Mahler: Symphonies 1-10 review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week

Berlin Philharmonic/Harding/Nelsons/ Dudamel/Nézet-Séguin/Petrenko/Rattle/ Haitink/Abbado
(Berliner Philharmoniker, 10 CDs & 4 Blu-ray Discs, or download)
This mammoth undertaking, of all of Mahler’s symphonies with different conductors over the last decade, brings variable musical results

Ten symphonies, eight conductors, but just one orchestra: there’s no doubt that the Berlin Philharmonic is the star of the show in this cycle of Mahler performances, taken from concerts given in the Berlin Philharmonie over the last 10 years. The earliest recordings – Claudio Abbado conducting the opening movement of the unfinished 10th Symphony on the exact centenary of Mahler’s death, and Simon Rattle’s performance of the Eighth – date from 2011; the most recent, the Sixth Symphony under their successor as chief conductor, Kirill Petrenko, comes from the beginning of last year. As usual with releases on the orchestra’s own label, alongside the audio recordings the lavishly packaged set also includes high-definition videos of all the performances.

Berlin Philharmonic: Gustav Mahler Symphonies 1-10, album cover.
Berlin Philharmonic: Gustav Mahler Symphonies 1-10, album cover. Photograph: Berliner Philharmoniker

The presentation is immaculate, and technically the playing of this outstanding orchestra is superlative. But as you might expect when conductors with such very different interpretative approaches are involved, the musical results are variable, and it’s unlikely that anyone will find all of them to their taste. At one extreme, there’s Yannick Nézet-Séguin’s glib, superficial account of the Fourth Symphony; at the other are Abbado’s searing performance of the 10th’s great Adagio, and Bernard Haitink’s noble, gloriously elegiac Ninth. The rest fall somewhere in between.

Daniel Harding’s First Symphony is perhaps a little under-characterised, but always carefully moulded and immaculately paced; Andris Nelsons’ Second, the Resurrection Symphony, is certainly integrated more convincingly than the performance he conducted in Birmingham in 2009, but is never the overwhelming experience a great account of this work can be. Gustavo Dudamel and Rattle each conduct two works. If Dudamel allows the tension to sag too often in the Fifth Symphony, especially in the outer movements, his account of the Third seems very fine, the arc of its opening movement perfectly traced, the finale sustained to a blazing climax.

Rattle takes on perhaps the biggest challenges in the Mahler canon, the Seventh and Eighth Symphonies. If he never quite solves the problem of the Seventh’s finale, he projects the epic canvases of the Eighth with all the pictorial vividness they demand. And Petrenko’s Sixth is very much on the credit side, too – a thoroughly traditional performance (the scherzo placed third in the sequence, the finale’s third hammer blow not reinstated), but one that balances quite beautifully the work’s tragic trajectory with its moments of elation.

Most Mahlerians are likely find something to impress them in this set, but at a considerable cost. Most of the major Mahler cycles on disc – those by Rafael Kubelík and Leonard Bernstein as well as Abbado, Haitink and Rattle, are available at significantly less than half the price of this one, and even the prestige of this great orchestra isn’t enough to compensate for that.


Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Berlin Phil: Europa Concerts 1991-2015 DVD review – a set of special things to savour
A quarter century of broadcast Europa Concerts are brought together in this extensive DVD set that features some exceptional performances

Andrew Clements

22, Jun, 2016 @2:00 PM

Article image
Prom 62: Berlin Philharmonic/Petrenko review – sinister magic marks a concert of startling brilliance
Petrenko proved his mastery of Mahler’s Seventh yet again as he brought out its lurking ambiguity in a performance that hovered between dream and nightmare

Tim Ashley

04, Sep, 2022 @12:02 PM

Article image
Tchaikovsky: Symphony No 6 review | Andrew Clements' classical album of the week
Kirill Petrenko’s first recording with his new orchestra has plenty to admire but taken as a whole feels rather underpowered

Andrew Clements

16, May, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
The John Adams Edition CD review – Berlin's lavish homage to an American great
This extensive Berlin Phil set is a treat, with some of Adams’s most substantial compositions given fine performances under the batons of the composer himself, Simon Rattle and Kirill Petrenko

Andrew Clements

29, Nov, 2017 @3:02 PM

CD: Mahler: Symphony No 4; Berg: Seven Early Songs


Tim Ashley

18, Nov, 2005 @1:13 AM

Article image
Bruckner: Symphonies Nos 1 and 5, etc review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
The conductor’s latest journey through Bruckner (and Wagner) is typically extrovert, allowing the music to flow naturally

Andrew Clements

24, Feb, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Berlin Philharmonic/Rattle – review

Mahler's Third Symphony ends the Berlin Philharmonic's London residency, with conductor Rattle in formidable form, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

24, Feb, 2011 @9:34 AM

Article image
The Asia Tour review – impressive Berlin Phil showcase as Rattle's reign nears end
Cho/Wang/Berliner Philharmoniker/Rattle
(Berliner Philharmoniker Recordings, five SACDs and Blu-ray)
An astonishingly vivid Petrushka is the highlight of a thoroughly documented final Asian tour

Andrew Clements

03, May, 2018 @2:00 PM

Berlin Philharmonic residency – review

Without each other, Rattle and the Berlin Philharmonic would still excel. Together, they are unbeatable, writes Erica Jeal

Erica Jeal

21, Feb, 2011 @12:54 AM

Berlin Philharmonic: A Musical Journey in 3D – review
This 3D recording of Simon Rattle conducting in Mahler and Rachmaninov is dazzling, writes Guy Dammann

Guy Dammann

09, May, 2011 @4:03 PM