The Hold Steady – a band whose relationship with their fans defines them

Following a band isn’t just about the music – it’s about fans feeling they belong to something bigger. Which is something the Hold Steady understand

Craig Finn: ‘I was no longer a loser’

Bands can have fraught relationships with their fans, even as they proclaim their love from the stage. One singer told me how he had pretended to be his own tour manager in order to email a fan whose presence at gigs he found particularly offputting, asking them not to stand at the front. Another, in an arena-filling band, said he hated playing the “back to our roots” club shows that big bands are supposed to adore, because they were always full of people desperate to demonstrate how they loved the band first and best by shouting out for radio session arrangements of early B-sides, when the band just wanted to play their new stuff.

So, as a Hold Steady fan, there’s some relief in feeling appreciated. The Brooklyn band rather slipped into their fan-celebration model by mistake. With them not being big ones for “digital strategies” and all, their fans stepped into the breach under the umbrella of “The Unified Scene” (a reference to a lyric from the song Sweet Payne … “Hey, there’s James King and King James and that’s James Dean/ At a table in the corner of my unified scene”), setting up a messageboard, organising meet-ups, and more or less running the band’s digital presence for themselves for a while. My favourite story of Hold Steady fandom involves their UK tour of 2007, when one young fan was spotted so often at the front he was asked to run the band’s merchandise sales. Then asked to do the same job in the US. When he said he couldn’t afford to do that, another (older, richer) fan stepped in and gave the young man his credit card for the duration of the US tour.

Gratifyingly, the band appreciate the efforts of their fans. Last year they launched a pledge campaign to benefit the family of a long-time fan who’d promoted several of their club shows in Pennsylvania, “Jersey” Mike van Jura, who died in 2012, aged 36. I never met him, but it’s a measure of how tightly knit the Hold Steady’s fans are that I and many others knew all about him, and knew about his passing even from several thousand miles away. That appreciation is why Craig Finn’s onstage monologue during the sometime encore Killer Parties makes a point of thanking the audience not for being at the show, but for being part of the show (when they played it at the End of the Road festival in 2009, the monologue mentioned by name pretty much everyone Finn knew at the festival, including me, my wife and my kids. I didn’t hear it. We’d left partway through that song to drive back to London).

All of which is a roundabout introduction to the fact that the Hold Steady have made a short film, ahead of their new album Teeth Dreams (released on 24 March), in which Craig Finn and Tad Kubler reflect on their relationship with their fans. Have a look, and let us know what you think.

PS I promise this is the last thing I will write about this Hold Steady album for the Guardian.


Michael Hann

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Hold Steady: watch the video for Spinners
Have a look at the animated video for Spinners, from the Hold Steady's new album, Teeth Dreams

Michael Hann

25, Mar, 2014 @5:30 PM

The Hold Steady: Heaven Is Whenever | CD review

Album No 5 is transitional, says Dave Simpson, but suggests there's more in the Hold Steady's locker

Dave Simpson

29, Apr, 2010 @10:30 PM

Article image
The Hold Steady: Thrashing Thru the Passion review – chancers and chasers in fist-punching glory
Craig Finn’s barstool-rock raconteurs paint a portrait of booze-soaked Americana with their most enthralling record in years

Al Horner

16, Aug, 2019 @9:00 AM

Live pop music review: The Hold Steady

Academy, Manchester
The purity and goodness of the American quintet have Dave Simpson rapt

Dave Simpson

12, Dec, 2008 @2:44 AM

The Hold Steady, Club Academy, Manchester

Club Academy, Manchester

Dave Simpson

15, Feb, 2007 @9:41 AM

Pop, folk and jazz CDs:The Hold Steady | Kylie | TTC | Luke Slater | Alasdair Roberts | Thelonius Monk

Pop, folk and jazz CDs: The Hold Steady | Kylie | TTC | Luke Slater | Alasdair Roberts | Thelonius Monk

Kitty Empire, Emily Stokes, Killian Fox, Ally carnwath, Neil Spencer and Dave Gelly

14, Jan, 2007 @12:06 AM

Article image
CD: The Hold Steady, Separation Sunday

(Full Time Hobby)

Dave Simpson

04, May, 2007 @10:57 PM

Article image
CD: The Hold Steady, Stay Positive

(Rough Trade)

Jude Rodgers

10, Jul, 2008 @11:18 PM

Review: The Hold Steady, Stay Positive

They may look mundane. But at best, thinks Graeme Thomson, they're impossible to resist

Graeme Thomson

12, Jul, 2008 @11:03 PM

DVD review: A Positive Rage - The Hold Steady

In keeping with the band's garage rock roots, this has a certain rough 'n' ready charm

15, Mar, 2009 @12:01 AM