Musicians fear reprisals for speaking to MPs' streaming inquiry

Select committee warns music platforms against interference after witnesses say careers put at risk

A Commons select committee has warned that no one should interfere with its inquiry into the economics of music streaming, after witnesses expressed fear that speaking up could harm their careers.

The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) committee is examining the effect of services including Spotify and Apple Music on the wider music industry, and has already heard evidence from recording artists including Guy Garvey of Elbow, Ed O’Brien of Radiohead, and the singer-songwriter Nadine Shah.

But the committee chair, Julian Knight MP, has warned that further testimony was limited by the fear of retaliation. “We have been told by many different sources that some of the people interested in speaking to us have become reluctant to do so because they fear action may be taken against them if they speak in public,” Knight said.

“I would like to say that we would take a very dim view if we had any evidence of anyone interfering with witnesses to one of our inquiries. No one should suffer any detriment for speaking to a parliamentary committee and anyone deliberately causing harm to one of our witnesses would be in danger of being in contempt of this House.

“This committee will brook no such interference and will not hesitate to name and shame anyone proven to be involved in such activity.”

In November, Nadine Shah told the committee: “Speaking on behalf of many of my friends, my fellow musicians, so many of them are scared to speak out because, myself included, we do not want to lose favour with the streaming platforms, and we do not want to lose favour with the major labels. You called me brave, some have called me stupid, but I am used to it.”

Tom Gray, of Gomez, the founder of the #BrokenRecord campaign who gave evidence at the committee, said the revelation was not a surprise to him. “I don’t think it’s incredible at all. If you go back through all of the evidence about young artists being afraid to come forward or what Nadine Shah said – ‘My friends say I’m stupid’ – nobody was fucking joking.”

He added: “There’s genuine jeopardy here for artists. There’s only one mode of selling music any more and that one mode controls everything in an artist’s life: their remuneration from the recorded works, their exposure to new audiences, their continuing relevance. These aren’t small things for an artist, it’s basically our world.”

Streaming services hold an enormous amount of power over artists, with the ability to grant or deny promotion through placement in playlists, on homepages and on algorithmic “radios” proving pivotal in the success of new music.

Last month, Spotify made that power explicit, offering artists the ability to artificially promote their music on the company’s artist radio feature, which plays songs similar to a given band. Acts who signed up to the “experiment” would have a selected song added to the artist radio more often – but would be paid a lower royalty rate in exchange. “This a form of payola or sponsored social media post,” said David C Lowery, the singer-songwriter in Camper Van Beethoven. “It is not necessarily illegal but the tracks would need to be labelled.”

Spotify did not reply to requests for comment.


Alex Hern and Lanre Bakare

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Digital streaming behind biggest rise in UK music sales for two decades
Platforms such as Apple Music and Spotify plus renaissance in vinyl records help fuel fastest annual growth since 1998

Sarah Butler

03, Jan, 2018 @12:01 AM

Article image
Record sales: vinyl hits 25-year high
LP sales up by 53% on 2015 after deaths of many music greats throughout the year and a trend for returning to ‘tangible music’

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

03, Jan, 2017 @8:59 AM

Article image
Paul McCartney and Kate Bush lead call for change to music streaming payments
Open letter to Boris Johnson signed by 156 musicians including Led Zeppelin and Annie Lennox aims to reword 1988 Copyright Act

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

20, Apr, 2021 @1:25 PM

Article image
MPs to examine impact of streaming on future of music industry
Culture committee chair Julian Knight said it would investigate whether the business models used by major streaming platforms are fair to writers and performers

Laura Snapes

15, Oct, 2020 @11:58 AM

Article image
Here, there and everywhere: Beatles songs to be streamed for first time
Fab Four’s full catalogue will make Christmas Eve debut on Spotify, Apple Music, Google Play and Amazon Prime, ending long streaming site holdout

Stuart Dredge and Peter Walker

23, Dec, 2015 @11:04 AM

Article image
Slipping discs: music streaming revenues of $6.6bn surpass CD sales
Popularity of services such as Spotify outstrips traditional formats for first time

Mark Sweney

24, Apr, 2018 @12:50 PM

Article image
Music streaming hailed as industry's saviour as labels enjoy profit surge
Some record labels have had their biggest rise in revenue in over a decade thanks to services such as Spotify and Apple Music

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

29, Dec, 2016 @2:09 PM

Article image
Modern mix tapes: the Guardian's new monthly playlist
As streaming becomes more popular, we want to help readers better navigate the huge number of new releases and make rewarding discoveries, writes the Guardian’s music editor

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

09, Sep, 2017 @9:56 AM

Article image
UK Top 40 singles chart to include video streaming figures
Tally will take in Apple Music, Spotify, YouTube and Tidal, while streams from free and paid-for services will no longer be weighted equally

Eamonn Forde

24, Jun, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
YouTube to launch new music streaming service
YouTube Music will replace Google Play Music and take on Spotify, Apple Music and Tidal

Laura Snapes and Mark Sweney

17, May, 2018 @10:26 AM