BBC Concert Orchestra/Martin Yates review – rumbustious Elgar a high point

Dorchester Abbey, Dorchester on Thames
English music festival works by neglected composers left me thinking music this far in the hinterland should be left there

The English music festival’s annual burrowings into the hinterland of early 20th-century British music continues to turn up pieces that have been neglected or ignored. The opening concert of this year’s programme, given by the BBC Concert Orchestra conducted by Martin Yates, consisted entirely of such works, even though it was bookended by Elgar and Vaughan Williams.

The performance of Elgar’s comic overture The Spanish Lady was described as a world premiere, which seemed odd, given that Yates has already recorded a suite assembled from the opera that Elgar worked on in the last years of his life, which began with this overture. It’s certainly not top-drawer Elgar, but attractive enough in a rumbustious way, with occasional echoes of his Falstaff and overture In the South, though the Dorchester Abbey acoustic did give it a brassy glaze. The Vaughan Williams that ended the concert was Old King Cole, composed in 1923 for a Cambridge festival, and more or less what might be expected from a work described as a “folk ballet” – a succession of solemn processions, jigs and fiddle dances, with a wordless chorus (members of the Thame Chamber and City of Oxford Choirs) and a final hint of the world of The Lark Ascending.

The pieces in between were all more or less unmemorable. Even Coleridge-Taylor’s Violin Concerto, performed in a new edition faithful to Coleridge-Taylor’s original intentions with Rupert Marshall-Luck as the impressively secure soloist, rather outstays its welcome, its bombastic opening movement sitting uneasily alongside the more genial music that follows. Delius’s Petite Suite No 2, receiving its first professional performance apparently, dates from 1890, when Delius was still digesting influences from Grieg and Dvořák, while William Alwyn’s Concerto Grosso No 1, composed during the second world war, has the occasional harmonic diversion to spice up its blameless neoclassicism. And then there was a piece by Reginald Morris, best remembered now for his textbooks on counterpoint and as a one-time teacher of Michael Tippett, but whose Sinfonia in C could have been written for an Olde English village pageant. It’s hard to believe that Morris’s music was once championed by Arthur Bliss and Adrian Boult, but then it’s hard to understand why most of the works in this concert needed to be revived.


Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
BBC Concert Orchestra/Yates review – a potpourri of premieres and folk tunes
David Matthews’ Norfolk March excelled but Vaughan Williams’ Fat Knight needed trimming in the opening concert of the English Music festival

Andrew Clements

30, May, 2016 @2:17 PM

Article image
Multi-Story Orchestra/Bold Tendencies review – Proms shifts gear with car-park concert
Christopher Stark led a toe-tingling programme of Steve Reich that was as notable for its playing as for its place

Erica Jeal

04, Sep, 2016 @1:48 PM

Article image
Elgar: Symphony No 1 CD review – Pappano has created a world-class orchestra
Pappano’s account of Elgar’s First Symphony and the overture In the South take a while to get going, but when they do, they are impressive

Andrew Clements

17, Aug, 2016 @2:00 PM

Elgar: Concert Allegro; Symphony No 2, Iain Farrington (piano), Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra/Vass – review
More than a century after Elgar suggested an orchestration of his Concert Allegro, pianist Iain Farrington has done just that – and in some style, writes Stephen Pritchard

Stephen Pritchard

20, Feb, 2011 @12:03 AM

Article image
BBC Concert O/Yates review – Finzi triumphs at the English Music festival
A reconstruction of George Butterworth’s Fantasia for Orchestra provided a seamless piece of musical speculation, but it was Finzi’s final Cello Concerto that gave this concert substance

Andrew Clements

24, May, 2015 @3:03 PM

Article image
The Dream of Gerontius review – ENO takes Elgar's soul on a dramatic journey
Simone Young set a dynamic framework for this staged interpretation, while Gwyn Hughes Jones sang the dying man with emotional conviction, backed by incisive soloists and chorus

Martin Kettle

02, Jul, 2017 @12:29 PM

Article image
Elgar: String Quartet; Piano Quintet  review | Andrew Clements' classical album of the week
A century after the composer’s String Quartet and Piano Quintet were premiered, the Brodsky Quartet return them to the spotlight

Andrew Clements

25, Apr, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
Elgar and Bridge/Schwabe: Cello Concertos review – hugely impressive and refreshingly straightforward
A performance full of finely realised detail and lacking in bombast ensures these two great and contrasting British cello concertos shine

Andrew Clements

26, Nov, 2021 @11:12 AM

Article image
Orchestra of the RAM and the Juilliard School/Gardner review – order and beauty out of chaos
Edward Gardner’s electrifying Prom exploring music and space deals with the human experience of the unknown

Tim Ashley

24, Jul, 2019 @8:55 AM

Article image
Orchestra to open Glastonbury festival
Former Haçienda DJs who reinvent club classics with a full orchestra are charged with waking up festivalgoers in prestigious opening slot

Guardian music

28, Apr, 2017 @10:13 AM