Tories deny Lady Warsi questioned morals of Muslim MPs

Conservatives say comments by shadow cohesion minister Sayeeda Warsi, made in Urdu, have been misinterpreted

The Conservatives today denied reports that its shadow cabinet member for social cohesion, Lady Warsi, made disparaging comments about Muslim MPs in which she questioned their fitness to stand for parliament.

Warsi, who is Muslim, was quoted on the Next Left website, as saying she did not think there should be more Muslim MPs and peers because they "don't have any morals or principles".

The remarks were reportedly made at a dinner in Yorkshire in honour of the visiting president of Pakistan-controlled Kashmir on 2 April, in response to comments by an earlier speaker who urged more Muslims to enter parliament.

Warsi is reported as saying: "I would actually disagree with that because one of the lessons we have learned in the last five years in politics is that Muslims that go to parliament don't have any morals or principles. Not everyone is [former Labour peer] Lord Ahmed, not everyone puts their community before their own career."

Her final comment was said to have been greeted with applause.

There are reports at Westminster that the Times had compiled a report on the speech, but the story had been dropped. Next Left said it had seen a copy of the unpublished article.

The Conservatives said Warsi's comments were made in Urdu and she had been misinterpreted. A party spokeswoman said: "What she was saying was you shouldn't vote a Muslim MP in thinking that they are going to vote or behave with a Muslim principle. You shouldn't vote them in because they tick boxes."

Warsi said in a statement: "I said that the definition of a good MP is someone that stands up for their constituents and who understands the communities they represent, not necessarily someone that ticks a particular ethnic box. People of every background feel let down by parliament and what is needed are MPs that can represent and empathise with their communities."

The Conservatives have never had a Muslim MP, while Labour had four during the last parliament including two ministers, Sadiq Khan and Shahid Malik.

A Labour insider said that the Tories were "spinning desperately" and insisted that Urdu speakers who had listened to the remarks could confirm the veracity of the translation contained in the Times article.

The Labour candidate Khalid Mahmood, who is hoping to be re-elected to Birmingham Perry Barr, described Warsi's comments as "offensive" to Muslim MPs. "This is a gaffe by her and they [the Conservatives] should recognise that."

He added: "I was very disappointed by her comments. I am going for election for a third term running and I have worked very hard. This bashing of Muslim MPs is just complete nonsense. What she has to do is realise why she hasn't got any Muslim MPs in her party."

Another website, Left Foot Forward, said it had seen the Times article. The website reported that the Sheffield Urdu and English newspaper Mahana ILM had confirmed it held a recording of Warsi's comments. But when contacted by the Guardian, Mahana ILM denied any knowledge of Warsi's comment.

Contributor

Haroon Siddique

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Lady Warsi: extremists forfeit their right to call themselves Muslim
Conservative party co-chairman says behaviour of some groups mean they are no longer a follower of Islam

Allegra Stratton, political correspondent

14, Nov, 2011 @4:37 PM

Lady Warsi: ministers fuelling Muslim radicalisation
Former Tory minister, who knows the family of the alleged 17-year-old suicide bomber, criticises a policy of ‘disengagement’ with Muslim communities

Matthew Weaver

16, Jun, 2015 @8:27 AM

Article image
Lady Warsi is right to confront anti-Muslim prejudice | Ghaffar Hussain

Ghaffar Hussain: Warsi's speech is welcome, though her reluctance to divide Muslims into moderate and extremist camps is misguided

Ghaffar Hussain

20, Jan, 2011 @4:06 PM

Article image
Lady Warsi says she fears Michael Gove becoming PM
Former party chair says senior Tories are concerned about minister’s views on Muslims

Dan Sabbagh

29, Mar, 2019 @12:51 PM

Article image
'Militant secularisation' taking hold of British society, says Lady Warsi
The Tory party chairman will lead an official visit to the pope by calling for Christianity to be given a central role in public life

Patrick Wintour, political editor

13, Feb, 2012 @11:02 PM

Article image
Lady Warsi launches bitter assault on coalition strategy towards Muslims
Former Tory chair targets Michael Gove for criticism and says failure to engage with the community ‘has fuelled resentment’

Mark Townsend

25, Jan, 2015 @12:37 AM

Article image
Sayeeda Warsi on Tory Islamophobia: 'It feels like I'm in an abusive relationship'
The Tories promised an investigation into anti-Muslim prejudice in the party – then watered it down. How high does the problem go? Disillusioned insiders – and the former party chair – speak out

Simon Murphy

27, Nov, 2019 @9:30 AM

Article image
Top Tory Warsi claims 'white girls are fair game' to some Pakistani men
Conservative party co-chairman says race played role in recent sexual abuse case in Rochdale

Nicholas Watt, chief political correspondent

18, May, 2012 @6:20 PM

Article image
Lady Warsi blames lack of Tory majority on electoral fraud

Tory chair says 'at least three seats' were lost due to alleged on electoral fraud and predominantly blames Asian community

Paul Owen

29, Sep, 2010 @4:43 PM

Article image
Politicians to blame for rise of 'respectable racism', says Lady Warsi
Conservative peer says divisive tactics used by Brexit campaigners have given green light for far-right views to enter mainstream

Anushka Asthana Political editor

22, Jul, 2016 @9:00 AM