Sibelius: The Symphonies and Tapiola review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week

Oslo PO/Klaus Mäkelä
(Decca, four CDs)
The prodigious young talent has an exclusive recording contract with Decca but his debut – a Sibelius symphony cycle – is frustratingly uneven

The Finn Klaus Mäkelä is still only 26, but he has already risen supersonically through the conducting ranks. He’s currently at the helm of two leading European orchestras, the Oslo Philharmonic and the Orchestre de Paris, and has become only the third conductor in the history of the label to be signed to an exclusive recording contract by Decca, following in the footsteps of Georg Solti and Riccardo Chailly. Whether Mäkelä will prove to be an artist on a par with those distinguished predecessors remains to be seen, but his debut with the company is certainly a statement of intent – a complete cycle of the Sibelius symphonies with the Oslo orchestra, recorded in the Norwegian capital last year.

Klaus Mäkelä and the Oslo Philharmonic: Sibelius album cover.
Sibelius album cover. Photograph: Decca

Of course, there’s no shortage of outstanding cycles of these symphonies already available, and in the final analysis Mäkelä’s set does not challenge the second of Colin Davis’s three versions, say, or either of those conducted by Osmo Vänskä. It’s frustratingly uneven, with performances veering between the outstanding and the prosaic, though the orchestral playing is consistently fine. Mäkelä’s approach to the First Symphony sets the tone for much of what follows; he seems to treat the work more like a symphonic poem than as a rigorous piece of symphonic architecture, with a succession of brightly coloured episodes that don’t necessarily connect, and while the First is by far the most diffuse and derivative of Sibelius’s symphonies, it’s a more cogent work than he suggests.

Underlining the set’s unevenness, though, the First is followed by a superb account of the Second Symphony, which perfectly encapsulates its mix of organic rigour and rugged defiance. This and Mäkelä’s account of the dark, brooding Fourth, which is suitably austere and never over-interpreted, are the highlights of his cycle, while the Third is probably its low point, with no sense of coherence at all. In the Fifth, the great turning points – the transition from the opening movement into scherzo, and the emergence of the glorious “swan theme” in the finale, two of the most thrilling moments in 20th-century music – are made to seem almost matter-of-fact, while the performances of Sixth and Seventh are thoroughly accomplished in a rather detached way, but nothing more.

The Seventh is followed by the last of Sibelius’s tone poems, Tapiola, revisiting the chilly landscapes explored in that symphony, and also by three fragments, less than four minutes of music altogether, which are thought to be all that survives of the score of an eighth symphony that Sibelius seems to have destroyed sometime during the second world war. It may bring one of the greatest of all symphonic journeys full circle, but the performances themselves leave many questions unanswered en route.


Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sibelius: The Seven Symphonies CD review – Järvi can't quite convince | Andrew Clements' classical album of the week
Paavo Järvi brings deep knowledge and affinity to this music, but the results don’t generate the thrills they should

Andrew Clements

17, Jan, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
Sibelius: Symphonies Nos 4 & 6 review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the month
Mark Elder and the Hallé bring a sympathetic, powerful character to Sibelius’s enigmatic symphonies

Andrew Clements

13, Feb, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
Schumann: The Symphonies review – bombast and revelation | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
The Staatskapelle’s sumptuous playing is hard to fault, but conductor Thielemann is too overblown at times

Andrew Clements

18, Apr, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
Scenes from the Kalevala review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
Scenes from Finland’s national epic were set to music by many Finnish composers beyond the best known, Sibelius. These works by Klami, Madetoja and Pylkkänen deserve wider recognition, as these accomplished performances demonstrate

Andrew Clements

27, Jan, 2022 @4:15 PM

Article image
Dausgaard/Appl/BBCSSO: Kullervo review – thrilling and intense account of Sibelius' epic
Thomas Dausgaard and the BBC Scottish Symphony conjure grand landscapes and a rousing plot with Helena Juntunen and Benjamin Appl the persuasive soloists

Erica Jeal

27, Jun, 2019 @2:30 PM

Sibelius: Tapiola

In our series on building a classical library, Andrew Clements selects the definitive recording of Sibelius' Tapiola.

Andrew Clements

06, Jul, 2001 @3:55 PM

Article image
‘It’s OK to take risks in concerts because there it’s safe to do so’: Conductor Daniel Harding on his double life as an airline pilot
He’s been on the podium with the world’s leading orchestras but, he says, his new parallel career flying for Air France has taught him things he never learned in 30 years of music making

Hugo Shirley

03, Nov, 2022 @6:15 PM

Article image
Sibelius: Tapiola, En Saga, 8 Songs CD review – freshness and glitter with Anne Sofie von Otter

Erica Jeal

02, Nov, 2017 @3:20 PM

Sibelius: Symphonies Nos 2 and 5 – review
It's not surprising Vänskä would want to revisit these symphonies with his current orchestra but they need a leaner sound, writes Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

22, Mar, 2012 @9:49 PM

Article image
Brahms: The Four Symphonies review | Andrew Clements' classical album of the week
Emulating Brahms himself with an orchestra of fewer than 50 players, these fresh, engaging recordings show that less can mean a lot more

Andrew Clements

11, Aug, 2022 @2:00 PM