Carmen review – WNO unleashes free spirit on Brazil's favelas

Wales Millennium Centre, Cardiff
A frenetic mix of gunrunners, drug gangs and slum workers assail feisty mezzo Virginie Verrez in Jo Davies’s interpretation of Bizet with added feminist verismo

Anyone expecting a blaze of colour evocative of sunny Spain and the fiery temperament of Bizet’s femme fatale gets it in the brilliant hues of the front cloth, but for barely two minutes. With the first note of the ominous death theme, the apparently vibrant start to Welsh National Opera’s new season gives way to a dismal scene. Director Jo Davies transposes the opera to Brazil circa the 1970s, ostensibly taking a feminist stance and posing the #MeToo question: why should Carmen have to die for the crime of being a rebellious free spirit, craving love yet refusing to be trapped by a man and caged?

Leslie Travers’ design has a curve of tiered galleries looking into a courtyard, creating a slummy favela of sorts, the elements of garrison guard, arms- and drug-smuggling and factory workers as though randomly imposed. It is possible to work out a vague rationale, but the scenario feels a contrivance, with layer upon layer of frenetic business supporting the concept but incidental to the music. Dance is another distraction: a female clad in black is the figure of death shadowing Carmen, taking attention away from focal dramatic moments, as when the cards predict what she already perceives as her inevitable demise.

In the title role, Virginie Verrez is feisty, with an impressive vocal presence, her native French allowing the words to emerge clearly, though somehow falling short of being the personification of Carmen. Dmitri Pittas’s Don José matches her in volume, but is too forceful of tone to elicit sympathy for his obsession, while Phillip Rhodes has the swagger to be an Escamillo plausible enough to merit the transfer of Carmen’s attentions.

WNO’s musical director Tomáš Hanus ensures that the true passion flows from the pit, treating Bizet’s wonderful instrumental lines with as much respect as those of the singers and arguing a case for the score to be heard as a prototype for the realism of verismo. But, ultimately, this is a staging where the directorial add-ons don’t amount to an overall gain in the operatic experience.

• At the Wales Millennium Centreon 28 September, 6/10 October. And touring.

Contributor

Rian Evans

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Carmen review – an unappealingly coarse lead
Alessandra Volpe is less than thrilling in the title role of the WNO’s stab at Bizet, but some of the support throws new light on the opera, writes Rian Evans

Rian Evans

21, Sep, 2014 @2:25 PM

Article image
Daniel Kramer: Carmen, I've cracked you

When Daniel Kramer took on the job of directing Bizet's opera, he faced a huge challenge: how to make this old war horse feel fresh? He relives his tussles with the Gypsy

Daniel Kramer

12, Jan, 2011 @9:31 PM

Article image
Bizet: Carmen – review
It's a shame that married couple Simon Rattle and Magdalena Kožená aren't more daring in Bizet's hot-blooded opera, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

12, Sep, 2012 @2:59 PM

Article image
Les Vêpres Siciliennes review – theatricality and spectacle in Verdi's grand opera
Conductor Carlo Rizzi and Welsh National Opera’s chorus and orchestra give the ear much to savour, but the voices disappoint in David Pountney’s new production

Rian Evans

10, Feb, 2020 @10:57 AM

Article image
Un Ballo in Maschera review – terrific gory fun with pirates, witchcraft and murder
A Swedish king rises from his coffin in David Pountney’s playfully vamped up staging of Verdi’s opera, supported by exceptional principal performances

Rian Evans

10, Feb, 2019 @5:31 PM

Article image
La Forza del Destino review – sprawling saga brought into sharper focus
Wonderful singing, Carlo Rizzi’s immaculate conducting and David Pountney’s dramatic staging bring welcome clarity to Verdi’s implausible piece

Andrew Clements

04, Feb, 2018 @11:11 AM

Article image
Carmen review – Bizet meets Busby Berkeley
Big numbers and bohemian loucheness characterise Barrie Kosky’s uneven production

Tim Ashley

07, Feb, 2018 @12:06 PM

Article image
War, peace, and everything between: the best classical music of autumn 2018
WNO takes on Tolstoy, Lothian’s other festival grows in stature, and Gershwin pays a visit to the Coliseum

Andrew Clements

27, Aug, 2018 @5:01 AM

Article image
Il Prigioniero/Fidelio review – inspired pairing probes depths of good and evil
The rising tension in Welsh National Opera’s double bill addressing the abuse of human rights across the world was deeply disquieting

Rian Evans

16, Jun, 2019 @2:34 PM

Article image
The top 10 classical shows of 2017
A magisterial Monteverdi cycle, Oliver Knussen’s adventures in haiku – and a hero’s return for Simon Rattle. Our critic picks his highlights

Andrew Clements

18, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM