The question: What's chemical castration?

Sarah Boseley: It has been a dream of many doctors, police and prison officers - not to mention home secretaries - to find a magic pill that would stop paedophiles re-offending, particularly because some of them beg for help in controlling their sexual urges.

Surgical castration of sex offenders went out about 100 years ago, but it has been a dream of many doctors, police and prison officers - not to mention home secretaries - to find a magic pill that would stop paedophiles re-offending, particularly because some of them beg for help in controlling their sexual urges.

The Home Secretary, John Reid said yesterday that he is willing to take some tentative steps down the chemical road for those paedophiles who want it. In this he is falling into line with several US states (though some have compulsory treatment for re-offenders) and a few European countries including France, Sweden and Germany.

But the choice of treatment is difficult. Side effects are a problem with hormonal drugs, including, sometimes, the irreversible growth of breasts. Reid spoke in the vaguest of terms, but mentioned both "hormonal medication" and "one of the newer antidepressant drugs" - the SSRIs (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors), which include Prozac and Seroxat.

The millions taking Prozac for depression - and, for that matter, the manufacturers - may not appreciate any glib link to chemical castration. What used to be known as the world's favourite happy pill does not end your sex life. But a reduced interest in sex is one of the recognised side effects and the Home Office says that "early evidence of greater control of deviant urges is encouraging". The department adds that drug treatment has to be coupled to psychological therapy.

In the US, the hormonal drug Depo-Provera is often used. This is injected progesterone, used worldwide as a long-term female contraceptive, which also inhibits testosterone production in men. But nobody believes drugs are a magic bullet. Sex offending is usually about power, violence and humiliation - not libido.

Contributor

Sarah Boseley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Delayed: the food study that could cut prison violence by 'up to 40%'
The Home Office has been accused of delaying new research that aims to reduce violence by 40% in Britain's overcrowded prisons by improving prisoners' nutrition.

Felicity Lawrence

17, Oct, 2006 @7:29 AM

Why do women steal?
Not everyone who shoplifts is a simple thief. But why does kleptomania affect mostly women - and what is the link with eating disorders? Sarah Boseley investigates.

Sarah Boseley

21, Jul, 2003 @8:30 AM

'John was very aggressive. The change in him was marked'
The Cotswold Community School is a residential school for some of the UK's most damaged boys. Their most recent treatment has been a course of fish oils.

Felicity Lawrence

17, Oct, 2006 @10:12 AM

Article image
Omega-3, junk food and the link between violence and what we eat
Research with British and US offenders suggests nutritional deficiencies may play a key role in aggressive bevaviour.

Felicity Lawrence

17, Oct, 2006 @7:29 AM

Article image
The soft option

More than 100 British sex offenders have volunteered for 'chemical castration'. But do the drugs really make them harmless? Decca Aitkenhead goes behind bars to find out

Decca Aitkenhead

18, Jan, 2013 @5:30 PM

Emine Saner on Belle de Jour the new Billie Piper TV series
The creators of ITV's 'Belle de Jour ' drama claim it is a realistic portrayal of one woman's story - but doesn't it simply glamorise the sex industry, asks Emine Saner.

Emine Saner

20, Sep, 2007 @6:18 AM

'Long-term prison is animalising'
Defendants facing murder charges will get their terms cut by a third if they plead guilty, under plans unveiled by Lord Woolf this week. Erwin James, who served 20 years himself, says there is a case for shorter sentences.

Erwin James

22, Sep, 2004 @1:06 AM

Eric Allison on the new law making prisons eligible for corporate manslaughter
Despite systematic abuse in some British prisons, no senior staff member has ever been disciplined. Little wonder, says Eric Allison, that the Lords this week refused to exempt prisons from a proposed new law on corporate manslaughter.

Eric Allison

07, Feb, 2007 @8:56 AM

Asbo aggro

Some say they are not enforced toughly enough. Others claim they represent summary justice meted out on the cheap. So are Asbos really working, asks Jon Robins.

Jon Robins

07, Jun, 2005 @11:10 AM

David Aaronovitch on why the 60s are not to blame for crime

The rampant liberalism and child-centred parenting of the 1960s are to blame for a lawless generation with no respect for authority, says Tony Blair. But David Aaronovitch is not ready to burn his kaftan just yet.

David Aaronovitch

20, Jul, 2004 @4:17 PM