Amyl and the Sniffers: Comfort to Me review – harder, more intense, erupting with defiance

Frontwoman Amy Taylor crackles like a live wire with too much current in Melbourne punk band’s electric second album

Anger, as the punk formerly known as Johnny Rotten put it, is an energy. For Amy Taylor, singer for Melbourne band Amyl and the Sniffers, it’s a renewable resource. “It’s my currency,” she tells us on Guided by Angels, the rip-roaring opener from the band’s second album, Comfort to Me. An electric performer, Taylor crackles like a live wire with too much current running through it.

One can only imagine what Melbourne’s long lockdown, and not being able to perform, has done to the psyche of someone like Taylor. Comfort to Me gets it all out in an eruption that’s more intense, and much less playful, than their self-titled debut from 2019. Taylor’s voice is defiantly flat, yet more powerful – like a poetry slammer fronting the Cosmic Psychos, the Sniffers’ spiritual forebears.

In Taylor’s words, she’s a “little bit classy, bit of a rat”. But she’s no cartoon figure, and the lowbrow profanity of a song like Don’t Need A Cunt Like You To Love Me is no joke. Like much of Comfort to Me, it’s an expression of independence and confidence. “I’m a businesswoman, run my own company,” she spits. The Sniffers swing furiously behind her in defence: “She’s 10 out of 10 / You’re so-so / You think you can fuck with her? / Hell no!”

In many respects, Taylor is reminiscent of the late Wendy O. Williams, who fronted New York shock-rock band the Plasmatics. She’ll show you her body, but only on her own contradictory terms; there’s an inner refusal to conform to anyone’s expectations of who she is, or should be. “I am still a hot girl, go on take a look” she sings in Laughing, flipping the bird at those who refuse to take her seriously: “You can keep fucking laughing!”

Cover image for Comfort to Me

At times, Comfort to Me is terrifying. Knifey is about going armed in self-defence as a woman. Taylor makes it sound perfectly reasonable: all she wants is to go for a walk in the park and, unlike Courtney Barnett, she’s not messing around with keys between her fingers. “Out comes the night, out comes my knifey / This is how I get home nicely,” she hollers. The threat of violence is a persistent undercurrent in Comfort to Me.

Yet there’s also a disarming vulnerability. Hertz, No More Tears and Maggot are all twisted love songs (the last featuring the lyric: “C’mon maggot, put your maggots in me” – Feel Like Makin’ Love it is not). Capital pushes the band into more political territory, something Taylor admits she’s only beginning to get a handle on, but it starts with a recognition that she’s part of a machine: “They sexualise my body and get mad when I exploit it”.

The best song here is the second single, Security. Behind all the bravado and self-defence, Taylor really just wants to be loved. It also captures the Sniffers at their peak musically. They’re a rhythm and boogie machine, Gus Romer’s bass laying down the tracks for drummer Bryce Wilson and guitarist Dec Martens to run on. By the end of the song, Martens pushes the band into pure white noise. As another live wire once said, stick this in your fusebox.

• Comfort to Me by Amyl and the Sniffers is out now


Andrew Stafford

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Amyl and the Sniffers review – turning pub rock bravado into punk mayhem
Debut album from the Melbourne punk band lives up to the ferocious sound of their hard-to-follow live act

Isabella Trimboli

24, May, 2019 @1:34 AM

Article image
Amyl and the Sniffers: Amyl and the Sniffers review – blunt-force, yob-glam punk
Melbourne band’s debut cannot live up to its own hype, though there are tight riffs and fun to be had

Michael Hann

24, May, 2019 @9:30 AM

Article image
One to watch: Amyl and the Sniffers
The Melbourne punk band’s no-holds-barred approach feels refreshingly uncontrived

Jude Rogers

04, May, 2019 @1:00 PM

Article image
Amyl and the Sniffers review – a blizzard from Oz
Channelling singer Amy Taylor’s rage and joyous abandon, the Australian punk band bring their second album to glorious fighting life

Kitty Empire

28, Nov, 2021 @5:30 AM

Article image
Witch Hats review – intense blasts of modern Australia as dystopian nightmare
Rough-hewn but intelligent, the third album from the Melbourne post-punk band is intense, melodic and undeniably Australian

Andrew Stafford

30, Jun, 2016 @10:29 PM

Article image
Josh Pyke, the Veronicas, Lime Cordiale and more: Australian music for isolated times
Each week we add 15 (or so) new songs to a Spotify playlist to soundtrack your physical distancing amid coronavirus – and help artists you love get paid

Guardian staff

03, Jul, 2020 @11:00 PM

Article image
Alice Ivy, Tkay Maidza, Paul Kelly and more: Australian music for isolated times
Each week we add 15 (or so) new songs to a Spotify playlist to soundtrack your physical distancing amid coronavirus – and help artists you love get paid

Guardian staff

18, Jul, 2020 @8:00 PM

Article image
Iggy Pop review – punk's real wild child just loves to be loved
That supple physique can’t move quite like it used to, but 71-year-old’s voice is in unbelievably good shape

Andrew Stafford

16, Apr, 2019 @12:55 AM

Article image
Download festival review – Slayer cast dark spells with ferocious swan song set
British hard rock festival brings angst, anger and a lot of black lipstick to western Sydney’s peaceful parklands

Nathan Dunne

11, Mar, 2019 @1:43 AM

Article image
Amyl and the Sniffers’ Amy Taylor: ‘I wanna punch stuff and yell ... but not all the time’
Having blazed a trail with raucous gigs, the Melbourne punk band’s singer deepens her oft-caricatured image on their new album

Brodie Lancaster

04, Sep, 2021 @9:00 AM