The Handmaid’s Tale review – ENO’s production of Atwood’s dystopia is chilling but slow to convince

Coliseum, London
Poul Ruder’s opera is at its most effective in its quietest moments, with the all-female production boasting strong performances from leads Emma Bell and Kate Lindsey

Years before Elisabeth Moss first put on Offred’s red kirtle and glowered at the camera from under a white visor, years before the TV series took Margaret Atwood’s book way beyond its ending, there was The Handmaid’s Tale: the opera, by the composer Poul Ruders and librettist Paul Bentley. It was premiered in Copenhagen in 2000 and staged at English National Opera three years later. Now, slightly revised by its authors – and, after Trump and 6 January, seeming more urgently relevant than ever - it’s back in a new staging, the first opera directed here by Annilese Miskimmon since she became ENO’s artistic director.

We are at a symposium listening to a newly discovered cassette tape, an artefact from Gilead, presented by an academic played by the actor Camille Cottin. Offred’s voice speaks to us first through the tape, sounding as delicate and distant as old shellac records – and then Kate Lindsey takes over in person, beginning a magnetic central performance in which it’s her voice, with its superbly controlled mix of sweetness and substance, that reveals as much as her actions.

Kate Lindsey (Offred) and Robert Hayward (The Commander) in The Handmaid’s Tale by Poul Ruders
A magnetic central performance… Kate Lindsey as Offred, with Robert Hayward (The Commander). Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

The full horror of her situation takes time to be revealed, perhaps too long: the Commander doesn’t turn up on stage for nearly an hour, and the executions in which every handmaid must be complicit happen only towards the end. The Wall displays photographs of the dead, not their hanging bodies. Yet there is subtle menace in the way the characters move in regimented lines in front of the long conference-centre curtains of Annemarie Woods’s set – and, indeed, throughout Ruders’s evocative score, vibrantly played by the ENO orchestra conducted by Joana Carneiro. High, chiming percussion adds a sheen of artificiality, and borrowings from other styles throw up brief associations: there’s a wrenching use of Bach in one of many flashbacks involving Offred’s little daughter. She’s played by the real-life daughter of Rhian Lois, who as Janine is part of a strong supporting cast along with Avery Amereau, Pumeza Matshikiza, Susan Bickley and others.

Despite Carneiro’s care, and even though Ruders has reportedly scaled back some of the scoring since the premiere, there are still passages that seem simply noisy, including much of the music for Aunt Lydia, which, despite a tour de force performance from Emma Bell, is pitched so high the surtitles are essential if you want to understand the words. The most effective moments are often the quietest, especially Offred’s intricate duet with her recorded former self – one of many grainy video flashbacks projected onto the curtains in a way that suggests The Time Before is simultaneously light-years away and close enough to touch.

The full horror takes time to be revealed… Kate Lindsey (Offred), left, in Poul Ruder’s The Handmaid’s Tale
The full horror takes time to be revealed… Kate Lindsey (Offred), left, in Poul Ruder’s The Handmaid’s Tale Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

Much was made of the fact that there was an all-female production team, with some two dozen female staffers taking a bow at the first-night curtain call. But while this opera tells a woman’s story ostensibly from a woman’s perspective, it’s not the feminist call to arms that the TV series had time and space to develop into: things happen to Offred, not because of her. If ENO wants to stage a real feminist opera it needs to look further, to more recent works, but this is at least a step in the right direction.

Contributor

Erica Jeal

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Valkyrie review – a striking, uneven start to ENO’s Ring cycle
Director Richard Jones brings magic-realist noir to Wagner’s world – with results that range from poignant to distracting

Tim Ashley

21, Nov, 2021 @1:29 PM

Article image
Margaret Atwood’s Handmaid’s Tale sequel escapes from tight secrecy
Strict measures meant to keep all details of The Testaments confidential until publication have fallen through for some US readers

Alison Flood

04, Sep, 2019 @2:17 PM

Article image
Madam Butterfly review – Minghella's production still looks good but the words are lost
With its cherry blossoms and origami birds, this 11-year-old production is strikingly beautiful, and Rena Harms and David Butt Philip give strong performances

Erica Jeal

17, May, 2016 @3:49 PM

Article image
Marnie review – Nico Muhly's psycho thriller sounds beautiful but fails to thrill
The central relationship is compelling and there is some tremendous writing for the ENO chorus, but Muhly’s stylised opera lacks Hitchcockian suspense

Tim Ashley

19, Nov, 2017 @4:14 PM

Article image
The Winter's Tale review – striking sounds but not enough fury in new Shakespearean opera
Rory Kinnear debuts as director for English National Opera in Ryan Wigglesworth’s accomplished first opera, but the inventive music fails to take charge of the story

Andrew Clements

28, Feb, 2017 @2:58 PM

Article image
ENO: The Yeomen of the Guard review – tonal uncertainties but G&S update has plenty to enjoy
Jo Davies’ 1950-set staging of the late G&S opera may not fully cohere but musically we’re in excellent hands and Richard McCabe’s is a moving – and sweatily desperate – Jack Point

Michael Billington

04, Nov, 2022 @12:02 PM

Article image
Orpheus in the Underworld review – balloons for tutus and jarring tragedy
Emma Rice’s imaginative reworking features lovely singing, pleasing comedy, striking stage designs – and a misjudged moment of sadness

Erica Jeal

06, Oct, 2019 @12:49 PM

Article image
Billy Budd review – magnificently sung production is slow to focus
Deborah Warner’s version of Britten’s most conflicted opera takes too long to reach the dramatic intensity its superb singers merit

Andrew Clements

24, Apr, 2019 @11:02 AM

Article image
Partenope review – Handel on a night out with beardy bohemians
Despite the culottes and mustachios, ENO’s revival of its 2008 production retains enough substance to back up its arch styling

Erica Jeal

16, Mar, 2017 @11:37 AM

Article image
The Day After review – devastation, dead cats and godlike grandeur
English National Opera’s rehearsal space becomes a post-apocalyptic crater in an imaginative and strongly sung production of Jonathan Dove’s chamber opera

George Hall

29, May, 2017 @1:09 PM