1812 Overture v The Lark Ascending – which best represents Brexit Britain?

Tchaikovsky’s militaristic bombast has knocked Vaughan Williams’s bucolic birdsong off the top of the Classic FM charts, which may say something about our national mindset

Classic FM listeners have voted Tchaikovsky’s rousing 1812 Overture as their favourite piece of classical music, pushing Vaughan Williams’s The Lark Ascending off the top spot and into third place (Rachmaninoff’s Piano Concerto No 2 in C Minor came in second). This is a bit of a shock: The Lark Ascending has come first for the past four years, while the Overture had, by 2015, drifted out to No 18 – prompting some to wonder if the poll reveals a shift in the national mindset, post-referendum and pre-Brexit. So, which is the better choice to represent Britain’s mood today?

Date of origin

1812: 1880

Lark: Composed 1914; debuted 1921.

Does the work hark back to a simpler, less confusing time?

1812: Sort of – it commemorates events surrounding Russia’s 1812 defeat of Napoleon’s army, specifically the battle of Borodino, which was notoriously confusing for all involved.

Lark: Yes and no. It was inspired by George Meredith’s 1881 poem about a skylark – but was composed at the dawn of the first world war, so perhaps not that much simpler or less confusing.

Peter Tchaikovsky.
Peter Tchaikovsky. Photograph: Heritage Images/Getty Images

Any possible comfort for those who voted remain?

1812: It celebrates success in a battle that was – on paper – a defeat, but the triumphalism of the victors was ignored. After they got tired of wrecking everything, they just went away.

Lark: Although it begins with the sound of a single violin, it eventually rises to a volume loud enough to drown out cries of “Get over it – you lost!”

Anything in it to particularly gratify Brexiters?

1812: Bombast, and plenty of it. It’s also about a country getting rid of an unwanted European occupier – unfortunately, by starving itself.

Lark: It’s written by a British composer, about a British bird.

Anything in its popularity to trouble the government?

1812: It’s a little pro-Russian for the present climate.

Lark: The British skylark population has declined by a third since the 1980s due to intensive farming; possible rallying cry for conservationists.

Trigger warnings needed?

1812: Yes, literally – 16 cannons go off during its performance.

Lark: Possibly, if you’re a bit weird about birds.

Vaughan Williams.
Vaughan Williams. Photograph: Bentley Archive/Popperfoto/Popperfoto/Getty Images

Does it offer any hope for those facing a future beset by uncertainty in a world run by venal incompetents?

1812: No.

Lark: No.

In that case, is it easy to slag off on social media as a way of infuriating its devotees?

1812: Yes. It was described as “very loud and noisy and without artistic merit” – by Tchaikovsky himself, who loathed it.

Lark: Yes. It’s routinely derided as a bland and safe choice, which is perhaps why Classic FM listeners are backing away from it.

Contributor

Tim Dowling

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Two, 50 or 100 years: when do leavers think Brexit will pay off?
Jacob Rees-Mogg says the benefits of leaving the EU may not be felt for 50 years – and he’s not the only Eurosceptic asking the people of Britain to wait patiently

Emine Saner

24, Jul, 2018 @4:54 PM

Article image
The power of Brexit food analogies – from crisps and cake to 'thick as mince'
Gastro-related phrases have infused the Brexit debate in recent days. But this type of political ribbing is nothing new

Pete Cashmore

27, Feb, 2018 @3:01 PM

Article image
Grannies against the right: older women are rising up – could they bring down Brexit?
From Germany to the US, older women have been at the forefront of recent demonstrations. This could be the protest force we now need in the UK

Polly Toynbee

07, Feb, 2019 @10:39 AM

Article image
Brexit T-shirts: artist Jeremy Deller sums up in two words what millions are thinking
Deller’s sweary protest T-shirts are a welcome blast of humour into the stagnant Brexit debate

Zoe Williams

14, Jan, 2019 @5:37 PM

Article image
Cher wishes she could turn back time over Brexit
The singer has been lambasting Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage and putting the world to rights in the best possible way – with deeply inappropriate emojis

01, Jul, 2016 @11:16 AM

Article image
This is ‘Deep England’: warm ale, village greens and cheeky milkmen
Forget Little Englanders – Deep Englanders believe that life was better before the evils of industrialisation, foreign competition and, you know, immigration

Pass notes

11, Apr, 2017 @11:57 AM

Article image
Trigger warning: is article 127 the new article 50?
Can Britain leave the EU but stay in the EEA, like Iceland, Lichtenstein and Norway? Depends who you ask …

28, Nov, 2016 @12:00 PM

Article image
Michael Gove and Boris Johnson: how did their friendship come out of the deep freeze?
The politicians fell out after Gove torpedoed Johnson’s Tory leadership bid. Now they are back on good terms – and the reason is Brexit

Jonathan Freedland

13, Nov, 2017 @6:03 PM

Article image
How ‘opera lads’ Michael Gove and George Osborne bridged the Brexit divide
Govey and Ozbo may be at odds over the EU, but that didn’t stop them pulling a four-dayer together at Europe’s Wagner festival

06, Aug, 2018 @5:06 PM

Article image
Auf wiedersehen, Britain: Brexit is forcing my German family to leave the country we call home
Alexander Menden enjoyed his dream job in London, his wife working in the NHS, their boys supporting England in the World Cup. But the disaster that is Brexit has changed all that

Alexander Menden

02, Aug, 2018 @10:00 AM