecting all would-be parties of government – and that means muddying press loyalties too. What Miliband needs to get back on track seems very simple then; he needs a few successes. But where are the media critics, inside or outside his camp, prepared to give him that?


Peter Preston

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ed Miliband suffers ferocious press onslaught - and it will get worse
Labour leader the butt of negative headlines as editors take advantage of internal dissent

Roy Greenslade

02, Feb, 2015 @10:25 AM

Article image
Ed Miliband and the Tory press - newspapers hark back to the 1950s

Roy Greenslade considers the national dailies' coverage of the Labour leader's speech

Roy Greenslade

25, Sep, 2013 @8:44 AM

Most newspapers warn Cameron not to launch an attack on Syria

Roy Greenslade on the advice from national newspaper editors to the prime minister ahead of today's debate

Roy Greenslade

29, Aug, 2013 @11:28 AM

Article image
Telegraph is the Torygraph again with this Conservative propaganda
Forget the other parties, blue papers attack Labour

Roy Greenslade

01, Apr, 2015 @10:19 AM

Article image
Local voters take their cue from national politics in the national press

Roy Greenslade looks beyond The Sun's 'political independence' to see how the papers' coverage of Ukip may influence the election outcome

Roy Greenslade

02, May, 2013 @11:36 AM

Article image
Newspaper readers' election votes reveal influence of rightwing press
Pro-Ukip propaganda in the Express and pro-Tory coverage in the Sun, Mail and Telegraph helped Labour lose the general election, YouGov survey finds

Roy Greenslade

08, Jun, 2015 @12:57 PM

Article image
Jeremy Corbyn's appeal is enhanced by the united hostility of the press
Negative newspaper coverage is tending to have the reverse effect, although Tory-supporting titles may well be very happy about that...

Roy Greenslade

17, Aug, 2015 @10:51 AM

Article image
National newspapers still hold the general election chips
Agenda-setting press casts its bets in a series of opening leading articles

Roy Greenslade

30, Mar, 2015 @10:42 AM

Article image
Most Tory newspapers praise Theresa May's cabinet reshuffle
But the Times and the Sun lament Michael Gove’s sacking and every paper questions the wisdom of appointing Boris Johnson as foreign secretary

Roy Greenslade

15, Jul, 2016 @8:04 AM

Article image
Yes, rightwing newspaper coverage did cause Ed Miliband's downfall
Labour must understand how press support for Ukip played a key role in its loss

Roy Greenslade

11, May, 2015 @8:29 AM