The Barber of Seville review – creaky WNO production heralds welcome return

Millennium Centre, Cardiff
The 35-year-old production has lost much of its stylish Italianate precision but Heather Lowe’s Rosina impressed, and other soloists kept the comedy lively

Welsh National Opera have been so noticeably absent from their main stages for a long 18 months – July’s small-scale Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland was a National Trust country garden affair – their return to live performance is, of course, to be welcomed. That much was made plain by this enthusiastic, if less-than-capacity, first night audience. Yet as the company launches its 75th anniversary season, putting on a production that’s 35 years old and audibly creaking – jettisoning a newer, less successful, Barber – seemed like retrograde progress, hardly a defiantly dynamic, let alone triumphant, return to business.

Giles Havergal, the original director, returned to oversee this revival, its basic conceit being a travelling company setting up to sing in a piazza. The tight squeeze of a set with its countless potential trip-up factors has always made this slightly nerve-racking to watch: here, though, the main obstacle was Robert David Macdonald’s English translation, clunky and full of tongue-twisters, too often a scramble of words, and too few laughs gained to justify the choice.

A pert and graceful presence... Heather Lowe as Rosina in WNO's Barber of Seville
A pert and graceful presence... Heather Lowe as Rosina Photograph: Richard Hubert Smith

For such a seasoned performer as Andrew Shore, this was no problem: his crusty Dr Bartolo, on whom the comedy hinges, was strong on caricature. As Bartolo’s ward Rosina, Heather Lowe boasted the best possible diction, her clearly focused mezzo soprano well projected. It was Lowe’s pert and graceful presence that dominated the ensembles rather than Nico Darmanin’s Count Almaviva or Nicholas Lester’s Figaro, the latter’s recitative patter lacking the panache Rossini’s factotum really needs. Keel Watson’s Don Basilio maximised his role in the farcical moments.

The wind section of the WNO Orchestra delivered their solo lines with flair but, perhaps due to the necessary distancing in the pit, the string sound got rather swallowed and, while conductor Tomáš Hanus was happy to be back at the helm, overall, there was simply not enough of the stylish Italianate precision that has characterised this production in the past.

• At the Millennium Centre, Cardiff on 29 and 30 of September and touring until 2 December.

Rian Evans

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

The Barber of Seville – review
With elements of the characterisations almost camped up, Rossini's natural sparkle appeared to have become a secondary concern, writes Rian Evans

Rian Evans

02, Oct, 2011 @3:48 PM

The Barber of Seville, Millennium Centre, Cardiff

Millennium Centre, Cardiff

Rian Evans

10, Oct, 2005 @11:02 PM

Article image
The Barber of Seville review – colourful but crass
Nicholas Lester shines as Figaro, but the humour is overdone in the WNO’s heavy-going revision of Rossini’s witty opera

Rian Evans

15, Feb, 2016 @12:55 PM

Opera review: The Barber of Seville, Millennium Centre, Cardiff

Millennium Centre, Cardiff
In Welsh National Opera's revival, it is clear from the immaculate overture that precision would be the byword of conductor Gareth Jones, says Rian Evans

Rian Evans

01, Oct, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland review – Welsh National Opera return with slick and zany family show
Will Todd’s Lewis Carroll-based opera sees WNO return to live performances with Fflur Wyn’s Alice the out-and-out star

Rian Evans

29, Jun, 2021 @8:51 AM

Article image
The Barber of Seville – review

Lucy Crowe's sparkle in the role of Rosina adds an extra touch of brilliance, writes George Hall

George Hall

27, Feb, 2013 @5:53 PM

Article image
Der Rosenkavalier review – balances humour and emotion
Olivia Fuchs’s new production for Welsh National Opera updates Strauss’s opera to 1911 and a world about to change for ever

Rian Evans

05, Jun, 2017 @5:32 PM

Article image
Hansel and Gretel review – a must-see production
The singing is wholly delightful, and the voices are better matched than any to date, writes Rian Evans

Rian Evans

23, Feb, 2015 @5:28 PM

Article image
Carmen review – WNO unleashes free spirit on Brazil's favelas
A frenetic mix of gunrunners, drug gangs and slum workers assail feisty mezzo Virginie Verrez in Jo Davies’s interpretation of Bizet with added feminist verismo

Rian Evans

22, Sep, 2019 @12:35 PM

Article image
Khovanshchina review – Russia's tragedy becomes the world's in compelling revival
Welsh National Opera mark the centenary of the 1917 revolutions in this chilling, brilliantly designed production of Mussorgsky’s complex opera

Rian Evans

24, Sep, 2017 @1:14 PM