Government accused of sexing up the honours list

The government was accused of abusing the honours system yesterday after a leaked document suggested the tennis player Tim Henman was recommended for an OBE to 'add interest' to the list.

The government was accused of abusing the honours system yesterday after a leaked document suggested the tennis player Tim Henman was recommended for an OBE to "add interest" to the list.

Minutes of deliberations over the new year's honours were leaked to a Sunday news paper by a Whitehall source who claimed the process was swayed by the publicity an honour might get, rather than genuine merit. The minutes were from a meeting on October 17 of the the main committee which considers honours.

They show the main committee, which is made up of senior civil servants, overruled a sub-committee on sports hon ours that was against "taking Henman at present". The Sunday Times said that rather than citing his achievements, the minutes showed that the main committee believed Britain's top ranking tennis player "should be taken now to add interest to the list".

The whistleblower told the Sunday Times they had leaked the document because the sys tem was over-secretive, dominated by spin and compromised by political bias.

The secret document also suggested that Professor Colin Blakemore, an eminent Oxford University scientist, was being excluded because of his "controversial" work on vivisection. There were anxieties of a backlash from the animal rights lobby, the newspaper claims.

Matthew Taylor, chairman of the Liberal Democrats, accused the government of debasing the honours system. He said: "People will be shocked that the honours system should be abused whether to benefit Tony's cronies or simply to generate publicity."

A spokesperson for the Cabinet Office, which is responsible for administering the hon ours system, said: "We totally refute the claim that honours are rewarded on anything other than merit."

The spokesperson said the main committee's function "was to take an overall view of the balance on the final list".

Consideration was being given to how to make the process "more open and transparent", the spokesperson said.


Mark Oliver

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

MPs to investigate 'secretive' honours system
MPs will undertake a review of the "wholly secretive" government honours system in the new year following a series of damaging leaks and a torrent of criticism of the selection process, it emerged today.

Liane Katz and agencies

22, Dec, 2003 @10:34 AM

Letters: Dishonourable conduct
I wrote to the honours committee looking at reform earlier in the year (Secret world of the honours system, December 23).

24, Dec, 2003 @2:35 AM

Article image
New year honours list includes outspoken critics of government
Chris Bryant and Julian Lewis receive knighthoods while Michael Marmot gets Companion of Honour

Peter Walker Political correspondent

30, Dec, 2022 @10:30 PM

Birthday honours refusenik JG Ballard speaks up
The writer JG Ballard turned down a CBE (Commander of the British Empire) for services to literature in this year's birthday honours.

Tania Branigan

22, Dec, 2003 @2:16 PM

Article image
Call for inquiry into government leak of honours list addresses
Publication of recipients’ details described as ‘most serious’ data laws breach

Frances Perraudin and Dan Sabbagh

29, Dec, 2019 @5:38 PM

Some who turned honours down
Peter Alliss, golfer, OBE, 1992

22, Dec, 2003 @2:21 AM

Menzies Campbell receives knighthood
No 10 aide receives CBE.

Michael White, political editor

31, Dec, 2003 @2:03 AM

Leader: Honourable members
A new elite emerged yesterday with the leaking of a secret Whitehall document listing 300 people who have turned down a knighthood, CBE or other award.


22, Dec, 2003 @2:22 AM

Article image
Iain Duncan Smith among three MPs in new year honours list
Former Tory vice-chairman Bob Neill and Labour’s Diana Johnson also receive honours

Peter Walker Political correspondent

27, Dec, 2019 @10:30 PM

Shunned Blakemore takes on honours role
A government scientist blackballed in the new year's honours list because of his support for vivisection revealed yesterday that he will be able to nominate and assess fellow scientists for this year's awards.

David Hencke, Westminster correspondent

14, Jan, 2004 @9:46 AM