HMS Pinafore review – ENO’s shipshape satire ramps up the camp

Coliseum, London
This is Gilbert and Sullivan played for laughs and the whole cast, including a creditable Les Dennis as Sir Joseph, are clearly having a whale of a time

Doubtless aiming for the feelgood factor, English National Opera’s first new production since lockdown is HMS Pinafore, Gilbert and Sullivan’s guarded 1878 satire on class, social mobility and Englishness, directed by Cal McCrystal and conducted by Chris Hopkins. It also marks the operatic debut of comedian Les Dennis as Sir Joseph Porter, the admiral and cabinet minister ludicrously unqualified for his job – as much an issue then, it would seem, as it is now. Dennis’s presence might raise eyebrows, but we should remember that he has already appeared in musicals and acted with the RSC. His Sir Joseph is an ineffectual old soak, who believes himself above the egalitarian values he ostensibly professes, and despite interpolated jokes about his not really being an opera singer, he delivers his patter numbers perfectly well.

McCrystal’s staging, however, can be hit and miss. The Victorian setting is maintained, though Gilbert’s dialogue is elaborated to take in references to, among other things, levelling up and cronyism, and also to permit louche innuendos about “bulwarks,” “frigates,” “big topmen” and the like. McCrystal’s fondness for visual comedy allows him to add into the mix both a tottery old lady (Flick Fernando) among Dennis’s retinue – an ageist joke that at times misfires – and an anarchic midshipman, brilliantly played by Rufus Bateman, who is scene-stealing throughout. The ship’s crew go in for tap dancing, nicely choreographed by Lizzi Gee, and there’s a hilarious gag in the middle of For He Is an Englishman, which gloriously punctures its grandiosity. The downside, however, is that in camping up something that already teeters on camp, McCrystal can go over the top: scenes such as Josephine’s (Alexandra Oomens) quiet musings on her love for Elgan Llŷr Thomas’s Ralph, for instance, would be more effective played straight.

John Savournin (centre) as Captain Corcoran in with cast and crew of HMS Pinafore at the Coliseum
Terrific fun... John Savournin (centre) as Captain Corcoran in with cast and crew of HMS Pinafore at the Coliseum Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

Musically it’s very fine. Hopkins keeps things elegant, buoyant and witty. Thomas and Oomens are lovely in their duets and arias. As Captain Corcoran, the excellent John Savournin gives us an object lesson in how to do Gilbert and Sullivan, with phrases nicely shaped and words finely pointed. Hilary Summers, with her rich contralto, is his funny, yet touching Little Buttercup, while Marcus Farnsworth’s Bill Bobstay and Ossian Huskinson’s beefcake Bob Becket are luxury casting indeed. The chorus, throwing themselves into the big routines, look and sound as if they are having terrific fun throughout.


Tim Ashley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The week in classical: HMS Pinafore; 12 Ensemble – review
The ENO delights with a lavish staging of the Gilbert and Sullivan comic opera, while the conductor-less string group tackle Max Richter’s mesmerising take on Vivaldi

Fiona Maddocks

06, Nov, 2021 @12:30 PM

Article image
Iolanthe review – House of Lords satire bursts with frothy exuberance
Coliseum, London
Cal McCrystal brings good-natured silliness, a revolving woolsack and a pantomime cow to this beautifully performed Gilbert and Sullivan revival

Erica Jeal

14, Feb, 2018 @12:21 PM

Article image
The Mikado review – Scottish Opera shakes Gilbert and Sullivan money maker
Colourful new production takes a few pokes at tax evaders and Volkswagen, though it misses the subversive point

Kate Molleson

15, May, 2016 @3:51 PM

Article image
The Pirates of Penzance review – precise patter aplenty in Mike Leigh revival
ENO’s surefooted return for Leigh’s 2015 Gilbert and Sullivan production has a cast richly decked with boastful pirates and a proto-Wagnerian police chief

George Hall

12, Feb, 2017 @10:59 AM

Article image
The Gondoliers review – a picture-postcard Gilbert and Sullivan from Scottish Opera
The company celebrated its return to the Theatre Royal with some good old-fashioned – if not downright antiquated – fun and frivolity

Rowena Smith

17, Oct, 2021 @12:41 PM

Article image
ENO: The Yeomen of the Guard review – tonal uncertainties but G&S update has plenty to enjoy
Jo Davies’ 1950-set staging of the late G&S opera may not fully cohere but musically we’re in excellent hands and Richard McCabe’s is a moving – and sweatily desperate – Jack Point

Michael Billington

04, Nov, 2022 @12:02 PM

Article image
Patience – review
The strength of the production lies in its realisation that Sullivan's tunes cry out to be danced, writes Michael Billington

Michael Billington

20, Feb, 2012 @6:56 PM

Article image
The Valkyrie review – a striking, uneven start to ENO’s Ring cycle
Director Richard Jones brings magic-realist noir to Wagner’s world – with results that range from poignant to distracting

Tim Ashley

21, Nov, 2021 @1:29 PM

Article image
The Mikado – review

This small-scale production of Gilbert and Sullivan's The Mikado is pitched somewhere between theatre of the absurd and vaudeville, and comes over with almost reckless gusto, writes George Hall

George Hall

08, Nov, 2011 @6:37 PM

Article image
Cal McCrystal on Iolanthe: 'It deserves to be as fruity as we can possibly make it'
Does Gilbert and Sullivan need updating for our changed times? Cal McCrystal explains why his joyful new Iolanthe contains not a single lecherous peer but plenty of feisty fairies

Cal McCrystal

13, Feb, 2018 @7:25 PM