What is the most overhyped cultural artefact of all time?

From Godzilla to Donda via Michael Jackson’s HIStory, entertainment is littered with marketing stunts aimed at fooling the consumer

In the Guide’s weekly Solved! column, we look into a crucial pop-culture question you’ve been burning to know the answer to – and settle it

Whatever you think of Kanye West, he remains hip-hop’s greatest salesman. His three pre-release stadium listening parties ensured that Donda, his third sub-par album on the trot, debuted with an undeserved bang. But even his manicfrenzied self-promotion doesn’t earn him a seat at the top table in the history of hype.

The origins of the word lie in criminality. In the 1920s, a hype was someone who short-changed customers. In the 60s music business, hype meant fixing chart positions through shady means. Now the word is generally applied to legal activity but it should still describe the gap between publicity and reality: the phrase “lives up to the hype” is oxymoronic. If hype delivers on its promises, then it’s no longer hype; it’s just great marketing. Take Michael Jackson in the 90s. He may have been guilty of stunning hubris when his team demanded that he be referred to as the “King of Pop” and towed a 10-metre-high MJ statue down the Thames, but his hits collection HIStory did become the biggest-selling double album of all time. Job done.

Real hype must end in failure and embarrassment, such as the infamous case of Suffolk rock band Brinsley Schwarz. In 1970, their aptly named managers Famepushers Ltd paid a fortune to fly scores of British journalists to a prestigious show in New York. But the jet had to make an emergency landing in Ireland, stranding the hacks in a free bar. When they reached the venue at the last minute they were hungover or still drunk. The stunt guaranteed a sour reception for the show and the debut album; it was 34 years before the band repaid their record label debt.

In Hollywood, the zenith (or nadir) of hype remains the 1998 Godzilla movie. Forbes reported that TriStar Pictures spent $50m on marketing and its commercial partners, including Taco Bell, a further $150m, thus exceeding the movie’s entire production budget. Between the saturated billboard campaign (“Size Does Matter”) and the 3,000 branded products, from pizzas to batteries, there was no escape. The (terrible) movie did make a profit but not enough to justify sequels or shift action figures, and is remembered as a giant waste of time and money.

That cash-drunk period just before the dotcom crash (itself the consequence of hype) was stuffed with expensive disappointments, from Be Here Now to The Phantom Menace to the carnage of Woodstock 99, but even they look benign next to the multi-billion-dollar hypes now generated by tech companies: at this point, the most egregious case of hype should be one that combines showbusiness with Silicon Valley snake oil, thus restoring the word to its original definition as something crooked – something with victims.

Enter 2017’s Fyre festival, an era-defining scam fuelled by the hot air of Instagram influencers and tech-bro bullshit. A once-in-a-lifetime experience for all the wrong reasons, it failed to deliver tolerable food and accommodation, let alone music, and ended up sending blowhard promoter Billy McFarland to jail for wire fraud. There are people who enjoyed Godzilla, or had fun at Woodstock 99, but there isn’t a single soul who had a great time at Fyre. Brinsley Schwarz got off lightly.


Dorian Lynskey

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Repeat offenders: what is the most overplayed song?
It has to be an omnipresent, year-round stinker. So which is it?

Luke Holland

31, May, 2021 @12:00 PM

Article image
Meet Chubby and the Gang, UK punk’s most vital new band
Charlie Manning Walker, AKA Chubby, on why his band’s fast and furious songs are what the world needs right now

James McMahon

17, Nov, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
What Europe is really listening to
From the French Madonna to the king of German ‘raop’, these are the continent’s true pop superstars

Peter Robinson

15, Jun, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
Why Janet Jackson’s Pleasure Principle is pop’s most influential video
If Dua Lipa and Silk City’s video for Electricity feels familiar that’s because Janet did it first In 1986. Here’s how the video changed the pop landscape

Leonie Cooper

05, Oct, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
What ended Britpop: Oasis, Diana or Euro 96?
A quarter of a century on, debate still rages about the demise of the lager-loving scene. But who was the real culprit?

Matt Charlton

12, Oct, 2020 @12:00 PM

Article image
AG Cook: the nutty producer behind the decade's most divisive music
Having polarised pop with the abrasive PC Music, he’s now going solo. ‘I trust my own dislike of things’, he says

Rachel Aroesti

16, Sep, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
What’s the most important part of a song: melody or lyrics?
While the two are often inextricably entwined, there can only be one winner when it comes to a song’s vital ingredient

Niall Doherty

23, Aug, 2021 @12:00 PM

Article image
Britney, bust-ups and 'B-List at Capital': how Steps staged pop’s most unlikely comeback
The return of Britain’s ‘naffest’ chart toppers put the fun back into today’s precision-tooled pop landscape

Michael Cragg

06, Jan, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
‘This is the most exciting moment I’ve experienced’: the artists changing the face of metal
Long mired in sexism, racism and homophobia, the rock genre is being transformed by a wave of progressive artists

Dannii Leivers

04, May, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Piercing feedback and pig noises: what's the most out-there album ever?
Defying tradition and bothering the mainstream, the likes of John Cage, Matthew Herbert, Laurie Anderson and Lou Reed battle it out for the best of the bizarre

Daniel Dylan Wray

01, Mar, 2021 @1:00 PM