The Magic Flute review – well-behaved revival needs more of Mozart’s anarchic spirit

Royal Opera House, London
There are strong performances, particularly from Gyula Orendt’s Papageno and Sarah Dufresne’s Papagena, but the fun is damped down in David McVicar’s 2003 staging that imposes coherence on the pantomimic plot

Maxim Emelyanychev – conducting Mozart’s The Magic Flute for the first time and making his debut with the Royal Opera House orchestra – writes in a programme note that he wants to feed off the energy of the audience. But on the first night of this revival of David McVicar’s production, now in its 20th year, I wanted more of that mercurial spark of inspiration.

Not that there isn’t much to admire in the individual performances: Gyula Orendt’s Papageno is the heart of this production, turning his journey towards earthly fulfilment with Sarah Dufresne’s Papagena into the most convincing development of character and comedy in the show; Anna Prohaska’s Pamina is full of adult anguish and subtlety, especially in her act two lament, while Aigul Khismatullina’s Queen of the Night is preternaturally precise in her glass-shattering rage, and Filipe Manu’s Tamino is a solidly stentorian model of well-sung princeliness.

At the heart of this production … Gyula Orendt (Papageno) and Sarah Dufresne (Papagena).
At the heart of this production … Gyula Orendt (Papageno) and Sarah Dufresne (Papagena). Photograph: ROH/Camilla Greenwell 2022

It’s just that none of them seem to be having much fun in Angelo Smimmo’s redirection of this show, which makes The Magic Flute an earnest post-Enlightenment essay. John Macfarlane’s imposingly tenebrous sets, lit with irresistible chiaroscuro by Paule Constable, create a world of visual and atmospheric coherence for these characters that the singers can’t sustain. The clunking dichotomies of the piece – between moon and sun, man and woman, ideology and instinct – let alone the ludicrousness of its plot, are only made more obvious and more problematic.

But there’s a spirit of sheer entertainment trying to break out in this show. The cast and musicians just need the excuse to release the Magic Flute into the weird masonic pantomime it really is, whose meaning lies in its messy inconsistencies, not its sunlit coherence. For the rest of the run, get down to Covent Garden and be the audience that helps Emelyanychev get Mozart’s party started.

• At Royal Opera House, London, until 28 January.


Tom Service

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Magic Flute review – dark, eclectic and disquieting
James Brining’s new production with Opera North is a sometimes heavy-handed phantasmagoria that probes the dark heart of Mozart’s work

Tim Ashley

20, Jan, 2019 @11:27 AM

Article image
The Magic Flute – review

ENO's final revival of Nicholas Hytner's staging sends this enchanting, balanced and entertaining opera out on a high note, writes George Hall

George Hall

14, Sep, 2012 @11:39 AM

Article image
The Magic Flute – review
Wizardry and darkness fight it out in Simon McBurney's captivating new ENO production of The Magic Flute, writes Fiona Maddocks

Fiona Maddocks

10, Nov, 2013 @12:07 AM

Article image
The Magic Flute review – WNO’s hectic new version is a lightsaber too far
Daisy Evans’ psychedelic and frantic modern reworking dodges the original’s problems, but loses much of Mozart’s magic and energy in the process – and the flute itself

Rian Evans

06, Mar, 2023 @12:57 PM

Article image
René Jacobs: The Magic Flute and more
René Jacobs is celebrated for his unconventional approaches to Mozart. And, with his latest release, he has plenty of surprises in store, he tells Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

09, Sep, 2010 @9:30 PM

Article image
The Marriage of Figaro review – zippy Mozart for the #metoo era with gender swap
This revival of David McVicar’s wonderful 2006 production sees an uneven cast and John Eliot Gardiner’s conducting sometimes too overbearing

Martin Kettle

02, Jul, 2019 @2:10 PM

Article image
La Clemenza di Tito review – delight to be back, but modern-dress production fails to convince
Richard Jones’s eagerly-anticipated new production of Mozart’s opera seria has moments of insight but overall too many incongruities, but there is much to enjoy musically, especially Nicole Chevalier’s Vitellia

Tim Ashley

18, May, 2021 @12:34 PM

Article image
The Magic Flute; English music festival; Wigmore gala concert – review
Garsington's move to the Chilterns made for an enchanting Magic Flute, writes Fiona Maddocks

Fiona Maddocks

04, Jun, 2011 @11:05 PM

Article image
Il Trovatore review – dispiriting Verdi revival lacks focus
Anita Rachvelishvili is a thrilling Azucena and Richard Farnes brings emotional subtlety to the score, but David Bösch’s production is patchy

Tim Ashley

05, Dec, 2016 @1:01 PM

Article image
Macbeth review – musically formidable revival of Verdi's opera
Željko Lučić and Anna Netrebko give powerful performances and Phyllida Lloyd directs this imperfect yet intriguing revamp

Tim Ashley

27, Mar, 2018 @12:29 PM