Richard and Linda Thompson: Hard Luck Stories 1972–1982 review – a tempestuous tale worth retelling

This eight-CD box set includes 31 previously unreleased tracks, not to mention every twist and turn of this most compelling of double acts

Box sets often exist merely to evacuate the wallets of the faithful. Here, though, over eight CDs (or a big download) is the story of one of the most intriguing partnerships in British music: the silvery folk-rock duo Richard and Linda Thompson. It is a tale worth retelling – and shelling out for.

As vocalists, the Thompsons shared a startling contralto directness that, squared, offered up a vision of often spare, unfussy beauty at one remove from convention or theatricality. This chronology kicks off with the pair’s first casual rock’n’roll experiments for a low-key ensemble project. It ends with the duo’s live immolation, when the Thompsons fulfilled lucrative 1982 tour dates despite their relationship having, as one of their most famous songs goes, “withered and died”.

A little like Fleetwood Mac – a more lucrative British late-60s outcropping – these former soulmates sang songs about their curdled love at one another across blasted North American stages. But Stevie Nicks never gave birth in a Sufi squat without hot water or electricity, or stole a car in Canada on a bender; she may never have kicked Lindsay Buckingham’s shins while he soloed – unlike Linda Pettifer, who, pre-Richard, performed as Linda Peters.

“After I hit Richard on the head with the Coca-Cola bottle it was fine,” Linda Thompson reminisced about that final tour to Rolling Stone in 1985. “I suddenly went from being this lady with three children – covered in scarves, with my eyes turned to the ground – to stealing cars and living on vodka and antidepressants. And I felt fabulous! Hitting everybody. You know, people’d say good morning to me and I’d say, ‘Fuck off.’ It was great therapy.”

The ballad of Richard and Linda has been rehearsed a great many times before of course, and the Thompsons’ work has been amply bootlegged and box-setted previously. But there are many great verses here not previously aired.

Richard Thompson’s Amazon Queen

Key to the excitement of this collection is its 31 unreleased tracks – such as Amazon Queen, an early Richard Thompson psych-pop outtake, or the demo of Dimming of the Day, unadorned and devastating, on a CD devoted to the duo’s 1975 album Pour Down Like Silver and its outtakes.

Having met in the heady swirl of the British folk-rock scene in the late 60s, Richard (formerly of Fairport Convention, then solo) and Linda (folk singer and jobbing jingles vocalist) first toured under the tongue-in-cheek name Sour Grapes before formalising as a duo with the 1974 release of I Want to See the Bright Lights Tonight.

Included with the remastered Bright Lights album is Mother and Son, a truly spooky, freak-folk outtake, and a revelatory version of the none-more-bleak The End of the Rainbow. Sung mostly by Linda, this warning of life’s grief and peril to a babe-in-arms is, perhaps, even more unsettling than the canonical Richard original.

Around the time of Pour Down Like Silver, however, Richard – always a searching, unconventional creative – convinced Linda to retreat further from the mainstream and embrace Sufism. As they moved between communities, ridding themselves of possessions and adhering to strict gender roles, Richard stopped playing guitar entirely in a bid to renounce worldliness. So when, in 1977, the duo reunited on stage with a new band composed of Sufi-community fellow-travellers, it was an occasion – one captured in the terrific live performances of disc 5, subtitled The Madness of Love.

A handful of excellent unreleased songs, never recorded in a studio, from their set at London’s Theatre Royal, Drury Lane capture Richard’s spiritual immersion, his understanding of Arabic and north African music and some novel, almost funk fusions, electric piano to the fore. Linda is in magnificent voice, despite previous and subsequent battles with the vocal cord condition spasmodic dysphonia.

The immense A Bird in God’s Garden makes plain the connections between the harmonic drones to which the couple were already partial and the devotional music of the near east. The song’s words are derived from Rumi; in 1972, a British band of Sufi convert folk musicians called the Habibiyya, some of whom ended up in the Thompsons’ live band, recorded a song of the same name. But this taut almost-jam stands alone – lyrical and hypnotic.. But this taut almost-jam stands alone – lyrical and hypnotic.

It’s accompanied by a beautiful, near 13-minute version of Pour Down Like’s Silver’s Night Comes In, sung here more by Linda. Bearing all the hallmarks of a love song, Richard’s devotion is directed not towards his partner, but to the divine: the leader of their sect had given his permission for the duo to record and perform, but only if it were in the service of God.

Shoot Out the Lights (1982) was the couple’s final, most celebrated album, in which the end was harrowingly obvious to everyone but the Thompsons themselves. The bounty on CD 8 includes outtakes and a spellbinding final-tour version of Pavanne, a Thompson co-write about a female assassin.

It is tempting to read a great deal into this song’s portrait of female agency and bloodthirstiness. But the draw here is Linda Thompson’s voice – clear and non-judgmental, unhitched from her inner critic thanks to the vodka and antidepressants. Richard Thompson’s guitar is uncharacteristically restrained – almost respectful.


Kitty Empire

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Thompson: Family review – Richard and Linda Thompson (almost) reunited on son’s album
The parents overshadow their children on this family affair, writes Ally Carnwath

Ally Carnwath

16, Nov, 2014 @12:05 AM

Richard Thompson: Electric – review
The folk-rock guitar hero has plugged in for his latest album, but the results are anything but predictable, writes Kitty Empire

Kitty Empire

10, Feb, 2013 @12:05 AM

Article image
Richard Thompson: 'I had to put the pen down, take a deep breath, have a little cry'
The folk-rock pioneer has finally written his memoir, covering a life-changing crash and his fiery romance with Linda Thompson

Jude Rogers

14, Mar, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Richard Thompson: Still review – characteristically stormy
Producer Jeff Tweedy brings extra texture to a fine set from the folk rock master

Neil Spencer

28, Jun, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
Richard Thompson's famous fans choose their favourite songs
Admirers from Robert Plant to Rachel Unthank pick the tracks from the master songwriter that mean most to them

The Observer

14, Mar, 2021 @7:00 AM

Richard Thompson: Dream Attic | CD review
Richard Thompson's decision to record his latest album live is a masterstroke, says Neil Spencer

Neil Spencer

21, Aug, 2010 @11:06 PM

Article image
Richard Thompson review – rock’n’rolling back the years
Half a century after his first gig with Fairport Convention, folk-rocker Richard Thompson is as cool and contemporary as ever

Jude Rogers

12, Aug, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
CD: Richard and Linda Thompson, In Concert November 1975


Robin Denselow

02, Aug, 2007 @11:10 PM

Acoustic Classics review – Richard Thompson gives a bravura performance
Most of these songs are still best in their original form, but the English folk veteran's years of experience shine through, writes Neil Spencer

Neil Spencer

12, Jul, 2014 @11:01 PM

Article image
Why Richard Thompson is keeping the faith
As he prepares to curate this year's Meltdown festival, Richard Thompson reflects on his personal journey from the frontiers of English folk to the haven of Sufi Islam, the tempestuous years with his ex-wife, Linda, and how it feels to be rubbished in song by his children. By Tim Adams

Tim Adams

10, Apr, 2010 @11:05 PM