Julia Holter: The Passion of Joan of Arc review – strikingly contemporary, piercingly loud live score

Town Hall, Huddersfield
The mercurial composer’s brilliant score perfectly captures the raging agony and beatific ecstasy of Carl Theodor Dreyer’s silent movie masterpiece

Julia Holter’s mercurial career has taken her from traditional pop to chamber music, indie to electronica, the avant grade underground to the Top 20 and recently to film scores. Here, the Los Angeles-based composer has teamed up with the 36-strong Chorus of Opera North for the world premiere of her new live score for Carl Theodor Dreyer’s 1928 silent movie masterpiece, The Passion of Joan of Arc. Holter initially performed a live soundtrack to the film in LA in 2017. This Huddersfield Contemporary Music festival performance was delayed for two years by the pandemic, but Holter kept writing, completing most of this finished score this year.

The newly restored subtitled black and white film – telling the story of the French saint’s religious persecution and execution with a script derived from minutes of her 1431 trial – is shown above the stage. Holter, behind a keyboard, sits with the chorus and musicians. A sense that anything could happen is reinforced by the provision of earplugs, and signs reading “This performance will be loud”. It begins with a hush, as a mournful trumpet is gently augmented by a percussionist to create a funeral, death-march effect.

Julia Holter.
Spellbinding … Julia Holter. Photograph: Brian Slater

The film hinges on lingering closeups of actor Renée Jeanne Falconetti, who gives what the influential New Yorker critic Pauline Kael once said “may be the finest performance ever recorded on film”. Falconetti’s mesmerising array of facial expressions morph from outrage to defiance to tearful sorrow to terror as Joan faces her inquisitors and ultimately her fate. The score’s brilliance is in the way it clings to that face like a shadow: becalmed, even beautifully beatific, then raging in intensity. Joan’s slow walk to the trial in manacles is soundtracked by an eerie reverie of voices. A timpani rumbles like thunder as the voices around her rise in intensity.

It’s striking how much the film and events of 1431 speak to current issues. One of Joan’s trumped-up “crimes” is to wear men’s clothing. “When the mission of God is finished I will wear women’s clothes again,” she cries. The misogyny is exposed as cackling male judges relish rounding on a 19-year-old young woman, the foreboding music somewhere between Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana and Jerry Goldsmith’s Ave Satani from The Omen.

There are some wonderful individual moments. The tenors sound straight out of a medieval abbey, the chorus subtly shift from male to female voices, percussion tinkles ominously as Joan faces the torture chamber and a bell tolls as her fate is sealed. Finally, the reason for those earplugs becomes apparent. As Joan is burned at the stake, flames flicker around her to a crescendo of sound led by a piercing bagpipe. Somehow, there is beauty in the music just as there is ecstasy in Joan’s agony; Falconetti’s face captures the moment that death brings release and martyrdom. This is a powerfully spellbinding union of image and sound.

The Passion of Joan of Arc is at the Barbican, London, on 25 November. Huddersfield Contemporary Music festival runs until 27 November.


Dave Simpson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Julia Holter review – galloping imagination leads to walk-outs and wonderment
The singer-songwriter cast a spell over the crowd with her cherished characters and carnival of sounds – but an industro-rock climax proved too much for some

Caroline Sullivan

15, Nov, 2016 @2:17 PM

Article image
50 great tracks for October from Noname, Julia Holter, Objekt and more
From Behemoth’s satanic metal to a triumphant return from Lana Del Rey, here are the tracks you need this month – read about our ten favourites, and subscribe to all 50 in our playlists

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

01, Oct, 2018 @9:59 AM

Article image
New band of the day: Julia Holter (No 1,228)

Sepulchral? Liturgical? Decorative and droning? Someone's been listening to old 4AD albums, haven't they?

Paul Lester

14, Mar, 2012 @5:01 PM

Article image
Julia Holter: Loud City Song – review
Julia Holter ruminates on the shallow world of celebrity-obsessed media and the ultimate futility of it all, writes Harriet Gibsone

Harriet Gibsone

15, Aug, 2013 @8:15 PM

Article image
Julia Holter review – magical mystery tour of classical, pop, jazz and all between
Rigour and precision are at the heart of Holter’s convoluted, supernatural songs – their glassy, silvery qualities unsettle and entertain in equal measure

Maddy Costa

11, Nov, 2015 @11:08 AM

Julia Holter: Ekstasis – review
Julia Holter's sophisticated, cerebral pop may not be for everyone, but it casts something of a spell on Michael Hann

Michael Hann

29, Nov, 2012 @11:45 PM

Article image
Julia Holter – review

Both pristine and deranged, Julia Holter drapes herself in mystery and transforms herself when she takes to the stage

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

21, Aug, 2013 @9:12 AM

Article image
Julia Holter: Have You in My Wilderness review – exceptional pop built on avant-garde foundations
From her found-sound DJ mixes to her experimental albums based on French novels and Greek tragedies, Julia Holter seems very much the serious artist. But she has always done beautiful melodies, and never more so than here

Alexis Petridis

24, Sep, 2015 @2:00 PM

Article image
Julia Holter signs up to score boxing movie Bleed for This
The film, which will be executive produced by Martin Scorsese, will tell the true story of Vinny Pazienza, whose life was derailed following a car accident

Guardian music

28, Oct, 2015 @10:59 AM

Article image
Julia Holter: ‘People just want to conquer somebody’
Her cerebral classical-pop explores the intricacies of relationships but she doesn’t want you to think, just feel. Meet the celebrated singer-songwriter who’s every bit as complex as her compositions

Kate Hutchinson

19, Sep, 2015 @8:00 AM