LPO/Gardner review – magical outing for Tippett’s ‘unplayable’ piano concerto

Royal Festival Hall, London
Coleridge-Taylor’s stately, long-lost Solemn Prelude and a crisp, exploratory interpretation of Elgar’s first symphony completed a trio of English compositions

Three very English but three very different composers – Samuel Coleridge-Taylor, Michael Tippett and Edward Elgar – made up the London Philharmonic’s latest programme under Edward Gardner. The centrepiece was unquestionable: a rare but thoroughly persuasive outing for Tippett’s fluent yet entangled piano concerto of 1953-55.

It was condemned as unplayable by the soloist Julius Katchen, who walked out shortly before he was due to give the premiere. These days, especially in the hands of Steven Osborne, a champion of the work, that seems an extraordinary misjudgment about a concerto that has proved its staying power. In Osborne’s hands, the concerto was not merely playable but eloquently played. It would be hard to imagine a more convincing account than the one that, playing from the score, he conjured here.

The work’s animating spirits are Beethoven’s fourth concerto, whose lyricism and structure it echoes at several points, and Tippett’s distinctive sense of fun and fantasy. These take wing in the concerto’s lapidary scoring, in which the soloist is never confrontational or dominating. Instead, it is the concertante interplay of the soloist with groups of instruments, most strikingly with the flute, violin and celesta, that holds the attention. Osborne’s encore, an improvisation on a Keith Jarrett tune, was every bit as magical.

Coleridge-Taylor’s Solemn Prelude for orchestra, which preceded the Tippett, was a different kind of curiosity. First performed at the Three Choirs festival in 1899, the score then disappeared, so this was its London premiere, 124 years on. It is a stately piece, with the composer’s customary clarity of scoring and professionalism, but it has nothing of the orchestral daring that permeates Elgar’s first symphony, which took up the second half of the programme.

Here Gardner was in his element, in a crisply directed performance that emphasised the exploratory rather than the traditional qualities of Elgar’s symphonic writing. This symphony may have its feet in the 19th century but, even at the close, it is constantly looking forward not back. Gardner understands this duality, and the LPO responded with the commitment that is starting to characterise their partnership.


Martin Kettle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
LPO/Gardner The Midsummer Marriage review – Tippett’s opera thrills in stupendous performance
In his opening concert as the London Philharmonic Orchestra’s principal conductor, Edward Gardner brought home the heady, almost narcotic quality of Tippett’s music

Tim Ashley

26, Sep, 2021 @1:10 PM

Article image
Tippett: The Midsummer Marriage review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
Gardner captures perfectly the overflowing exuberance of Tippett’s score, with Toby Spence and Jennifer France an ideal Jack and Bella

Andrew Clements

29, Sep, 2022 @3:40 PM

Article image
LPO/Gardner/Ehnes review – next principal ignites the spark
There were poised accounts of Walton and Bartók, but it was in Nielsen’s ‘Inextinguishable’ Symphony that things caught fire

Erica Jeal

10, Oct, 2019 @1:55 PM

Article image
SoundState: LPO/Edward Gardner review – a compelling musical journey
Rebecca Saunders’ concerto was the highlight of an opening night that also included Missy Mazzoli and the last major work by George Walker

Andrew Clements

31, Mar, 2022 @12:31 PM

Article image
LPO/Gardner review - defiant and exultant Beethoven opens new season
A magnificent, edgy Fifth Symphony was paired with Jörg Widmann’s energetic Con Brio and complemented by a haunting group of Sibelius songs

Tim Ashley

24, Sep, 2020 @12:07 PM

Article image
LPO/Gardner review – timely celebration of the brilliance of Oliver Knussen
The LPO’s celebration of the late composer included a superbly assured performance of his Horn Concerto by the 19-year-old Annemarie Federle, a last-minute replacement. Glittering Ravel and sequences from Britten’s only ballet followed.

Andrew Clements

02, May, 2022 @9:02 AM

Article image
LPO/Gardner review – Brett Dean provides tantalising prelude to cool Mahler
World premiere of this extract from Dean’s ‘planned opera’ was full of vivid colour and ear-catching textures. The Mahler that followed was stylish and unsentimental

Flora Willson

27, Apr, 2023 @12:47 PM

Article image
LPO/Gardner/Gerhardt review – tour de force playing in remarkable UK premiere
Brett Dean’s Cello Concerto was played with tremendous virtuosity by Alban Gerhardt, emphasising the music’s compelling nature

Tim Ashley

28, Apr, 2022 @11:16 AM

Article image
Edward Gardner appointed LPO principal conductor
Gardner will take over from Vladimir Jurowski at the London Philharmonic Orchestra from 2021-22 season

Imogen Tilden

26, Jul, 2019 @11:08 AM

Article image
Elgar: Symphony No 1; Introduction and Allegro CD review – notable for its clarity

Andrew Clements

13, Apr, 2017 @2:00 PM