Beyond the Garden review – Susan Bickley is magnificent as fact and fantasy blur

The Hub at St Mary’s, Lichfield
Stephen McNeff’s chamber opera, based on the relationship between Alma Mahler and her daughter, hinges on two singers who rise to the occasion

Manon Gropius is best remembered as the “angel” to whose memory Alban Berg dedicated his great Violin Concerto. Her parents were Alma Mahler and the Bauhaus architect Walter Gropius, and she died of polio in 1935 at the age of 18. Manon and her mother did not get on – Alma even stayed away from her funeral in Vienna – though the year before her death they had spent Easter together in Venice. There they stayed in a hotel called Oltre il Giardino (Beyond the Garden) and that provided the title for Stephen McNeff’s chamber opera based on their deeply ambivalent relationship. First performed in Slovenia two years ago, it received its UK premiere at the Lichfield festival.

McNeff and his librettist Aoife Mannix avoided the temptation of creating a biographical opera about Alma and her daughter. In their text she becomes Ottilia, a woman living out old age with her crumbling memories in New York, and Manon is Klara, a young journalist who interviews her. But as the 70-minute two-hander goes on, Ottilia’s attitude to Klara seems to echo Alma’s treatment of her daughter: “How will you catch a man dressed like a fish?” she asks her at one point, while Klara responds by accusing her of impaling men “like worms on a hook”. While recalling fragments of her life Ottilia/Alma unloads her guilt about her treatment of Manon, as well as her resentment at being forced to give up writing music while she was married to Gustav Mahler, but whether through age or design she reconstructs her past too, so that fact and fantasy constantly blur.

It’s certainly a potent subject for music theatre; there are no “operatic” set pieces, just a sharply characterised musical dialogue that McNeff’s sparing accompaniment for a quartet of violin, clarinet, harp and piano (members of Gemini, conducted from the keyboard by Dominic Wheeler), counterpoints very economically. There’s no staging apart from a few props, and dramatically it all relies on the ability of the two singers to bring their characters to life. Alison Rose vividly tracks Klara’s transition from confident inquisitor to intimate confidante as the piece goes on, while Susan Bickley magnificently presents Ottilia as very much the grande dame, with just enough vulnerability to add another dimension to a character whom history has never regarded well.

• At All Saints Church, Hereford, on 25 July.

Contributor

Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
René Pape review – a truly magnificent voice
The German bass shrugged off a cold to present song cycles by Beethoven, Dvořák, Quilter and Mussorgsky with scrupulously judged expression

Tim Ashley

18, Dec, 2016 @12:32 PM

Article image
Rusalka review – Natalya Romaniw is a rapturously magnificent water nymph
Romaniw unleashes an overwhelming torrent of sound and emotion in a spectacular production that imbues Dvořák’s fairytale with sinister magic

Tim Ashley

19, Jun, 2022 @11:19 AM

Article image
Jephte/Dido and Aeneas review – magnificent DiDonato brings understated passion to Purcell
Joyce DiDonato probed Dido’s desire and anguish with characteristic subtlety, while the Pomo d’Oro Choir were superb in Carissimi’s Jephte

Tim Ashley

04, Feb, 2024 @3:08 PM

Article image
Kaufmann/LSO/Pappano – magnificent, lyrical Wagner
Jonas Kaufmann and Karita Mattila often mesmerised in this recital of songs and excerpts, in which Eric Halfvarson made a tremendous Hunding

Tim Ashley

09, Feb, 2017 @2:20 PM

Susan Graham – review
For her latest recital the American mezzo shunned her more usual trouser roles in favour of potraits of good and bad women, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

02, Jul, 2012 @5:27 PM

Gurney: Songs : Bickley/Burnside | CD review

A well-conceived and important disc for all English music enthusiasts, says Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

06, Aug, 2009 @11:01 PM

Article image
Jephtha review – Clayton is magnificent as a wide-eyed zealot
Oliver Mears’s powerful but flawed staging of Handel’s biblical oratorio boasts very fine singing and performances, with Jennifer France’s Iphis and Allan Clayton’s Jephtha standouts

Erica Jeal

09, Nov, 2023 @1:07 PM

Article image
Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk review – magnificent descent to self-destruction
Mark Wigglesworth opens his tenure as ENO’s music director with a powerful new production, inspiring memorable performances from orchestra, chorus and soloists

Andrew Clements

27, Sep, 2015 @12:52 PM

Article image
Les Enfants Terribles review – dark sibling fantasy
Top-flight dancers, Javier de Frutos moves, Philip Glass score and Cocteau’s twisted tale don’t quite add up

Luke Jennings

05, Feb, 2017 @8:00 AM

Article image
Rameau: Naïs review – exuberant baroque rarity
Rameau’s pastoral opera written in 1748, is an allegory for King Louis XV’s role as peace maker and is stuffed with arias and dance divertissements

Andrew Clements

14, Jun, 2018 @2:00 PM