Brahms: The Four Symphonies review | Andrew Clements' classical album of the week

Danish Chamber Orch/Adam Fischer
(Naxos, three CDs)

Emulating Brahms himself with an orchestra of fewer than 50 players, these fresh, engaging recordings show that less can mean a lot more

Though these days we generally hear the Brahms symphonies performed by a full-sized symphony orchestra of 70 or 80 players, the composer himself is said to have preferred smaller forces. The orchestra in Karlsruhe, which introduced his First Symphony, had 49 players, the Meiningen Court Orchestra, responsible for the premiere of the Fourth, numbered 48. Thomas Dausgaard recorded the four symphonies with a band of that size for BIS, and now Adam Fischer has followed his example; the exact number of players he uses isn’t given in the sleeve notes, but a photograph of the Danish Chamber Orchestra suggests there are fewer than 50 of them, and certainly these constantly fascinating performances demonstrate that, even in Brahms, less can mean a lot more.

The cover artwork for Johannes Brahms: Complete Symphonies.
The cover artwork for Johannes Brahms: Complete Symphonies. Photograph: PR handout

These aren’t period-instrument performances, though it does sound as if Fischer has encouraged his strings to ration their use of vibrato; it’s their scale, and the greater transparency that comes with using fewer strings, that pays such dividends, allowing the woodwind and brass to make their presence felt without any over-emphasis. Fischer adds even more buoyancy by paying scrupulous attention to every detail of the rhythmic articulation; he generally favours quick tempo too, though it’s rare that they seem unduly fast – the finale of the Second sets off at quite a lick, for instance, yet never seems rushed, while the finale of the Fourth loses none of its cumulative power by always being kept on the move.

These fresh, meticulously rethought performances may be worlds away from the classic recordings of these symphonies, whether it’s Herbert von Karajan’s version of the First, Claudio Abbado in the Second, Carlos Kleiber’s barnstorming Fourth, or Riccardo Chailly in all four of them, but among recent surveys, it’s hard to think of more engaging ones.

The week’s other pick

Pablo Heras-Casado has already recorded the Schumann concertos for Harmonia Mundi with the period instruments of the Freiburg Baroque Orchestra, so it’s odd that for the same label he has opted to conduct the thoroughly modern Munich Philharmonic for his survey of the four symphonies. At their best his accounts of the concertos were very impressive, but there’s little to recommend these disappointingly under-energised performances, despite occasional touches suggesting that Heras-Casado has attempted to import ideas from his experience of working with the FBO. Everything about the playing and the approach seems utterly routine, and they don’t begin to compete with the best of what’s already available: for those who want a traditional recording of these works, Wolfgang Sawallisch’s 1960s set still takes a lot of beating, while John Eliot Gardiner’s version demonstrates what historical awareness can bring to these works.

Contributor

Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Brahms: Complete Songs Vol 1 – Opp 32, 43, 86 and 105 review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
Tenor Christoph Prégardien gives an intelligent and perfectly weighted performance with pianist Ulrich Eisenlohr

Andrew Clements

13, Jan, 2022 @5:00 PM

Article image
Alexandre Kantorow: Brahms review | Erica Jeal's classical album of the week
Kantorow’s affinity with the German Romantic sparks mercurially expressive and resonant playing in this follow-up to his 2020 Brahms disc

Erica Jeal

11, Nov, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Enescu: Works for Piano review – committed and accomplished performances
Three of the Romanian composer’s underperformed, muscular works for piano are superbly interpreted by the young pianist Daria Parkhomenko

Andrew Clements

23, Feb, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Heiner Goebbels: A House of Call review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
Beckett, Rumi and first-world-war prisoners are referenced in Heiner Goebbels’ diverse score that incorporates chanting, jazz-rock, rhythmic dislocations and delicate solos

Andrew Clements

08, Sep, 2022 @2:04 PM

Article image
Sibelius: The Symphonies and Tapiola review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
The prodigious young talent has an exclusive recording contract with Decca but his debut – a Sibelius symphony cycle – is frustratingly uneven

Andrew Clements

24, Mar, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Bruckner: Symphonies Nos 1 and 5, etc review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
The conductor’s latest journey through Bruckner (and Wagner) is typically extrovert, allowing the music to flow naturally

Andrew Clements

24, Feb, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Franck: Complete Songs and Duets review – elegant and refined vocal works
Carefully shaded performances of the Belgian composer’s lesser known songs – and wonderfully comprehensive sleeve notes – help mark the bicentenary of his birth

Andrew Clements

31, Mar, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Samuel Barber: The Complete Songs review | Erica Jeal's classical album of the week
Every song Barber is known to have written is brought to life by 10 UK singers, including Nicky Spence and Mary Bevan

Erica Jeal

05, May, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Mahler: Symphonies 1-10 review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
This mammoth undertaking, of all of Mahler’s symphonies with different conductors over the last decade, brings variable musical results

Andrew Clements

18, Feb, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
Ives: Complete Symphonies review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
The conductor and his orchestra express the transcendental immensity of Ives, especially in a glorious Fourth Symphony

Andrew Clements

27, Aug, 2020 @2:00 PM