Mahler & Ye: The Song of the Earth review – song-symphony returns to its golden age

Michelle DeYoung/Brian Jagde/Liping Zhang/Shenyang/Shanghai SO/Long Yu
(Deutsche Grammophon, two CDs)

Xiaogang Ye sets the Tang-era Chinese poems that ultimately inspired Mahler’s Das Lied von der Erde to colourful new music

The texts that Mahler used for Das Lied von der Erde, his great song-symphony, came to him third-hand. The German words he set had been translated from the French, which was in turn versions of poems from the golden age of Chinese literature during the Tang dynasty (AD618-907). The convoluted process took them very far from the much more concise originals, and in 2005 the conductor Long Yu asked the composer Xiaogang Ye for an orchestral song cycle using the Chinese versions of the texts that Mahler set; he compares and contrasts the two works on this recording with the Shanghai Symphony.

Mahler and Ye: The Song of the Earth album cover
Mahler & Ye: The Song of the Earth album cover Photograph: PR Handout

Though Ye’s The Song of the Earth ends with the two poems Mahler brought together for his valedictory Abschied, he chooses a different order for the earlier ones, and opts for soprano and baritone soloists (Liping Zhang and Shenyang) rather than Mahler’s mezzo and tenor. His treatment of the concise texts is much more extrovert and histrionic than anything in Das Lied von der Erde, too, with frequent use of glissandos, particularly in the soprano writing. Ye studied in the west with Alexander Goehr and Louis Andriessen, but his musical language is an amalgam of earlier 20th-century styles, beginning with Debussy, Ravel and Stravinsky, with just occasional Chinese elements. It’s all very colourful, if sometimes rather overwrought.

Ye’s song cycle seems to inhabit an utterly different expressive world from that of the Mahler, but Yu’s performance of the earlier work isn’t convincing. Though the playing of the Shanghai Symphony is generally excellent, at 58 minutes it’s one of the faster versions of Das Lied on record, rather bright and brittle at times. And while the tenor Brian Jagde has the vocal muscle to cope with Mahler’s demands, there’s not enough lyrical warmth in his singing, and the mezzo Michelle DeYoung sounds utterly unengaged, her words mostly indecipherable.

This week’s other pick

There’s more Mahler on the first disc from the Bayerische Staatsoper’s own label, a performance of the Seventh Symphony recorded at concerts in the Munich Nationaltheater in 2018, conducted by Kirill Petrenko, who was then the company’s music director. Petrenko has made so few recordings that this is bound to be compelling listening, but it’s also a fascinating interpretation of Mahler’s most challenging symphony in its own right, never missing a textural detail, and strictly observing all of the score’s dislocations and abrupt tempo changes. It may not always be a comfortable experience, but it is a riveting one.


Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mahler: Das Lied von der Erde review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
The conductor’s fine recording with the Berlin Radio Symphony has accuracy, perception and crystalline detail

Andrew Clements

13, Aug, 2020 @2:00 PM

Article image
Mahler/Cooke: Symphony No 10 review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
Part of his cycle of works by Mahler, Vänskä’s stoic approach pays dividends in the composer’s unfinished work, with unswerving instrumental detail

Andrew Clements

25, Mar, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra/Fischer review – rich and urgent Mahler
The orchestra who premiered the work in 1912 gave Mahler’s Ninth Symphony a fierce and articulate performance under Ádám Fischer

Tim Ashley

21, Feb, 2019 @11:59 AM

Article image
Mahler: Das Lied von der Erde CD review – Jonas Kaufmann delivers a real disappointment

Andrew Clements

29, Mar, 2017 @3:43 PM

Article image
Mahler: Titan review – period instrument insights into a beautiful mind
Before Mahler’s First Symphony reached its final form, it was a ‘tone poem’, well revived here on German and Viennese instruments

Andrew Clements

09, May, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
Mahler: Symphonies 1-10 review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
This mammoth undertaking, of all of Mahler’s symphonies with different conductors over the last decade, brings variable musical results

Andrew Clements

18, Feb, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
The best classical music works of the 21st century
Over the coming week, the Guardian will select the greatest culture since 2000, carefully compiled by critics and editors. We begin with a countdown of defining classical music compositions, from X-rated opera to high-tech string quartets

Andrew Clements, Fiona Maddocks. John Lewis, Kate Molleson, Tom Service, Erica Jeal and Tim Ashley

12, Sep, 2019 @4:20 PM

Mahler: Symphony No 7 – review
Jonathan Nott gives one of Mahler's greatest challenges a credible shot, writes Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

15, Mar, 2012 @10:30 PM

Article image
Mahler: Symphony X CD review – insubstantial additions to an unfinished work
Yoel Gamzou’s interpolations of the great unfinished work are intrusive and his tempi can be irritating, but there are some transfiguring moments

Andrew Clements

31, Aug, 2016 @4:04 PM

Article image
Mahler: Symphony No 8 DVD review – Chailly pays impressive tribute to Abbado
Riccardo Chailly’s debut concert with the Swiss orchestra, dedicated to his mentor Claudio Abbado, is thoughtful and measured

Andrew Clements

22, Jun, 2017 @5:00 PM