LSO/Barbara Hannigan review – playing havoc with the balance of sympathies

Barbican, London
The soprano and conductor takes on jarring dual role as she juxtaposes Strauss’s Metamorphosen with a multimedia version of La Voix Humaine

Recently appointed associate artist with the London Symphony Orchestra, soprano-conductor Barbara Hannigan has made much of her dual role, often singing and conducting simultaneously, with uneven results, both live and on disc. Her latest venture, first unveiled in Paris in January last year, juxtaposes Strauss’s Metamorphosen with a multimedia version of La Voix Humaine, Poulenc’s one-act opera depicting the final phone conversation between a desperate woman, Elle (“She”), and the unseen lover who is dumping her for someone else.

Her take on the work is idiosyncratic. At several points, Elle admits to lying, and Hannigan, in a video talk before her performance, posits the idea that the opera itself is a lie, arguing that Elle’s lover doesn’t really exist, and that “all this is a fantasy in her mind”. She notes Elle’s need to control her world, much as she herself controls the orchestra. “Perhaps she imagines that she is me,” she tells us.

Hannigan conducts and sings the opera largely with her back to us, while live footage of her face and torso, directed by Clemens Malinowski, is projected from multiple platform cameras on to a large screen behind the orchestra. Rhythmic gestures are dramatically integrated as she pounds the air in fury at a crossed line on her now nonexistent phone, or claws her face in self-pity. Though she is amplified, the role suits her well vocally, and there is plenty of the underlying orchestral sensuality that Poulenc demanded. Yet it remains misguided. Conducting yourself on film seems quite literally self-regarding, I’m afraid. And if Elle’s lover doesn’t exist then Poulenc’s heroine becomes a delusional narcissist, which plays havoc with the balance of sympathies.

Barbara Hannigan.
Rhythmic gestures … Barbara Hannigan. Photograph: Mark Allan

Video was also promised for Metamorphosen, but didn’t, for whatever reason, materialise. Strauss’s great lament for the collapse of European culture in the last days of the second world war needs no visual accompaniment, and in this instance gained terrible resonance from being played on the day of the invasion of Ukraine. The performance, though, was overly restrained and understated, rarely attaining the harrowing immediacy the work ideally needs, which was a shame.


Tim Ashley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Edinburgh international festival returns with music-heavy lineup
With theatre and dance scaled back, music dominates, including concerts from Simon Rattle, Damon Albarn, Nicola Benedetti and Laura Mvula

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

02, Jun, 2021 @11:28 AM

Article image
LSO/Mark Elder review – a matchless Rosenkavalier
Soloists Sarah Connolly, Anne Schwanewilms and Lucy Crowe brought sensitivity and poise to Strauss's opera, and the LSO gave full value to the score's heady harmonic surges and misty-eyed nostalgia, writes George Hall

George Hall

09, May, 2014 @5:35 PM

Article image
Salome review – lethal desires and emotional extremism
Alexander Soddy made an auspicious Royal Opera debut with his wonderful conducting of this revival of David McVicar’s staging: a tragedy of horrifying power

Tim Ashley

11, Sep, 2022 @12:25 PM

Article image
LSO/Rattle/Hannigan review – Abrahamsen's masterpiece soars
In an all-Nordic programme, the 2013 song cycle Let Me Tell You lost none of its ability to bewitch in a concert that also featured Sibelius and Nielsen

Andrew Clements

11, Jan, 2019 @3:37 PM

Article image
The week in classical: Siemens Hallé international conductors competition; LSO/ Hannigan; Turandot – review
A trio of young conductors vie for a job with the Hallé; Barbara Hannigan takes Mahler at his word; and Antonio Pappano makes a thriller of Puccini’s final opera

Fiona Maddocks

18, Mar, 2023 @12:30 PM

Article image
Madama Butterfly/Der Rosenkavalier review – Glyndebourne openers perplex, provoke and charm
Annilese Miskimmon’s stripped-back Puccini update and an admirable but uneven Strauss revival opened this year’s summer festival

Tim Ashley

21, May, 2018 @11:36 AM

Article image
Der Rosenkavalier review – big guns and young lovers overcome stage obstacles
Renée Fleming leads a fine cast including Alice Coote, Sophie Bevan and Matthew Rose in a production whose romantic comedy plays out against a distractingly over-the-top backdrop

Andrew Clements

18, Dec, 2016 @2:30 PM

Article image
Der Rosenkavalier review – glittering 50s update cleverly separates love and lust
Bruno Ravella’s production has a glamorous staging that allows Miah Persson’s understated refinement to register

Tim Ashley

03, Jun, 2021 @1:32 PM

Article image
Salome review – petals, porn and dead ponies give Strauss a feminist reboot
Adena Jacobs floods her stage with blood in an English National Opera re-imagining that does not quite live up to its early intrigue

Tim Ashley

30, Sep, 2018 @10:35 AM

Article image
Strauss: Die Frau ohne Schatten review I Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
Strauss’s fairytale epic is full of magnificent detail in the hands of Christian Thielemann, while Camilla Nylund’s Empress is supple and intense

Andrew Clements

28, May, 2020 @2:00 PM